The Indenture of Edward St Ives
By
Chapter 1 April, 1944
The limousine wound its way thru the dark streets of London, made even darker by a light fog, which had set in about three hours earlier. The driver no doubt would have had difficulty finding his way, if he had not been to this same address many times before. The two passengers in the back seat were thankful for that and for the fog, because the skeletons of the bombed-out buildings, silhouetted against a moonlit sky, would have been truly depressing.
The few buildings left standing on both sides of
the street were sandbagged almost to the curb. Pedestrians using the sidewalks
during the daylight hours had to walk single file or walk on the edge of
the street. This made for hazardous driving conditions, particularly in this
up-scale part of the city, where the streets were narrow and the traffic
was at its heaviest.
The Blitz had come and gone but the rocket sites
on the northern end of the continent had not yet been destroyed, so there
was a continuing need for the population to pack inside the bomb-shelters
every night. The city was far from normal. There was still a blackout. And
the headlamps from the few automobiles on the streets were still painted
over to let only a small sliver of light shine thru. It was just barely enough
to be seen by another driver, while completely invisible from the air.
Petrol was heavily rationed, so there was little
civilian traffic, except for the occasional taxi. The taverns were closed
at this late hour and only a few night workers could be seen hurrying to
their places of employment. Viewed altogether, the city exuded something
of a sense of peace and tranquility. But this was superficial, because there
were still the rockets that could be heard exploding with far more force
than that experienced by aerial bombs. And the wail of the fire trucks racing
thru the streets could be heard from dusk to dawn.
Deep down, the feelings of the citizens were running
at fever pitch. The cause for this concern, beyond that of the falling rockets,
was the long awaited Invasion, which at long last appeared to be imminent.
Although they were unaware, it was this very subject that had brought the
two-limo passengers out at this late hour. Actually, they did not know why
they were out; save they had been summoned to the residence of the Prime
Minister for lunch.
Most Britons might think of Winston Churchill as
something of an eccentric; but few would ever say so. Great Britain was a
Constitutional Monarchy. The seat of power lay with the Parliament and the
recognized leader was the Prime Minister. Never more so than now and never
more so than with this particular prime minister. So the term eccentric was
never used in describing him, for perhaps Britain had never had a more respected
leader in the long history of the Commonwealth than Churchill.
Still, lunch at midnight could hardly be viewed
as a commonplace affair, even in war torn Britain. But the two government
officials on their way to his residence hardly gave it a second thought,
when the invitation was extended for this late hour.
The limo pulled over to the curb at number ten
Downing Street and parked. The driver hurried around and opened the passenger
door where he was joined by two Royal Marine sentries. They had emerged from
covered guard posts secluded well inside sandbagged barricades. They were
dressed in full battle gear and each of them was equipped with a shouldered
Sten machine gun.
The first one stepped forward to take the identification
cards of the two passengers, which had been handed to the chauffeur. He immediately
retreated to the hidden light of the guard post where the cards could be
scrutinized. They were then handed back and the two passengers emerged from
the automobile. Both of the marines, who now recognized the occupants as
army officers, saluted, even though the two of them were in civilian clothes.
They walked toward the large oaken door that was the entrance to the residence.
When the door was opened from the inside, their credentials were again verified,
and then an Officer of the Royal Navy escorted them thru the hall leading
off the foyer.
A stairway led down three flights of stairs. They
chose to walk down rather than wait for the elevator, which would only accommodate
two of them at a time. On the ground floor they emerged into a large reinforced
bunker that contained some one hundred rooms. This was the command post and
wartime residence of the Prime Minister. They were led thru his conference
room into a private dining room, which contained a mahogany table and chairs
to seat eight people, with an additional half-dozen more lining the walls.
The escort then seated them at a table prepared for three people. A waiter
entered the room immediately and announced that Sir Winston would be with
them momentarily.
Precisely at midnight the
PM entered with an aide who was carrying a brief case. The aide set it down
and then pulled out the other chair and held it out for the Prime Minister.
He then whispered something out of earshot of the others and retired.
The two officers were cousins. They were also distantly
related to Churchill thru his dowager grandmother the Duchess of Marlborough.
The three were old friends from Cadet days at Sandhurst. Indeed, they had
all three served as sub-lieutenants in the same regiment in the Sudan, when
Britain interfered in an effort to subdue the Mahdi uprisings.
They were both of royal lineage and were now formerly addressed by Sir Winston as Lord Edward Wycliffe and Brigadier Anthony Gale, Earl of Dunston. Thereafter, they referred to each other as Eddy, Tony and Winnie as they had when they were young men at school.
Churchill began the conversation by asking them
if it was all right if he ordered for them. “Our chef prepares an excellent
sole,” he said. “I’m sure you will be pleased.” The other two recognized
the comment as being a polite way of saying that perhaps it was all that
he had to offer. Certainly the Nations leader could have had anything he
wanted to eat. But he wanted them to understand that he ate what the common
man ate. And as his guests, they were expected to do the same.
Churchill often invited guests to his quarters
at night. He disliked eating alone. And then too, it gave him a welcome respite
from the heavy burden of government and the loneliness of his quarters. But
he found it difficult to relax completely, because the war was usually not
too far from his mind. Tonight was to be no exception. It was no coincidence
that his two guests were from British Intelligence. Wycliffe was head of
MI-5 and Dunston commanded the overseas division known as MI-6.
He apologized for the late hour and for the disruption
of their routines. “I used to work during the day like normal people.” He
said. “But then what is normal these days. I never evacuated to the Underground
like everybody else when the war started. I tried it once but then I was
just too tired the next day. After we built this place, I had my bed moved
over here near the war room. Then I found that I couldn’t sleep because of
the bombs. Now it’s the rockets. I became a night owl. Now I’m afraid I have
a habit that won’t be easily broken.”
They chatted amiably for a few minutes, as old
friends were wont to do. But the officers were reluctant to lead the conversation
into any serious subject, because time would not permit. They both knew Churchill
had something on his mind. And they both knew from years of experience in
his company that he often arrived at what he wanted to say by a very circuitous
route.
“Do you recall the first
battle of the Somme,” he said, not expecting an answer. Both of them had
served honorably in that terrible war and both of them had been in the meat
grinder known as the Somme from early in July until November of 1916. It
was not likely that anybody who was there would have forgotten one horrible
moment spent in the trenches. Churchill knew this having served for a brief
period on the Western Front. It was just his way of beginning the journey
toward the point he intended to make. And they both knew he intended to take
every minute of the time scheduled for lunch before he made it. And they
were both equally sure when it was made that it would require some action
on their part.
“Recall how Dougie made a perfect mess of things?”
He had reference to another personal friend of theirs, Lieutenant General
Sir Douglas Haig. And in particular, how much of the British Expeditionary
Force under his command was squandered in the face of German machine guns.
Haig had engaged in maneuvers inland of the French
coast for several weeks before he made up his mind where he wanted to commit
the BEF against the entrenched Germans. When he did make up his mind, he believed
an overwhelming artillery attack would render the German infantry helpless.
His forces would then prevail along a seventy-mile front. But instead of
a victory, which might have ended the war, it would come to be known as the
worst defeat ever suffered by British arms.
The artillery did not have the expected effect
on the morale of the German soldiers. They hunkered down inside well-fortified
bunkers and rode out the barrage that lasted for days. Neither Haig nor his
advisors believed any human could withstand such a shelling. But the Germans
did. Then when the British advanced across “no mans land” under a “rolling
barrage;” they were met by withering machine gun fire.
One of Haig’s problems was lack of communications.
His shells had cut his own telephone lines. When this happened, his officers
at the front of the advancing troops could not advise him of the situation.
Wave after wave was cut-down, as those in the rear, unaware of what was happening,
continued to advance. And the few who made it to the German trenches were
impaled on the wire, which had remained intact.
Finally, after some seventy thousand men were lost,
the majority in the first twenty minutes, the attack was halted. It was not
stopped by Haig, who was at his Headquarters miles to the rear, but by junior
officers. They risked being court-martialed for cowardice. But if they had
not taken matters into their own hands and disobeyed orders, most of the
British Army would have been lost. As it was, the lines on the Somme were
stretched very thin. And had the Germans been fully cognizant of the lack
of British reserves, the war might have been lost there and then.
Something drastic had to
be done or all might still be lost. They expected that it would take the
German Secret Service just a few weeks to discover the true nature of the
situation.
“You know Eddie that organization
of yours was in its infancy. But I truly believe that the scheme they came
up with on the spur of the moment saved us all.” Churchill was talking, as
he looked up at the waiter.
Just in case the details
might have been eroded by time, he intended to spend the next few minutes
rehashing the events. Not only did it appear that this almost forgotten part
of military history played a major role in the affairs of the Nation at that
time; but it may well be the basis for another plan that was churning around
in the active mind of their friend and superior.
“I am a firm believer in military intelligence.
I have seen many a battle, and so have the two of you, that hinged on a commander
knowing what to expect from the enemy. But there is an equally important
side of your work. It was paramount then and might well be so today as we
approach the time for Invasion.”
So that was it then. They
were both thinking the same thing as they glanced knowingly at each other.
But why did he not come right out and tell them what was on his mind? Because
they both knew it was not his way. And they both knew he did not intend to
interfere with the details of their work by telling them exactly what he wanted.
“We were in a sorry state
in those days.” He said. Churchill had taken several bites of the sole, which
he found to his liking, and he was beginning to warm up to his subject. They
both knew he liked nothing better than to talk. And they enjoyed listening
to him. He did have a way with words, although he was not known to get to
the point quickly. He was famous for this, much to the consternation of some
ranking military officers. General Eisenhower would say of him, after their
meeting with Stalin at Casablanca, that he thought he would drive them all
to distraction with his convoluted approach to a problem. And he did have
a penchant for monopolizing the conversation, which bored the American to
distraction.
Churchill was a maverick who had a reputation for
conducting warfare by what had been termed “strategy by impulse.” Indeed,
his Chief of Staff would write, “he had ten ideas a day and only one of them
was any good. But I was always at a loss to know which was which.”
The Prime Minister continued on with his story:
“We had no idea what we were going to do. We expected the Germans to find
out we had only a few reserves left. And when they did, they were going to
take maximum advantage of the situation. That’s where your gang came in Eddie.
Misdirection is the name of the game. You two lads know it well and are famous
for it, I might say.
“We only had two divisions
of infantry left here in London. What we did have, we decided to use in a
little game of Three-Card Monte with the Germans. We knew they had spies
all over the place and we intended to take full advantage of the fact, if
we could.
“Remember when we loaded
all the troops into covered lorries and transported them up north. And then
we put them on trains and headed them back south again. We off-loaded them
at Waterloo Station. And then we put them on lorries and sent them down to
the debarkation points. We did this during the day so the Germans could watch
us. We even went so far as to have the men march aboard the ships waiting
to transport them to the front. After the bands stopped playing and the women
stopped waving, and when we figured the Germans were in their schnapps, we
quietly moved them off the ships again. Then in single file, we route-stepped
them about two miles inland in the dark. Sometimes we hauled them back by
lorry and sometimes by train. Anything we could think of to keep the Germans
guessing, we did. After the troops had a short rest we had them do it all
over again. I have no idea how many trips back and forth some of them made.
But I remember hearing from relatives that some of the tuba players in the
bands at Waterloo and on the quay got awfully tired.”
The three friends began laughing at the charade
they remembered so long ago. And then Dunston grew more serious as he said,
“You know Winnie, some of those boys did yeoman duty during those crucial
months. They were far more valuable to us here than they would have ever
been in France.”
Lord Wycliffe looked up from his plate and wiped
his mouth with his napkin. And then he began to chuckle all over again.
“It worked.” Churchill said.
“It fooled the Germans into believing we had virtually an army of reinforcements.
And it gave us about a three-month respite that we would not have enjoyed
otherwise.”
“Indeed it did,” replied
Wycliffe, giving the appearance that the three of them were having a luncheon
conversation and not listening to a military briefing, which they were. “It
gave Kitchener the time he needed to conscript and train a whole new Army.”
He volunteered.
“Yes, now the opportunity
for another little Monte game might be in the offing.” Churchill said this
with a twinkle in his eye as he stood up and motioned for the two of them
to join him in the conference room. What he had to say to them next was of
the highest security classification. And then it was only discussed in the
presence of those who had a clear need to know.
When he had personally secured
the sound proof door behind him, he said, “That scheme you worked out with
the Americans, Eddie, is paying dividends, I’m talking about the one where
you have that fake army poised to strike them across the straight at Pais
de Calais.”
During one of the battles
for the so-called “soft under-belly” of the continent, General George Patton’s
forces underwent a severe shelling. Later, the General chose to make one
of his frequent inspections to a field hospital. He was there, as much as
for anything else, to show his support for the wounded and to award some medals
for valor.
After he placed a medal on a wounded and unconscious
soldier’s pillow, the General kneeled and whispered something into his ear.
When he stood-up, he noticed what appeared to him to be a perfectly healthy
soldier sitting on the edge of his bunk. He asked the man what was wrong
with him. The soldier began crying and said he could not take it any more.
When Patton asked him what it was he could not take, the soldier replied
that he could not take the shelling any longer. Words were exchanged with
the soldier and the medical staff accompanying him. Patton became enraged.
And during a tirade about cowardice, and his disapproval of the soldier being
quartered with those he referred to as “these brave men,” Patton slapped
him.
The medical staff had just suffered a tongue lashing
at the hands of the General. When he left, they were still smarting and were
eager to report what had just happened. The story found it’s way to the Supreme
Commander, General Dwight D. Eisenhower. And within hours, he had given orders
to have Patton relieved of his command.
Patton was returned to England where Eisenhower
believed he could more easily control his precocious field commander. There
was no doubt about it, he was the best the American Army had to offer; but
he was unpredictable. This fact did not go unnoticed by the German High Command.
Field Marshall Erwin Rommel immediately suspected
some kind of trick. He could not believe Eisenhower would relieve his best
combat commander over such a trivial matter. His suspicions, and those of
Adolph Hitler, were confirmed when Patton was given command of the newly
formed Second Army. But the Second Army was not an Army at all; it was a
sham, dreamed up by Lord Wycliffe and his American associates.
Construction of a typical army installation had
begun six months earlier. Steadily, it increased in size as the expected
time of the Invasion drew near. It was complete with water tanks, barracks,
streets and even a baseball diamond. It was calculated to make the Germans
believe it was an American Army forming for a massive assault across the
Channel.
Wycliffe had spared no expense
or effort in making his creation look real. The best artists and special
effects technicians that could be found in the American movie industry assisted
him. There were columns of tanks massed on the outskirts of the camps. And
fighter aircraft of all descriptions were deployed next to landing strips.
They had constructed roads leading from the main arteries. And they had even
built railroad spurs from the main lines to warehouses on the base. But it
was one gigantic mock-up. Nothing was real. Everything was made of canvass
and wood.
The problem was it looked too real. Although the
Allies enjoyed air superiority, they were still bothered by the occasional
fighter-bombers making strafing and bombing runs. They gauged the effectiveness
of their work by the number of times it was struck and by how often they
had to effect repairs. They repaired it often. So realistic was it that German
photoreconnaissance interpreters believed it was the main invasion force.
Communications were set up between Eisenhower’s
Headquarters and the new “Headquarters” of George Patton. But instead of
an actual army discussing the routine problems of maintenance and supply,
there were only a few communication technicians, who were acting out parts.
It was not only the British and the Americans that
practiced this kind of subterfuge; the Germans had their successes as well
but not on such a large scale. Churchill, who liked a funny story, stopped
in mid-sentence to tell them just such a tale that was apropos to the subject:
“I heard this the other day at a staff meeting
with the Americans. It seems the Germans had built a fake aerodrome, with
accompanying fake airplanes, off the coast of France. It accomplished what
they wanted it to do all too well. Our aircraft strafed and bombed to their
hearts content and each day it was put back together again. And then we detected
a mistake of some kind or other that gave the show away. Instead of laying
on a high altitude raid by the American bombers that would have blown it
to kingdom come, our lads were good sports. They made a final low-level bombing
run. But this time it was with wooden bombs.”
The resulting laughter of the three of them served
to break the tension that had been building since the subject of invasion
had come up.
“Gentleman,” said Churchill, “Rommel and Von Runstedt
actually believe the Invasion is coming from a point here on the Channel.
They believe it, because this is where our previous ill-fated effort at Dunkirk
was launched. And of course, this is where the French beaches are easily
accessed. And it is the shortest distance between here and there. But, moreover,
that is where Hitler believes it is coming.
“I need not go into the
details of the two or three elaborate schemes the two of you have engineered
to make him think so. Suffice it to say his astrologers and soothsayers of
various stripes have also agreed with his military professionals in this
respect. But my friends, that is not where it is coming. It is coming at
Normandy. Just when, I am not at liberty to tell even you.
“But what we must do is
to continue to reinforce this mind-set of theirs. We must make them so certain
of what they now believe that several days after the actual landings at Normandy
they will continue to tell each other the main thrust is still coming from
Pais de Calais. They must believe that Normandy is only a large-scale raid
designed to draw off their defensive units.
“We know from capturing the ”Enigma” code machine,
that Von Runstedt, at Hitler’s insistence, has withdrawn Field Marshall Model’s
Tenth Panzer Army from the Eastern Front and stationed them equal-distant
between Pais de Calais and Normandy. This way he can strike in a timely manner,
once the main attacking force has been determined. If they guess right, and
the panzers are released before we breakout, our forces at Normandy will
no doubt be driven back into the sea at a tremendous loss of life.” Churchill
paused for a few seconds to pour his guests a glass of port. Dunston took
this opportunity to seek permission to ask a question.
“Why if we know where the Panzer Army is, do we
not destroy it now?” he asked Churchill.
“Because,” he answered,
“we would lose one of our most important assets. I refer to the “Enigma“
machine I was just talking about. So the goal then is to keep the Germans
from deploying those tanks until it is too late. And that is where you lads
and the Americans come in. And the Resistance fighters and the Free French,
as well, I suppose.
“If we could get them to
keep their eyes on the face card, and since we know where it is at all times,
we would have them where we want them,” he said.
“Sometime when we have time,
I will tell you about the fair that my father took me too when I was a boy.
He explained to me how the Monte dealer used the cards to shill the spectators.
He didn’t rely as much on slight of hand as he did on misdirection. He used
their knowledge of what they thought they had seen to make up their minds.
And by looking clumsy, he made it look simple. They looked to the obvious.
Everyone just knew where the face card was. And once their minds were made-up,
they were seemingly unable to change them. That’s why they lost, consistently.
“And that is why you my
friends, with your knowledge and understanding of the true facts and the
vagrancies of human nature, are in a unique position to euchre them out of
a victory once again.” With that last statement, Winston stood up. It was
a signal that his time was up. He had pushed a buzzer underneath the table
and a waiter opened the massive door and entered with their coats and hats.
Back in the limo, the two rode silently for some
time. Each was engrossed in his thoughts. Then Dunston spoke, “Eddie, I have
to confess to being naive, but I have never actually seen that game played
have you?”
“No, but I assume it is
akin to the pea in the shell game.” Wycliffe said. “The operator moves the
shells around a few times so that the observers can keep their eyes on the
shell containing the pea. He relies on them seeing it at the outset and then
following it with their eyes. It looks so simple that they sometimes stand
in line to place their bets. Once they make up their minds to what they see,
they are reluctant to change. And that’s the point Winston was making. The
Germans have concluded the Second Army is the invasion force and come hell
or high water they are not going to change”
Dunston spoke again. “Our job then is to keep this
idea reinforced in their minds. They must not be allowed to look away from
the pea, or the face card in the Monte game, which is actually the Second
Army.
“Let’s meet tomorrow for lunch,” Dunston said.
“Get some sleep and then lets talk some more about how we can cause the Germans
to lose their knickers. And we just might have their ‘guts for garters’ in
the bargain.”
__________________________
The American Air Base at Polebrook, just northeast
of London, was the home of the 379th Bomb Group. They were the first of those
deployed to the United Kingdom and had, perhaps, some of the most experienced
aircrews in the Army Air Corps.
One of their aircraft commanders was lounging on his bunk reading a magazine. It was 1000 hours and the sky was overcast with a heavy rain and fog. It was one of those rare days they could not fly and they were taking a much-needed rest from combat.
The door opened to the Quonset
hut, which housed a number of the Group’s officers. An orderly they recognized
from the Commanding Officers office stepped inside and inquired of a Captain
St Ives.
St Ives stood up and asked
him what he wanted. “Sir,” he said, “the Colonel would like to see you.”
St Ives put on his raincoat. As he moved towards the door, he received some
gentle chiding from some of the others, who were inquiring about what kind
of trouble he had gotten himself into.
He took a bicycle from the rack next to the metal
building and pumped the half-block thru the mud and water to Headquarters.
He hung up his coat and hat and combed his hair and then knocked on the Commanding
Officers office door. A voice from inside told him to enter. He walked in
and crossed the small office to a desk where the Commander was sitting. He
was talking to another officer of the same rank, whom the Captain did not
recognize.
St Ives saluted and was asked to take a seat. He
was introduced to the visitor, who was a representative of the Division Commander
at the next higher Headquarters known by the radio code name as “Pinetree.”
“Captain,” the visitor said, “I am in a hurry to
get back before it starts raining so I’ll get straight to the point.” He
said this with a smile on his face.
“I have been talking to
Colonel Armstrong here and he informs me that you are one of his best officers.
Your record indicates you are a graduate of the Military Academy and as such
you are one of us. And always, as you know, we are expected to lead out. And by that I mean we are expected to show the way by
accepting those assignments which might not be the most desirable. But I
have been directed to tell you that the assignment you are going to be asked
to take now is extremely hazardous. At the risk of seeming melodramatic,
I want to tell you the results of the up-coming Invasion might well rest
squarely upon your shoulders, if you elect to accept. You are, of course,
under no obligation to do so. Nobody is going to say or think the less of
you if you don’t. And whatever your decision, you are formally advised this
conversation must not go any further than this room. In fact, it never happened.”
“Of course I’ll do it,”
replied the Captain. What ever it was, he did not expect it would be much
more dangerous than flying bombing missions into Germany. Short of a suicide
mission, he did not see how it could be. And he knew Americans never required
this of anybody. He had said he would take the assignment without thinking
and now he could not easily change his mind.
“What is on anyway,” he asked?
“I am not at liberty to tell you, even if I knew,
which I don’t. But suffice it to say it is most important and of the highest
security classification. I want you to leave in the morning for London. That
is with your Commanding Officer’s permission of course,” he said.
Armstrong looked at them
both with an affirmative nod. It was a mere formality.
“You are to have dinner at the Savoy, where there
will be a room reserved for you. Don’t worry about the expenses. Major General
William Kepner’s Aide will pay for the dinner and the room. You will be the
General’s dinner guest at seven. He will tell you what he wants you to know.
If he wants you to stay in London for more than two days, you will advise
your Commander. When you return, you will brief him on only that part of
the mission necessary to get the job done. At all times it is on a need-to-know
basis. Colonel Armstrong understands this. No other member of this organization
will be told anything, other than that you have been given the customary
few days off after a long stint of combat. It must look like a routine rest
trip to London. Are we all clear on this?” He spoke with finality to his
voice, requiring no answer from either of the other two officers.
St Ives arrived at King’s Cross station in the
early afternoon and boarded the Underground. He then walked the few additional
blocks to the Savoy Hotel. This was one of the finer hotels in London with
a worldwide reputation. It was not available to the public, having been appropriated
by the Government for the duration of the war.
The Captain checked at the desk and found his reservation
was in order. The elevator had been purposely rendered inoperative, to prevent
an accident in the event the building was damaged from a near miss. He carried
his bag up the steps to the second floor suites. The rooms he was assigned
were perhaps as nice as any he had ever seen, let alone any that he had ever
occupied. As he set his overnight case on the floor and sat down on the velvet
sofa across from the bed, he began to think. The thing that had been bothering
him the most was how everything was working just as he had been briefed.
That indicated to him the mission really was of some importance. And by the
looks of his rooms now, he was surer than ever that it was. And then there
was General Kepner, the officer he was to have dinner with that evening. Kepner
was not just anybody. In fact, he asked himself as he sat there, why was he
meeting with such a high-ranking officer at all? True, the Hotel was not that
far from Eighth Air Force Headquarters at Bushy Park, so it was no big thing
for Kepner to meet him there for dinner. But to meet with a Captain was not
something Generals did without a very good reason and certainly not the deputy
to the Eighth Air Force Commander. This is one of the things that bothered
him. And why was he not instructed to meet him at his office? And what was
all the secrecy about, anyway? And why was he singled out to do this job,
whatever it was? And was he, perhaps, some kind of sacrificial lamb being
shown a taste of the good life before being led to the slaughter? These thoughts
were traveling around in his head, as he lay down on the bed. And then like
a good soldier, he took a nap, believing that in wartime, you should eat
and sleep whenever you had the chance.
That evening, he was seated at the General’s table
in the main dining room. He had only been there a few minutes when a Group
Captain entered and made his way to the table. St Ives stood up as the RAF
officer introduced himself. He told him he was one of two aides to General
Kepner. His chief duties, he said, as he sat down, was to function as a liaison
between the American military and components of the British Government. He
also informed him the General would not be dining with them; but rather he
would see him at a meeting at the British Home Office in the morning at 0900
hours.
During the course of their dinner conversation,
St Ives was told a staff car would pick him up in front of the Hotel at 0830
in the morning.
He had very little association with the British,
although he had been in their country for sometime. And he had almost none
at all with officers from the RAF. He admired them immensely, particularly
those who flew the fighter planes in the “Battle of Britain.” But he still
thought they were rather a stuffy lot. The Englishman, on the other hand,
had long since changed his mind about the stereotypical Americans being rustic.
This was due to his long association with men like General Kepner.
It took the two of them very little time to get
acquainted. And when they did they were well on their way to becoming good
friends. They spent the next two hours talking about things far from the
war. After he learned that the Group Captain knew nothing about why St Ives
was in London, they found other things to talk about.
They were both regular officers in their respective
services. Both had graduated from military academies and they were both near
the same age. They liked each others company and agreed to meet again the
first chance they had.
The staff car was waiting at the curb precisely
at 0830 the next morning. St Ives was hoping it would be late. He was still
looking for an indicator that maybe this assignment did not have the priority
he had been led to believe.
It took only a few minutes to reach the front entrance
of the large building, which was the Home Office. This is where much of the
important business of the British government was conducted. Just as he was
wondering where he was to go and what he was to do, he saw his friend from
the night before. They saluted and shook hands. And then St Ives was escorted
past the security checkpoints to a set of offices on the third floor. He
was instructed to enter and to tell the secretary inside the door who he
was. His friend did not linger but appeared to be in a hurry to depart. As
he did so, they reaffirmed their promise of the night before to meet again.
They had exchanged phone numbers and St Ives promised to give him a call
on his next trip to town.
But he still had a funny feeling in his stomach
that all might not be well. Indeed, as he watched his new friend depart down
the hall, he began to wonder if he was ever going to see London again.
The secretary was expecting him. He was given a
temporary identification badge and after signing some papers, he was escorted
thru some paneled halls and then into an impressive looking conference room.
There were three people seated at a long oaken table. One of them was an American
who was a Major General. St Ives assumed, of course, that he was General
Kepner. But who the two civilians were, he had no idea. He guessed rightly
that they were British. And now his curiosity was beginning to overcome the
feelings of apprehension, which had been bothering him.
St Ives suspected he ought to salute the General
but then he thought better of it as Kepner began speaking to him.
“Come on in Captain and have a seat right here.”
He said. “My name is Kepner and these two gentlemen are Lord Wycliffe and
Brigadier Gale, the Earl of Dunston. They represent the two branches of British
Intelligence. My purpose here this morning is to greet you and to run interference
for you, if need be. We must make sure you get everything you need to carry
out your mission, which you will be told about straight away.”
The gnawing feeling in his stomach had returned
and was getting worse. This operation did, after all, have the highest priority.
And he knew this kind of activity spelled danger. What had he gotten himself
into, he wondered? And why did he volunteer? But then he remembered, he had
had very little to say in the matter.
He expected the two Englishmen would outline the
program and then turn the details over to others to instruct him. Likewise,
he expected Kepner to depart after making the introductions. But when two
assistants entered the room with pots of coffee and tea, and another followed
carrying a tray of cakes of some sort, he knew they were here to stay. And
then it dawned on him why. It was security. That was it, the number of people
who knew about this thing, whatever it was, was sitting right here in this
room. And now he was really beginning to wish he had never gotten himself
involved.
“Captain,” the Earl said, “this job we want you
to take on is as important as any of the war, heretofore, and it is not without
danger. Unfortunately, we can’t tell you what it’s all about and then give
you a chance to volunteer. Once we have told you about it, I am afraid you’re
stuck with it old boy.
“We are in a game here. That’s what we do, my friend
Lord Wycliffe and I, we play a lot of games. True, the loser usually pays
a high price for losing. And it is unfortunate but the price for losing is
lives and not chips. That’s what makes it so different and so difficult,”
he said, as he paused while looking directly into the eyes of St Ives. Then
he began again. “Now we are in a game of trying to out guess our enemy. We
want him to think the main effort for the Invasion is not at Pais de Calais.
We will make several large-scale penetrations before we launch the main force.
Hopefully, we can keep him confused about which is which until it is too
late. By too late, I mean too late to deploy Model’s Panzer Army that is
waiting to counter attack. If he can bring it to bear against our actual
Invasion Army, I am afraid we might be looking at another Dunkirk or something
even worse.”
He stopped for a minute to let his guests digest
completely what he had just said. St Ives thought to himself, but only for
a second, that Dunston was something of an actor, who might be playing a
roll. But that was just what he was doing.
“You have flown over General Patton’s Second Army
many times I am sure.” Dunston said. “And I am also sure you have observed
each time you pass over, it has become more up to strength. Well, it is now
about ready to go. What we do not want the Germans to know, and I must say
that we do not want them to know at all costs, is that the Invasion is coming
from this point. All activity before and after will be a ruse. A feint, as
it were.”
While Dunston paused again to pour a cup of tea,
Wycliffe began to talk. “Captain what we have in mind is a little plan that
the two of us have put together. We want the Germans to stop believing that
General Patton’s Army is the main Invasion force. And I might add, only the
two of us have been involved in this little scheme. Even General Kepner is
hearing about it for the first time.”
“That is correct Captain,” Dunston interjected.
“It needs be this way to insure your safety. The last thing we want is for
this little party to be compromised. We don’t want it to backfire. And we
do want to bring you back safe and sound.”
That last statement did it. Now the cat was out
of the bag. St Ives mind had shifted into overdrive. He had concluded they
wanted him to cross over the channel and to do something. Something that
is going to cause the Germans to believe the main thrust is some place else,
while Patton drives right into their center with his Army. But why not a
“ground-pounder,” he wondered? And then it dawned on him; they want him to
fly an airplane over there and then somehow get it and himself on the ground.
How he was going to do it was the thing which had him worried, as he listened
to Dunston tell him more about what they had in mind.
“We want a bomber to crash land in France. We want
you to fly that bomber and then we want you to contact the French Resistance
and tell them the Invasion is actually coming on the Normandy coast. I know
you are asking yourself, why a bomber? Why couldn’t we just drop one of our
people with a parachute, or for that matter, why could we not just radio
them? These are all good questions. But we must do something out of the ordinary
to draw the Germans attention to you. Above all you must not tell them that
the real Invasion force is Patton’s Second Army.”
“You see Captain,” Wycliffe added, “we suspect
the Resistance has been penetrated by the Vichy. They will go straight to
the Germans with your information. When they do, the Germans will shift their
forces to repel an attack at Normandy. That should put the Tenth Panzers
out of position for at least twenty-four hours. By the time they realize
they have been fooled, General Patton’s Army will be off the beaches and
deployed well inland.
“It won’t be difficult to convince the Germans
you are legitimate, because they will see the aircraft and realize you survived
and are in the hands of the Resistance.” Wycliffe was going slowly now watching
for any signs that either of the two were becoming confused. “But why would
you be expected to know anything about Invasion plans?” He asked rhetorically?
“This is not something that an aircraft commander on a bombing mission is
privy to. And why would the subject even come up for that matter? The answer
has to be that we intentionally set up a scheme, whereby, you were there
for no other reason than to brief the Resistance.”
“It shouldn’t be too difficult to stage a scene
where the Germans capture you after they find out what you have told the
French.” Dunston said. “The fact of the matter is it would be difficult to
keep it from happening, given the political situation in the area where we
want you to land.
“We want them to interrogate you, which of course
they will. After you have given it your best effort to resist, you will tell
them the Invasion is coming over on the coast of Normandy. And that you were
not really on a bombing mission after all but fell out of formation purposely.
Tell them your real mission is to brief the French so they can get prepared.”
Wycliffe grew even more serious as he said, “Captain,
the key to this whole thing is to resist as long as you possibly can before
you tell them anything. They are going to rough you up a bit. And we expect
they will even threaten to shoot you if you do not tell them whether what
you have told the French is true. You must hold out to the end. We do not
believe they will shoot you, if you can act scared enough to convince them.
But try to wait until they do threaten your life before you start acting
like you’re very frightened.”
The General interrupted to ask a question. “What
is going to stop them from declaring that he is a spy and shoot him anyway?”
“That is the chance we have to take. But I don’t
think they will.” Dunston answered him. “We have taken it into consideration.
But our escape plan to get him away from them and back here will make that
point moot. He will be in uniform. They will check and find out, he is in
fact a bomber pilot, and then think twice before they accuse him of being
a spy. But they certainly will pay close attention to what he tells the Resistance,
else why is he there in the first place?”
“You see,” said Lord Wycliffe, directing his remarks
to Kepner, “while they are waiting for Berlin to digest the information he
has given the Resistance, we will have the needed time to put the machine
into gear to effect an escape. Trust us on this gentlemen, we are organized
to do this. As a matter of fact, we have done it before and more than a few
times.
“We want you to land right here with your wheels
up and with two of your engines feathered.” Wycliffe continued talking, as
he stood up and went to a sidewall and pulled down a map of France. “Please
note this exact location. You will want to plan on landing right here.” He
picked up a pointer and directed the Captain’s attention to a spot that had
been marked. When he was certain that St Ives and Kepner had the place firmly
in mind, he removed the marking pin.
“We will have British operatives waiting for you.
They will take you to the Resistance just like they would if you had really
lost two of your engines over England and had limped across the channel.
You will have, of course, jettisoned your bombs.” Wycliffe told them.
“Now this brings up the problem of your crew,”
said Dunston. “We want you to prepare just the way you do for any other mission.
Your crew must not suspect what is going to happen. This is most important,
because I can assure you the Germans will be watching. Anything out of the
ordinary will alert them. When they recap your mission, after they take you
into custody, they will be sure to pick-up on any deviation from the norm.
They will be trying to convince themselves that you are a set-up. And if
they do, they will not pay any attention to what you have to tell them.
“That is why everything must go just as it usually
does, right up until the time you give your crew the order to bail out. Yes,
we feel it’s the best way to go. You could land with them on board in France
but then what would they do. Their lives would needlessly be put in jeopardy.
And there is better than a good chance that some one of them might compromise
the entire program.
“Where and how you do this is of course up to you,”
the Earl continued. “We do suggest, however, that you run your engines up
before regular start engine time. Tell your crew chief that you thought two
of your engines were a little ragged on your last mission but that you forgot
to enter that fact in your maintenance forms. Then tell your co-pilot you
suspect something might be wrong. And that you have checked them out to make
doubly sure they are all right. The point is you want to be on record as
suspecting your engines. Rest assured this will be reported to the Germans
during their investigation.”
“This is very true,” said Wycliffe, “we know, and
so do you, that the Germans have spies everywhere. The daily news broadcasts
from Berlin attest to that. We all know this ‘Lord Haw Haw’ fellow is getting
his information from somewhere. We really don’t pay much attention to him.
We have not made a concerted effort to close him down, because he isn’t privy
to anything of real importance. But something like the status of your airplane
is right up his alley, to use one of your expressions.”
Dunston went on to say,
“we want them to believe we went to elaborate ends to get you into the hands
of the Resistance, therefore, what you have to say to them is of the utmost
importance. Do we all understand this?
“But I want to reiterate once more before we adjourn:
under no circumstances, even at the peril of your life, Captain, must you
tell them or even imply that the real thrust is coming from Patton’s Second
Army. If you do, you will put the entire invasion force in jeopardy and perhaps
allow the Russians to occupy all of Europe.
“Your job is to get the aircraft on the ground.”
Dunston went on to tell him, occasionally shifting his glance toward Kepner.
“Our job is to get you into the hands of the Resistance. And to get you back
safely. After you tell them your story, things will move rapidly according
to plan. We do not think for a moment that you are going to be in any extraordinary
danger. If you have any questions later we will be in touch with you and
maybe set-up another meeting in a few days.” With that said, the three of
them stood up and shook his hand. And after he saluted the General, he turned
and walked across the room and out the door while the others sat back down.
Kepner was the first to speak. “Gentleman, I have
some questions that’s for sure. What are we doing here anyway?” He said this
with an edge to his voice.
Dunston did not hesitate to answer him. “We thought
you might,” he replied. “The three of us know that Patton’s so called Army
is a ruse. But the Captain doesn’t know it. And we have it on good authority
that the Germans don’t know it either. I know that some of the things we
told him do not bear close scrutiny. And we did for sure pass quickly over
that spy business. But let me tell you the real plan.”
“Please do.” Said Kepner, who was now acting like
a General. In fact, Wycliffe and Dunston both felt for a minute as though
they were going to get dressed down by one who had a reputation for being
an expert in this area. Wycliffe, to ward off what they were both sure was
coming, hastened to get to the point.
“General, we don’t expect the Germans to swallow
any of the story he has been instructed to tell them.”
“Then what is the point of telling them...?”
“Please General let me explain,” said Wycliffe,
interrupting him.
“Captain St Ives believes Patton’s army is the
main strike force. The Germans are not interested in anything he has to say
about anything else.”
“Yes but they will torture him and more than likely
when he holds out to the bitter end they will shoot him.”
“Not really, General, because after they go through
the motions of interrogating him they will give him an injection of Scopolamine.”
“What is that?” He wanted to know.
“It is something new the bounders have developed.”
Dunston was quick to answer. “As best we can determine it is some kind of
a truth serum. They will give it to him and he will tell them every bit of
the truth. But it will be the truth, as he understands it. He will tell them
exactly what they want to hear: the main strike force is not landing at Normandy
but at Pais de Calais. But the three of us know that is not the truth.”
“Then that is why you were so sure they wouldn’t
shoot him. There would be no need too.” Kepner said. “In fact they might
even go out of their way to see that we get him back.” The two Englishmen
looked at each other knowingly as Kepner said this. Dunston wanted to tell
him he was quick to catch on. But he thought better of it and said nothing.
“Do they know you know they have this drug?” The
General asked.
“No, and that’s what makes the plan so workable.”
Dunston replied.
Three days after St Ives returned to his base,
Col Armstrong called him into his office to tell him the next mission laid
on by “Pinetree” was to be Bordeaux on the coast of France. That is all he
said. The fact he had been told to alert St Ives personally was a signal
to both of them. And Armstrong did not ask him what it meant. He knew he
would not tell him, even if he were to ask.
An hour later, St Ives was
in base operations looking at the maps kept there for the benefit of the
Group’s navigators. He helped himself to one of them and then without looking
at it, he departed. He climbed back on his bicycle and peddled out to the
revetment where his ground crew was working on his airplane. He asked the
crew chief if he could run up his number one and number three engines, after
telling him he forgot to enter the fact there might be something wrong with
them in the maintenance forms. He briefed the sergeant regarding his suspicions
about his engines and then climbed into the airplane and sat down in the left-hand
seat. With the crew chief listening to the engines, St Ives checked the magnetos.
The two of them observed the drop in RPM. He gave them both a final run-up
and then shut them down. Everything appeared normal to the crew chief, who
signed the maintenance write-up as “ground checked ok.” St Ives did not depart
the airplane immediately behind the crew chief but waited until he could
see him from his side window. Then he went back to the navigator’s compartment
and switched on the overhead light. He removed the map from his jacket and
rolled it out on the table. He observed the location of the docks at Bordeaux
and then drew a line from the target to the inland city of Château roux.
He then drew another line from Polebrook to intersect the line he had just
drawn. That would be the point where he left the formation, regardless of
the direction the Group was headed.
______________________________________________
Chapter 3 California, 1970.
As St Ives turned the corner and headed down the
street towards his house, he could not help but notice the leaves swirling
in the street behind him. It was as in the Santa Claus poem, he thought...“dry
leaves before the wild hurricanes fly, when they meet with an obstacle mount
to the sky”...Odd he thought, thinking about something like that. But more
and more, just just this sort of thing was distracting him; flashbacks mostly
to the last combat mission he flew during the war. He wondered if that was
what old age was all about? And would he eventually prefer the company of
his own mind to that of people in the real world?
He was becoming concerned about this constant daydreaming.
And he wondered if it had anything to do with the depression, which had been
bothering him for several months.
It was almost like a fugue. Yes, fugue was the
word he was looking for. The mind entered into a sort of hypnotic state called
a fugue sometimes when under a great deal of pressure, or if afflicted with
a mental illness. It was more absorbing and far more riveting though than
a daydream. And it lasted longer, he thought.
Recollection of this strange word prompted his
mind to race across time and distance to a court-martial, where he heard
it for the first time.
The chief pharmacist at a base hospital some twenty
years before claimed he could not remember how to fill prescriptions. The
hospital commander did not believe him and had him up on charges for malingering.
The defense maintained he had lapsed into a fugue, as a result of being under
severe stress from problems at home. In the end, however, he was convicted
and served time in the guardhouse.
Fascinating, how just now his mind was able to
recall the incident with such clarity, and to make the word association with
daydreaming, which he was almost sure were unrelated.
There was the usual number of parked cars in front
of his house, friends of his kids no doubt. He could see them as he turned
the corner. There was also his wife’s car and another belonging to somebody
else, parked in his driveway blocking his garage.
He could see them also and he could feel the anger
begin to build just as it always did. It never mattered how often he brought
up the subject of the garage and the gang of kids who seemed to live at his
place. No matter what he said or did, whether he coaxed, pleaded, or threatened,
his kids still took no notice of him.
It was as though he did not exist. And when he
raised his voice to press the issue and to instill some discipline into their
lives, his wife would take their side against his. As often as not, she would
verbally attack him in a way that was out of all proportion. And she was
prepared to escalate the argument to the point of threatening him with bodily
harm.
On those occasions when she started screaming,
he would escape to his bedroom, where he would read or watch television until
it was time for bed. Usually in the middle of the night, he would get up
and fix a sandwich. The sight of the dirty kitchen, with the unwashed dishes
and empty pizza boxes strewn about, would disgust him to the point where
he would spend the next hour or so cleaning-up before going back to bed.
It had been long in coming, because he did not
want to admit that they had failed as parents and as a family. But now, after
twenty-five years of marriage, he was prepared to believe things were never
going to change, unless he took some kind of direct action to change them.
Divorce was not an option, because of the unfavorable
settlement laws that affected the military husband. Some kind of counseling
was in order; but she would hear none of it. She liked things just the way
they were.
She had her bridge activities and her club activities
and something she called a tea once a week. From each of these time wasters,
she came home with a look about her of one who had been too near the flowing
bowl.
As long as there was sufficient money coming in,
so she could indulge her every whim, and as long as he kept out of her way,
and he made no demands on her whatsoever, she was happy.
He had long ago realized, and he had told himself
over and over of late, she and the children were nothing more than leeches.
And he believed they intended to continue on in this way for the rest of
their lives. But what truly frightened him was, because he was in the Service,
there was absolutely nothing he could do about it, and they knew it.
They had him. And in a real sense he was indentured
to them. He was their captive who was being held for ransom, a bond slave,
so decreed by the courts.
But even this was not what bothered him the most,
he told himself. What really deep down angered him, what grabbed at his gut
and would not let go, was the fact they had no respect for him.
They were not remotely aware
of the sacrifices he made during the war. He had tried to tell them many
times but they never would listen, they just did not care. It was as though
he never lived or accomplished anything. They held him and his life’s work
in the utmost disdain. That is what hurt. And that is why he would never forgive
them.
That is also why some direct action, something
in keeping with his real and not perceived nature, would be forthcoming.
And whatever the final plan would be, the operative word would be action;
something that would be decisive and never to be forgotten by them. And make
no mistake about it, he told himself; he had the resolve to carry it out.
Anybody who thought otherwise had badly misjudged him. And it would be easy
to do, because he had long ago ceased to care anything about any of them.
As these dark thoughts continued to occupy his
mind, he began to think about his last combat mission and how he had never
told his son about the role he played in successfully bringing about the
greatest military invasion in history. His destination had been the shipyards
at Bordeaux. When he saw the route from East Anglia to South Hampton and
then to Cherbourg, Le Mans, Limoge, and then approaching Bordeaux from the
North, he knew that his part of the plan was on. The route passed within
a few miles of the Chateauroux area. All he would have to do was to report
engine trouble and then make a long sweeping left turn to head home. But
he had no intentions of going home.
A few minutes before his Group reached the Channel,
he called to report the oil pressure on two of his four engines was fluctuating.
He told the group leader his crew was bailing out. But by the time he had
made up his mind to turn back, the engines were running smoothly and the
oil pressure had returned to normal. He advised his group leader that it
must be his instruments and not the engines and he radioed him he was continuing
on behind the formation.
He had never told her much of the story either,
about how he dropped his bombs over the Channel, and then reported engine
failure on two of his engines just after they reached the coast of France.
And she was only vaguely aware of his capture after he crash-landed near
Chateauroux. He tried to tell her once about what had happened; how he was
tortured, and finally forced to tell the Germans what he knew about the Invasion
coming at Normandy, as he had been instructed to do. She gave him an excuse
for not wanting to listen. She said the recounting of the event was too stressful.
She told him that talking about such things was not good for his depression,
which even then was beginning to bother him. And anyway the war was over,
she said, and he should forget about the whole thing.
His memory of that mission
had returned piecemeal over the years. Usually it was during one of his frequent
flashbacks. He would recall years later how the Germans had given him a shot
of something in a needle. They told him it was to prevent infection from
the many cuts and scrapes he suffered during the landing.
For the longest time, he thought this mission was
for naught. Because he knew he had told the Germans it was coming at Normandy,
which it did. He always wondered why he was told to tell them that thus jeopardizing
the element of surprise? Not until the world became aware of Scopolamine,
did he realize he had not given away the true Invasion plans after all? But
he had been drugged into telling the Germans only what British Intelligence
wanted them to hear?
In a way he was a hero. He was directly responsible
for causing the Fuehrer to hold the Tenth Panzer from attacking in support
of the Seventy-Six Panzer Division outside of Caen. As a result the Seventy-
Sixth was forced to break off the attack of the beachhead to keep from being
encircled and annihilated. As a result, the attacking infantry divisions
at Omaha finally made it ashore. And once inland, they were able to disburse
before the Tenth Panzer was allowed to deploy. By the time they did, it was
too late; and then American fighters and medium bombers quickly took the
panzers in hand. They never played a significant role in the battles that
followed.
Years later, he became aware of all of this. But
he was neither at liberty to divulge the secret role he played, nor that
of British Intelligence, to other people in the Service.
This situation weighed heavily on his mind. He
thought he was being penalized, somehow, for not completing his combat tour.
But he came slowly to realize as he was consistently being promoted ahead
of his peers, that men like General Kepner and Col. Armstrong remembered
his deeds and were looking out for him. He was most appreciative but it was
not the same thing. What he wanted as much as promotion was recognition from
his peers. And above all, he wanted some kind of recognition and appreciation
from his family.
_________________________________________
Edward St Ives, Colonel, USAF, son of a wealthy
Idaho potato grower, left his office late, as he did almost every night.
He did not stay because he was a workaholic like most of his colleagues but
stayed because he had no place else he wanted to go to. Lately, he had formed the habit of dropping by the Stag Room of the Officers
Club before going home.
This room was a new Club addition, a way of making
off-duty time spent on base less formal. It was a kind of sop tossed to aviators
to make the Service a little more attractive, in an effort to keep more of
them out of the cockpits of the major airlines.
The Stag Room, so called, really had no formal
name. The reason for this was to keep from offending some sensitive soul.
But even more important, it was to keep the base commander from coming to
the attention of some member of a congressional watchdog committee. So there
were no regulations restricting anybody from attending. But custom here,
as in so many other areas in the Service, dictated the rules.
Women were allowed. However, they were never in
attendance. Bachelors, who lived on base, and who did not care to don coat
and tie in the evening, were the most frequent visitors. Aircrews, who had
just landed from a long flight and were still in flying clothes, were also
welcomed. Then there was the occasional drop in by a senior officer, who
was welcome; but by custom would not stay long, because of the informality
of the place. His continuing presence might be seen as placing a damper on
the conversations.
So, Col. St Ives would order a beer, intending
only to stay for one. But truth be told, he would usually stay a little longer
than was customary. He ran the risk of indulging in this rather boorish behavior
for the simple reason he liked it there. Of all the places he could think
of, this is where he preferred to be. These were his real sons, these young
pilots. And he felt almost as close to some of them as any father would toward
a natural son in a well-adjusted family.
Talk was usually about aviation in some form. But
the only subjects forbidden, because of a time-honored tradition, were religion
and politics. Rank was strictly observed in these informal settings. To have
it otherwise would be to erode good order and discipline, so necessary for
the effective functioning of the organization. Everybody knew this without
being told or reminded. They were all professionals. They were in the Air
Force by choice and not because they had to be.
So, St Ives would attend for just a little while,
promising himself he would not over stay his welcome. But he hated to leave.
Each time he left, he wondered why he came in the first place, knowing that
just when he started to enjoy himself, he would have to go home.
He would go just about every evening for an hour
or so, telling himself that he was not really so much interested in socializing
with them, as much as he was there to get a feel for what they were thinking.
But he knew they were never candid and that they spoke to him as they might
to their own fathers.
As he drove towards home, he lapsed into one of
his typical reveries. He wondered what it would be like to have one of these
young officers for a son, instead of the one he had. They were the crème,
no question about it, he thought.
All of them were over-achievers. As far as he knew,
they were all university graduates. He did not know for sure but he thought
it was a requirement for flight training these days.
They were all patriots, every one of them. They
were drug free and goal oriented. Any father, he said to himself, would be
proud to call anyone of them, son.
As he drove home, he began to think about the routine
of a popular comic, “now you take my wife, please?”
“Yeah, and take my son too,” he whispered under
his breath. “Yeah, you can have him. I don’t want him. He lacks ambition
and he is little better than a bum.”
But as he ran on in his mind, sinking deeper and
deeper into his thoughts, he realized this was old ground he had covered
many times before. What he had not often thought about though, was why he
had such a strong kinship with these young officers. After going over the
many obvious reasons, his mind settled on one thought. He loved them for
the very exact opposite reason he hated his son and the rest of his family
too. These young men respected him. It was as simple as that, he told himself.
They saw in him, the man they wanted to become.
Each one of the medals he wore on his tunic meant something to them. They
imagined what it had been like, hour after grueling hour, in combat in the
skies over Germany and France. They were aware of the tremendous number of
casualties suffered in that air war. They also knew the Eighth Air Force
suffered more casualties among their officers than the total number of all
other branches of the Army fighting in the European Theatre.
In the beginning of the air war in Europe, it was
mathematically impossible to survive. Twenty-five combat missions were designated
as an arbitrary number for completion of a combat tour of duty. When he started
flying bombing missions, the average number accomplished was nine, before
being shot down.
Most of his close friends had been killed or crippled
outright, while others crash-landed, or jumped in enemy territory, sometimes
spending years in captivity, living on starvation rations.
And they knew this as well. And they afforded him
the respect he was due. But to his son, it might as well have happened to
a total stranger, who came from another world.
__________________________________________
Chapter 5
The
clan Saint Ives had its historical beginnings during the dark days of the
Middle Ages. They were Scotsmen who lived on the border of the area that
was given over to the Viking hoards as a homeland. But the English kings
did not turn over this land to the Scandinavians out of the goodness of their
hearts, rather; they did it to stop them from raiding along the Scottish and
the English coasts.
The Scots posed little threat to the Vikings. And in fact, they were quick to adopt some of their customs. One of the more important was their law.
The Viking law or Dane Law, as it would come to
be known, was much preferred by them over the English common law as pertained
to the passing of title to the land.
Dane Law held that the eldest son, under the rights
of primogeniture, inherited the land from his father. Second and third sons
remained at the suffrage of the eldest. But, since the farms were small,
and the land poor, it could not usually support more than one family. The
younger men, lacking other career opportunities, signed on-board the long
boats bound for England and plunder.
The English practice of land management was similar
but varied in one important aspect; the king owned the land. It was parceled
out to noblemen and then to serfs who worked it and paid taxes to the Crown.
These fiefdoms were a form of slavery and did not
sit well with the freedom loving and rebellious Scots. The English did not
always give the Scots the same latitude they gave the Vikings and it became
the cause for bitter struggles between the two, lasting for many generations.
Ongoing battles between the clans and the English
kings resulted in hatred for the English, and in many cases, displacement
of clan leaders. In many instances it was necessary for them to leave Scotland
for the New World. And even when a Scot was not under warrant, he often chose
to immigrate, if and when he got the chance.
Many emigrants, be they Scot or some other nationality,
moved west in fulfillment of the Nations “Manifest Destiny.” Thus in due
time, the great-grandfather of St Ives, a descendant of a displaced person,
found himself on the Oregon Trail.
Like most pioneers, the elder St Ives was looking
for land. Farm land in Idaho was there for the homesteading, to be shared
with Mormon pioneers, who were moving up from Utah Territory, to settle and
to form new branches of their Church.
Small homesteads were the rule at first, being
only as large as one family could work with a team of horses. But there was
nothing to prevent an enterprising farmer, with a growing family of sons,
from purchasing adjacent land. And as farming became more mechanized, larger
holdings began to appear. And the larger they grew, the more prosperous they
became.
Certain areas of Idaho were best suited to the
growing of potatoes. And as the big estates came into being, co-ops formed,
and some of the larger companies incorporated and expanded.
Within just a few short years, technology changed
the face of the potato industry. By the middle of the century, the backbreaking
labor that was so necessary in St Ives youth, was pretty much a thing of
the past.
By the 1960’s, large companies would contract for
land, and using machinery exclusively, would plant, harvest, process and distribute
potatoes to grocery stores. They were also able to ship frozen French fries
to fast food chains without their product ever being touched by human hands
In the 1930‘s, however, during the height of the
Depression, potato growers throughout Idaho and Utah were just getting by.
Tractors and other machinery were available to speed up production, and to
make the work somewhat easier, but the market was depressed and not many
farmers were in a financial position to buy them.
But the big problem to major expansion was labor.
At that time, no one had discovered a way of getting the potato from the
plowed ground, sort it, grade it, sack it and then load it. At least not
as cheaply as the farm laborer could do it.
At that time, potato farming was as backbreaking
as any labor to be found anywhere. It was to be avoided if at all possible
but for St Ives and his brothers, it was not possible.
Their working day, during the harvest, started
at five in the morning. First there were the chores, and then after a quick
breakfast, they were into the fields.
Their father would hitch-up the horses to the potato
plow and then start out well ahead of the pickers.
St Ives and his brothers would each take a row.
As the potatoes were plowed-up, they would bend over and fill a bucket. When
the buckets were full, they would pour them into a “gunnysack.” Then they
would bend over again and walking along stooped over, they would fill another
bucket and another and still yet another.
Bucket after bucket and sack after sack they crouched
along until they thought their backs would break. The hot sun beat down on
them but there was no let-up until about an hour before dark and then the
sacks would be hauled to the storage sheds. Evening chores would follow and
then a late supper and then to bed. All they had to look forward to for weeks
on end was another backbreaking day, followed by another, until the harvest
was in.
The Colonel often reminisced about those hard years
growing up and when he did, he thought about his son. And he would compare
him to the other male members of his family. His son was always found wanting
in the extreme.
Frankly, he told himself once, he could never remember
having seen his son do anything involving real labor. Not for a day, even
for an hour. He had never held anything remotely resembling a job and he
was incapable of understanding what his father’s youth had been like. Neither
did he want to know. Why should he, thought St Ives, it never involved him.
And as long as his mother was there to fend for him, it never would.
Working hard was for suckers. In fact, work, period,
was for suckers. He told his father this one day and it sent him into a silent
rage that lasted for a week.
When the Colonel’s father was nearing retirement
age, he visited a lawyer and had a family trust drawn-up. He was cognizant
of the need to pass on his estate to his sons as equitably as possible. He
was also aware of the many farms that had been sold-off because they had
been devised to several heirs in equal shares.
Then too, there was a case he knew of where the
eldest son, who had been doing most of the work for years, had been given
the largest share of the property as a reward. But, unlike in Dane Law, his
father had given minor interests to several of his siblings. The eldest son
was then obligated to pay them their share.
It took him years of scrimping and saving to pay-off
what was not his responsibility in the first place. And in all likelihood,
he would never recover a cent, because he would never sell the property.
St Ives father knew these things. He knew that families
had been torn apart because they had deviated from the old ways. Still in
all, he wanted to do what was right by the younger boy.
When his father made up
his mind what he was going to do, he called a family council. He explained
to them that it was his desire that his estate be held in joint tenancy by
the older brothers. The younger would be given the opportunity for a family
financed college education. After the books were audited each year, he would
also be given a small percentage of the profits.
This money was not to come to him directly but
was to be invested in a mutual fund, so that by the time he was fifty years
old, he would be quite well off.
It was suggested that he enters the University
of Idaho for one year and then tries for an appointment to West Point.
His father was a contributor to one of the political
parties in the State and he had business associates that had political connections.
He believed an invitation to sit for a competitive examination for one of
the senatorial appointments was a very definite possibility.
This was very much to the liking of the young man.
At any rate, he figured it was the best he could hope for, and it would allow
him to pursue a career away from the potatoes, with which he had a love hate
relationship.
His father and his brothers were true to their agreement
and to the arrangements made at that meeting. His estate grew as their holdings
grew. And now as he was about to retire from the Service in just a few short
weeks, he calculated in his mind that he might, indeed, be well situated financially.
As he reminisced and talked these things over with
himself, he wished his own family were as thoughtful and loving as his extended
family. But that was not to be and he realized he was powerless to make it
happen.
As he dwelled on the differences between his family
and his brothers, he swore an oath that their largess and hard work would
never go to benefit any of the slackers who lived with him.
No, not one red cent of his potato money was ever
going to find its way into their pockets. But he realized he was going to
have to do some serious planning, if he was going to keep it out of their
clutches and that of their lawyers.
He attended a genetics class while at the University.
He had been around livestock all his life and heard terms he never understood. And he wondered if the old timers, who talked about such
things, knew themselves what they were talking about.
While he was sitting at his desk one day, his mind
wandered back to his freshman year and to the brief encounter he had with
the subject. Terms like dominant and recessive characteristics came to mind,
as well as zygotes, genotypes, phenotypes and first and second filial generations.
And he wondered if they really could predict the color of a horse or a cow?
If certain genetic traits were inherited by plants
and the lower animals, why not humans? And if these theories did pertain
to humans, how come people were so different? Were his son and daughter really
part of the hard working St Ives gene pool? If so, then how come these acorns
fell so far from the tree? Was there really potential here for achievement
and how far below the surface was it?
How much of the responsibility for their monumental
failure then could be blamed on society, and how much was predestined, because
of some genetic fowl-up? Was it because their pregnant mother refused to
obey any of the doctor’s instructions? Could it be because she drank heavily
and made no pretense of quitting smoking? Were their young fetal minds pickled
before they had a real start in life? Perhaps genetic science would be interested
in studying their heritage or maybe social science? But then he asked himself,
who cared?
It was Christmas a few years back, he recalled.
His son had received a present that needed assembling. The boy eagerly volunteered
to help in order to expedite things. His father, in a magnanimous mood, accepted
the offer. They agreed to team-up. The father would do the assembling while
he assigned his son the job of reading the directions.
It was during this simple father and son activity
that he discovered a horrible truth. The boy was functionally illiterate.
He could not even read the simplest of sentences.
It was like a kick in the stomach to him. He had
no idea. She had continually assured him the boy was above average and progressing
nicely. “After all,” she asked rhetorically, “isn’t he getting promoted each
year?”
He could not deny that he was, however, he berated
himself for not taking more of a hand in things. But when he would ask how
he was getting along, she and the teachers continually assured him that all
was well.
Well, all was not well. And he had received a shock
from which he never recovered.
It was at this point, he told himself, that he
really began resenting the boy. He was resentful of his sloth, which had
resulted in his failing in Reading, Mathematics and English as well.
Oh, he passed the courses well enough. And he was
promoted on time. But for the first time, he became aware that he should
have paid more attention to the conversations of his friends, when they discussed
the school policy of never holding anyone back. “He can’t read or write,
but you ought to see him finger paint.”
He over heard a friend say that once of his own
son. But he thought he was joking.
But what was he to do? Could he really have made
a difference? Should he have ordered him to study?
And what good would that have done? She would have jumped in and taken the
boy’s side against him and then it would have ended, as it always did, in
a family squabble.
She loved confrontation on any subject. “Leave
him alone,” she would say.
How much then was his fault and how much was hers?
And how much of it was the boys? Is he a bad seed or is he just lazy? Did
he lack for training or is he just human? And is it human to always want
to take the easy way just because you can?
As he pondered these things, his mind wandered
to a staff meeting once at Curtis Le May’s Headquarters. The General was
commenting about the unsatisfactory performance of one of his wing commanders:
“There is the unfortunate and then there is the incompetent. But I do not
have the time or the desire to debate the difference, since the results are
always the same.”
So, whatever his reasons are for failing, he is
still a failure, he thought. And nothing can be done about that. But more
to the point, he told himself, there is not enough time left in school to
make much of a difference. Not even if a miracle occurred and the boy changed
completely.
No, he will not be able to go on in school, which
is all right. But he is not prepared to learn a trade, and he lacks the ambition
to hold a job, if he had one. No, he told himself, the best he can hope for
is to be a member of the low paying unskilled labor market.
I wonder how he intends to support himself? And
then the answer came to him in a rush. He intends to rely on his mother and
she intends to rely on me. And they both have their eyes on my potato money.
Yes, he said to himself, whatever he needs to get
by, he intends to get from me. He smiled, as he thought about the plan forming
in his mind that would lead to a rude awakening. And
it was coming to them all, and soon.
___________________________________
When it came, it came fast, and it left him devastated.
He had been expecting it but he had postponed this day in his mind. By not
thinking about it, he figured it would go away. But it was as inevitable as
his demise and now it was here. It was actually going to happen this afternoon.
Just after lunch, his secretary, joined by one
from another office, spread a tablecloth over one of the desks. He saw them
do it and it struck a panic nerve deep in his stomach. He imagined this was
how a condemned prisoner felt when he was served his last meal. But unlike
the prisoner, he could not hope for a reprieve. This was to be final. This
was to be his last day on active duty. He loved the Air Force and his heart
was about to break.
The secretaries came in with a large cake and a
bowl of punch. He had been to many of these “goodbyes” held for other people.
He had eaten their cake and drunk their punch and all the while wondering
where it came from. Where did they hide it from the condemned until the last
minute?
He supposed it was hidden like dirt at a gravesite.
They kept it covered with some kind of artificial grass so that it did not
stand out as dirt. Just as a loved one is not really dead until that same
dirt is replaced, so the secretaries keep the cake hidden like the dirt.
Nothing is going to happen, says the subconscious, until they have brought
out the cake.
When all is ready, the call goes out to the various
offices that coordinate their activities with the office of the new retiree.
And then in about an hour, everybody comes sauntering in one at a time, as
though it was not all planned. It looks as though they just accidentally popped-in,
and since they are there, they might as well have some cake.
The entire ritual is choreographed to effect an
air of indifference as though it is no big deal, this retirement. You are
in the Service one day and on the golf course the next, lucky you.
He smiled as all his friends came by and shook
his hand. But deep down, he was fighting waves of panic. He could not bear
the thought of tomorrow. It sent his mind racing away on some escape adventure
to avoid yet another spasm of panic. The last thing he wanted to do was to
breakdown. But he realized he was on the verge of doing just that.
The going out ceremony was short and simple. No
one had the time anymore for full dress parades. Not like in the old days.
The retirees, he and two enlisted men, stood at
attention. The base band played a stirring Souza march. One of the senior
officers, who had been designated for the occasion, gave some military commands.
There was some presenting of commendation medals, some more saluting, and
some congratulations, which all took place in front of the Headquarters building.
And then the formal part was over.
Some people came by and shook his hand. Some of
the wives of his close friends kissed him on the cheek. And as at the graveside
service, when the minister says Amen, they began drifting away, the better
to separate themselves from him. It was as though he had some contagious
disease they might catch if they stayed too long in his presence.
But they tried not to act as though it was a funeral.
Rather, they appeared to be in a hurry and had to get back to their office
to take care of some pressing business. Above all, they tried not to look
at him too long, because they were afraid they might see him with a tear
in his eye.
He started to walk towards his car, because that
is the procedure. No going back to the office for something you forgot or
forgot to do. That is not playing by the rules. It sets the whole emotional
thing going again.
No, goodbye is goodbye. It is just as final as
at the gravesite. No climbing back out after they have stuffed you in.
Usually, the newly retired walks to his car accompanied
by his wife or a close relative. Not so, Col. St Ives. No one showed-up and
the no shows were conspicuous by their absence.
He did not want them there anyway. He would have
had to say something nice to them and he just could not do that. And then
there would have been his son, standing around with his hands in his pockets,
looking for all the world like he was on drugs, and not even having the social
presence to shake his fathers hand. No, he was glad that none of them had
come.
It was better this way. But he and everyone else
present saw it as a breach of social etiquette, something that was considered
to be extremely rude, maybe even gauche.
To him, it was even more than that. It was seen
as one more reason to expedite the planning. The sooner he figured out the
details, the sooner the Plan could be implemented; and none too soon to suit
him.
Suddenly his queasy stomach felt a little better,
as he realized he had work to do tomorrow after all.
______________________________________
Chapter 7
A few weeks before he retired, St Ives again went
by the Stag Room after work. Standing talking to one of the employees behind
the bar was an officer he had seen there once or twice before. He had been
introduced to him once and he recalled his name was Rasmussen. He knew he
was an attorney and that he worked in the Base Legal Office. Other than that,
he knew little about him.
He had thought about meeting and talking to a legal
officer many times about his family situation; but he was torn between divorce
and trying to make a go of his marriage. Now he spoke to Rasmussen, and when
the man behind the bar moved into another room, he engaged him in light conversation.
He had no intention of saying what he said next, so he was quite surprised
to hear himself ask Rasmussen if he might drop by his office sometime?
Rasmussen asked him if there was anything specific
he had in mind, whereupon; St Ives told him hesitatingly, that he was interested
in knowing something about divorce laws and how they might affect someone
who was retired.
He told Rasmussen, for want
of something better to say, that he knew they were different for civilians
but just what that meant, he did not know. The legal officer sensed the Colonel
was somewhat embarrassed and needed help with the conversation, so he eased
him into the subject.
He told him things were different and that he should
probably drop by his office for a chat. Without further discussion, Rasmussen
suggested that he make an appointment, so as to be sure he was in his office
when he dropped by. St Ives said that if it were all right with him, he would
stop in for a few minutes after work the next night. Somehow, he felt that
by keeping it as informal as he could, he would not have to commit himself
to a course of action. He was trying to delay what he thought was the inevitable
and he knew it.
He showed up the next evening, which surprised
them both. Rasmussen sensed that he wanted information but was reluctant
to pursue the subject. He realized he was uncomfortable. He was like many
people in this regard, who came to see him for advice.
The lawyer did not want to pry too deeply into
his affairs. He had planned to answer only the questions asked of him. But
instead, he told him there were two cases, which had been published in a
recent law review. He had reread them that day, he said, and he thought they
might fit his situation. He went on to say that he would tell him what was
in the legal review, and then if he had any questions, or if there was anything
he did not understand, they could discuss it.
He told him: “an army officer by the name of Major
Mandrell had returned home from Vietnam broken in body and in spirit. He
had stepped on a land mine and it had severed both his legs and made him
a paraplegic.
“His wife, who was a comely lass, was said to be
having an affair while the good major was in combat. When she was given the
news of the extent of his injuries, she promptly sued him for divorce. Although
she later remarried, and was financially well off, she sued him for fifty-percent
of his retirement pay.
“She alleged that since her divorce was filed in
California, his retirement pay was subject to the Community Property laws
of that State. The State Supreme Court found in her favor.
“Following his recovery, sufficient to be medically
discharged from the army, Mandrell was consigned for the rest of his life
to a veteran’s hospital with a ninety-percent medical disability. This meant
that his remaining pay was exempt from federal taxation in that amount.
“When she heard about it, she promptly sued him
for half that as well. Again, she alleged that she also had earned that money
during the course of their marriage. It too was upheld.
“A challenge to the US Supreme Court was made at
considerable expense to Mandrell.
“While all of this was going on, an Air Force Colonel
by the name of McAuley suffered nearly the same fate as Mandrell, that is
to say, his wife sued him while he was in combat. She, likewise, wanted half
of his pay and half of his retirement pay when he retired.
“The California courts agreed. It was as though
California was a sovereign nation in this regard and the United States was
a subservient jurisdiction. It too was appealed,” Rasmussen told him.
“Both cases were argued successfully in the Supreme
Court by both petitioners but at considerable expense. The Court ruled against
California, stating that money owed an ex-wife should be based on need and
that it was not a vested right by virtue of marriage. Also, they emphasized
again, a serviceman’s pay was protected from seizure by the states where
they had served.
“Most legal scholars, outside of California, expected
this reversal,” he said. “But it was viewed as a major setback in the agenda
of The National Organization of Women, who made directly to the office of
their champion on the Armed Services Committee, one Betsy Schroeder, of Colorado.
“Betsy promised them she would rectify this Supreme
Court oversight, forthwith,” Rasmussen added.
“She was true to her word, because she attached
a rider to an important Armed Forces Appropriation Bill. In due course, it
became law. Now it was only necessary for a divorcee to show she had been
married to a service man, regardless of the length of time involved. And
when he retired, as long as thirty-five years later, she still had a vested
interest in half. And now, and your not going to believe this,” he said,
“it didn’t matter that he had not heard from her in all those years, and
both had remarried and there were no children involved, she still got half.”
He went on to say. “In some cases, the second wife,
who had been married to the serviceman, all those many years, was obliged
to go to work after her husband retired, in order to satisfy the debt to
his first wife. And believe it or not, the first wife may have been married
to him for only a few months and the second for many years. And there may
have been dependent children from the second marriage.
“Congress, realizing they
had been finessed by NOW, and that the new law made absolutely no sense,
woke up and overturned it. Some would later call into question Ms. Schroeder’s
judgment and exercise of zeal, by asking her if she was not hurting more
women than she was helping?
“Eventually, a period of ten years was established
as the criteria.” But he said, “this too, in my opinion, is flawed. There
is no way of knowing how many potentially good marriages are ending in divorce
when they don’t otherwise have too. What is happening, the servicemen are
opting out in the ninth year, to avoid what they think might be a lean on
their retirement pay later on,” he said.
When he had finished with his narrative, he asked
St Ives, “Have I thoroughly confused you?”
“Not in the least,” he replied. “I understand perfectly.
You have covered the subject pretty well and I want to thank you. How about
letting me buy you a beer?”
He thought to himself, as they walked to their
cars, that this Rasmussen was a pretty good Joe. He felt comfortable with
him and he made up his mind he would get to know him better.
Later, St Ives told the lawyer, he figured things
were about what he had been told they were. He did not want to go into it
in too much detail right now. But he did tell him that at one time, he had
seriously considered divorce as a way out of his dilemma. He told Rasmussen
this, without explaining too much about what he meant by the term dilemma.
But the controversy and the unsettled position of Congress on this issue,
as he understood it, had caused him to postpone his plans, he told him.
Now it was out of the question, he told Rasmussen,
because his family under the present laws, which had just been explained
to him, would go right on living much as they had been doing. And of course
that was unacceptable. The comment confused Rasmussen but he did not think
it was appropriate to ask for an explanation.
Still later, after he had left his new friend,
he told himself again that divorce was not an option. Some other means of
divesting himself of his family must be sought. Some other way to extricate
himself from his servitude must be found.
The first step of any good plan was to establish
the criteria on which the plan was to be based. One of a number of criteria
in this case, he told himself, was to force his family to face the real world
every day just as countless millions did. In order for them to do this, they
must go to work.
Secondly, they must be stripped instantly of all
income provided by him. This was the only assurance he would ever have that
they would actually become part of the work force.
Next, all property or assets which could be turned
into cash must be sold and the money either given to charity or placed where
they could not reach it.
They must suffer a devastating shock, which would
leave them homeless and penniless. Then, the only means open to them for
survival would be to get jobs. He would give anything or do anything, he
told himself, for the privilege of eventually knowing they had all done an
honest day’s work.
A couple of weeks after their conversation about
divorce laws, St Ives met him again at the little bar. He was beginning to
enjoy his conversations with Rasmussen and he suspected it was mutual. On
one of these occasions, they started to talk about what provisions had been
made for a widow after a Serviceman had retired. Rasmussen’s answer quite
surprised St Ives. Although, what he said was not foreign to him, it was
not something he had thought about in a long time.
“I’m afraid it is a lot like civilian life,” Rasmussen
told him. “If you do not make some kind of effort to see your family is taken
care of while you are still in the Service, after you pass away, they are
going to be in financial straits. Your retirement pay stops and they are
going to be dependant on Social Security alone. Unfortunately, people who
came into the Service when you did, do not have much Social Security accrued
because the military did not come under this protection until the middle
of the nineteen-fifty’s. There are a few dollars appropriated as some kind
of pension but not enough even to talk about“
“Tell me about it, I have never heard of it,” said
St Ives.
“Well, you of course know of General Arnold. But
you may not know too much about what happened to his widow. Arnold was the
wartime designer, builder and administrator of the modern Air Force. Many
historians believe he and Gen. George C. Marshal, Army Chief of Staff, were
the two outstanding people of that era. Certainly they contributed much more
to the war effort than some of those who received more credit. General Arnold
worked tirelessly, long hours of the day, seven days a week, from before
the advent of Pearl Harbor, until the end of the war. He worked so hard and
doggedly that when he retired he was in ailing health. He had in his bank
account at the time, the munificent sum of five thousand dollars.
“He took the money and bought a small home. And
then shortly, thereafter, he died. The country mourned his passing for days.
The Congress mourned him by insuring that his widow was paid the handsome
sum of fifty dollars a month for the rest of her life. This made her eligible
for welfare, which she would have had to resort too, if it had not been for
the generosity of her two sons.
“In 1968, when veterans began to retire in fairly
large numbers, Congress, shamed by the Arnold affair, provided future widows
with a generous benefit plan. But it was dependent upon whether the serviceman
elected to sign-up. If he did, as you know, he was required to give up a
rather large monthly sum of money to insure his wife’s financial future.
“Most everyone joins the Survivors Benefit Plan,
as it is called. I don’t have much to do with it. But to the few people who
ask me, I tell them it is a good deal. It is certainly a lot better than
what Mrs. Arnold had to live on,” he told him.
Soon after the draft began for the build-up of
the wartime Armed Forces, Congress instituted a National Service Life Insurance
program. They made a ten thousand dollar term policy available to all service
personnel for six dollars a month. After the war, they allowed them to convert
to a paid-up plan. St Ives chose to do this, believing at the time that it
would be used for an educational fund for his yet unborn children, as well
as insurance for his wife. He would later change his mind on both counts.
“Is there anything you want to ask me about paid-up
NSLI, while we are on the subject?” Rasmussen asked
him.
“No, I’m pretty well squared away on about everything
now,” he said. “And thanks again.”
“Think nothing of it. Anytime I can be of help concerning
anything now or after you retire, let me know. That’s what friends are for,”
he said.
Three weeks into retirement, Ed St Ives was becoming
seriously despondent. Where before, he was suffering only mild depression,
he was now experiencing several attacks of panic a week. And once he was
rushed to a hospital with a suspected heart attack.
He had no place to go and nothing to do. He sat
for hours each day on his patio listening to the ranting of his wife and
thinking about his plan to extricate himself from her clutches. But under
the circumstances, he was having a difficult time concentrating. She, in
turn, was constantly nagging him to get out of the house, and to go get a
job, or just to do something to keep out of her way.
He was disrupting the normal routine of their lives.
They did not feel comfortable anymore, lying around all day in a filthy house
in front of the television, not with his disapproving eyes watching them.
Fights and squabbles were even more frequent than
before and she gave him no peace. He thought a couple of times of going back
to his office for a visit, or over to the Stag Room for a while, but then
thought better of the idea. He was not up to it. Not yet anyway. He told
himself that maybe later on, perhaps in a few weeks.
He had heard of a General who did this. He would
go back to his headquarters periodically for a full command briefing. It
was the same briefing as the one given to the man who replaced him. But any
such outward interest, or appearance of having an interest in the affairs
of his office, by someone of his rank, would look ridiculous.
Anyway, St Ives problem was more homesickness than
it was reluctance to turn over the reins. And as he became more bored, he
became more depressed.
His plan to work on his plan was not working out.
He would start to write down the essentials of what must be done and how
it was to be accomplished, then off he would go into a deep daydream. Clearly,
he was becoming a candidate for a nervous breakdown.
He hit upon the idea of getting away from his family
for awhile. But he knew it would be only a temporary solution to his problem.
He thought about going to Idaho to see the farm and to pay a visit to his
brothers. He had not seen them for a year or so and he needed to talk to
the custodian of his mutual fund.
According to his father’s
trust, he had been eligible to make withdrawals for some time now. He had
only an estimate of the amount that had accrued over the years but he thought
it might be considerable. Now, he wanted to know exactly how much was there.
But when he found out, he was not sure exactly what he was going to do with
the information.
St Ives had not been driving long from his home
in Riverside, when he began thinking about the family he had just left. As
a matter of fact, he was usually thinking about them. He always seemed to
be trying to justify his feelings. He would go over and over in his mind,
the reasons why he disapproved of them so.
His young daughter, who had once been his favorite,
was now ranked along side the other two in his esteem. He
did not want to admit it but she was as big a washout as her brother.
He was pretty sure that she too could just barely
read and write. But in her case, it was not entirely her fault.
He always thought if your parents were reluctant
to help you or encourage you, at least thru the second grade, you were never
going to develop a love for reading. And if you did not like to read, school
was going to be difficult, and you probably would miss out on a lot.
He mused about what he knew about teaching kids
to read. He remembered taking a course in psychology once, where some of
the lectures were about learning, and specifically about learning to read.
It seemed the time-honored method of teaching reading phonetics was going
to be eventually replaced by something called the Sight Method. This new
scheme would have the pupil memorize each word in the vocabulary.
He thought at the time the idea was flawed. Why
abandon a perfectly good system, which had long proven effective for something
little more than an idea?
He later heard they were going to try it first
in California, which did not surprise him.
He never helped her. Her teachers told him that
sight and phonetics could not be taught simultaneously. It was one or the
other and not both. And the ineffective sight system was the one in vogue
when she started school.
So, on those few occasions when he tried to help
her, his wife got all over him for confusing the child.
She did learn to read a little but only slightly
better than her brother. And neither of them was able to overcome their handicap.
As far as he could tell, they never thought it was very important to do so.
It was to her credit though, he told himself, that
she went to school everyday. However, that is where her friends were. But
most important of all that is where her boyfriend was. So perhaps, he thought,
in the end he might be giving her too much credit. But more to the point,
was she learning anything that was going to do her any good? He inquired
once of her mother about this and he was curtly told to mind his own business.
She was a pretty girl and she was not at a loss
for male friends. There were always several of them hanging around his house.
When he expressed his opinion about her spending too much unsupervised time
alone with them, his wife told him that this too was none of his affair.
He knew that she had been sexually active for at
least two years. When he brought this up with his wife, he fared no better
than he did with any of the less sensitive subjects he tried to discuss with
her. In this case, he was thankful he had an excuse for not getting further
involved. But nevertheless, he knew she was headed for trouble and that her
mother was having little influence on her.
He was positive that she had had one abortion and
perhaps more. But he could only be sure about the one. He came home late
one night and found the two of them having a shouting match in her room.
From the conversation he overheard, he concluded that his daughter was little
more than a tramp, who had no respect for him or for her mother. He would
also learn from the same incident that she was involved in other unsavory
matters as well. This would be corroborated by the local police, who divulged
the fact that her mother, unbeknownst to him, had picked her up at the station
for conduct unbecoming a good citizen on more than one occasion.
She was a candidate for Juvenile Hall. When her
mother unloaded on her about all her moral shortcomings, she laughed at her
and told her she was from the dark ages. She had a smart mouth and a sharp
tongue like her mother. She also loved confrontation and continually fought
with her brother and the two of them fought with their mother. He thought
once that his home resembled the infamous Bedlam.
As he drove along, thinking about them, a passage
from the Bible came to his mind. He could not quote it but he remembered
it had something to do with the siring of “a generation of vipers.” Yes,
that is exactly what they were; a den of unloving self-centered and selfish
human beings, whom he had come to think of literally as the enemy. And like
enemy, they would be dealt with accordingly.
He remembered that it was
somewhere around Victorville when it happened. He would later conclude that
it was probably caused from the months of severe depression and brought on
now by the added stress of recalling events in his daughters wasted life.
He first had a peculiar feeling come over him. Then he lost his ability to
think clearly, followed by the realization that he had all but lost his powers
of concentration.
He pulled off the road into a rest stop, just as
the scene began to unfold. It was not like any daydream he ever had before.
He was at the Los Angeles airport. Of course he did not know what was happening
to him. He did not realize that he had entered into a fugue over which he
had no control.
He purchased a ticket and was surprised to find that he was boarding an airplane, which was scheduled to land at Orley field in Paris. Throughout the flight, he kept wondering why he was going to France. Yet, that was where he wanted to be. It was almost like a compulsion, this need to reach Paris.
He recognized the place, having been there before.
And after clearing customs, he rented a car and drove south out of the city.
Then he realized with a start that his final destination
was Château roux. And it came to him in a rush of excitement that he was
going back to see her.
His reason for wanting to see her was to find out
if she was married. He knew she would be there. The French were unique in
not wanting to move too far from where they were born and raised. He knew
that if she had moved, he probably could find relatives who knew where she
was.
She had worked at the Catherine Wheel, a quaint
wooden hotel that was more than a hundred years old. It was named for the
large rear wheel of a royal coach. In fact, there was just such a wheel mounted
near the front entrance.
He remembered the hotel featured a number of small
rooms with a spacious restaurant. Her mother had been the owner and concierge.
All the more reason to believe he could easily find her.
He reasoned that since she had been a waitress
and a bookkeeper for her mother, there was a very good chance she was still
at the hotel in some capacity.
The first time he met her
was when she was just fourteen years old. He had crash-landed near her home
during the war. And now eight years later, when he saw her again, she had
grown into a beautiful young woman.
The Americans had built
a large aircraft overhaul depot near her city. Its purpose was not only to
service aircraft but for strategic reasons as well. Their plans were calculated
to reduce the probability of global war and to offset the continuing huge
Russian military build-up of the past several years. They did this by locating
a number of Air Force bases in Europe and nearby countries. These bases were
close enough for the new jet bombers, which would be coming off the assembly
lines in two years, to reach the heart of Soviet Russia.
The scene continued on as intense as before. And
he remembered well the first year, after he came back the second time. It
was after the war in 1951. They were some of the happiest months of his life.
He did not miss the constant pressure, which had been thrust upon him by
his wife and her dominant personality. Away from her and the constant bickering
and fighting, he was enjoying a newfound freedom. And there were new awakenings
within him that made him feel that each new day was going to be an adventure.
He was a young man but had not felt young in years.
Now he felt the way he did ten years before. The object of his newfound feelings
was the twenty three-year-old daughter of the owner of the Catherine Wheel.
It started innocently enough, as an affair often
does. And it stayed that way physically but emotionally; it was far from
innocent. He was madly, crazy in love with Elaine and he had been for months,
perhaps, in a way he always had been.
He ate at the hotel as often as he could afford
too. He always sat where she would wait on him and he would always act as
inconspicuous as possible, so as not to attract her mother’s attention.
She spoke English with a thick accent, which absolutely
energized him and set his heart racing. It thrilled him to hear her speak.
He never tired of hearing that sweet feminine voice.
He remembered that she was intelligent. Yet, she
was not the least bit egotistical or domineering. Her personality and demeanor,
he thought many times, was as completely different from that of his wife
as any two people could possibly be.
She liked him too. In fact, he could tell that
she liked him a lot. But that did not mean she was going to let him touch
her. On the contrary, she was Old World Catholic and not even a single man
was allowed to be alone in her company, without hiding from her mother and
her neighbors.
He was married, of course. And she had told him
straightaway that she was the French equivalent of off-limits to him. But
all of this not withstanding, she had fallen in love with him and had managed
to find a way to tell him so.
He had always thought that some of the most beautiful
country in the world was in that part of France. The nobility, who predated
the Revolution, must have thought so too, because they dotted the landscape
with their mansions.
The city, which really was a large town, was an
easy drive from Paris. It was situated among rolling hills, crisscrossed
with small rivers and streams.
The area was steeped in Old World tradition. It
was slow paced and devoid of any pretense. Most of the people came from families
that had lived there for generations.
They were not wealthy nor were there any truly
poor among them. They led simple lives, for the most part. In fact, the produce
market was also the town social center. It had always been that way and he
thought it would probably continue on for many generations to come.
He remembered telling a friend once about why he
thought it would be a great place to raise a family. He commented that he
would not mind spending the rest of his life there. But even as he said it,
he knew it was only a casual observation, a passing fancy.
As his mind continued on in the deep trance that
had possessed him for the past hour, he saw again very vividly, the beautiful
autumn landscape of France. And he seemed to be experiencing the exact same
feelings, which had overwhelmed him on one day many years before.
Elaine had coaxed and had gotten permission from
her mother to go for an afternoon drive in the country. She had packed a
picnic basket and he had borrowed a car from a friend. The innocence of the
situation and his feelings for her that day came flooding back. And it was
as though he was living it for the first time. And he remembered. And his
pulse beat faster even now, as her closeness overcame his better judgment,
and he confessed his love for her. She responded with a declaration of her
love for him. But she reinforced his understanding that nothing was possible
outside of marriage and under the circumstances this could never happen.
They stopped by the side of the road at a breathtaking
scenic overlook. And he marveled again at the beauty of the place. They ate
their lunch there, and then motored a short distance to the birthplace of
George Sands, the legendary mistress of Chopin. On the way back, they stopped
at a medieval church where they sat and talked for a while about what it
would be like if things were different.
All in all it was the best day of his life. And
he would tell himself many times thru the years, he would give anything to
live it over. And now, thru some extraordinary aberration of the mind, it
had become possible.
The scene began to fade away and was replaced by
another from his early-married life immediately after the war. Life was good
then, and although they did not have a lot of money, they lived well. Then
too, they had each other, and they were in love.
The future for him looked bright. He had graduated
in 1942 from the accelerated class at West Point. He was then commissioned
and sent directly to flying training. Upon graduation, he transitioned into
the B-17 bomber and then it was on to more training with his new crew and
finally to England and combat.
He was a survivor of the bloody air war over Europe.
He rose steadily thru the ranks and at the relatively young age of 26, he
was promoted to the rank of Captain. Following his return from France, just
before the Invasion, he was promoted to Major.
She reveled in her newfound social status. She
had an engaging personality, and she was well liked by all their friends,
which were many, and were sprinkled throughout the ranks.
Their social life was full.
She learned to play bridge and Mah Jong and she spent much of her time engaged
in these activities.
She attended all the women's club luncheons. And
it was there that she first participated in a cocktail before lunch, not
because she liked alcohol particularly, but because everyone else had one.
First it was one and then out of boredom, it became two or three.
She could not remember and neither could he, when
she began to like the stuff, or when she began looking forward to a cocktail
before dinner.
There were the usual dances, as well as the bridge
parties and the dinners at friend’s homes. Always there was alcohol present.
She soon gained a reputation for one whom occasionally over indulged. But
she always managed to stop short of embarrassing the two of them, at least
in the early years.
She had been raised in the Midwest during the Depression.
Her family was not poor, but like most people, they had to budget their money
to provide for the essentials of middle class living.
Food was not scarce in their home, as it was in
some others, but only the staples could be said to exist in quantity. Meat,
milk, and desserts were considered to be luxuries and not part of the daily
menu.
After she married St Ives, all of this began to
change. When they went out for dinner, she felt free to order anything she
pleased in any quantity. This newfound freedom to indulge her senses in all
the things that had not been readily available to her while she was growing
up began to change her personality. No longer was she grateful for her daily
bread, so to speak. But she began to believe that extravagance was a privilege
of her husband’s rank, the mantle of which fell so easily about her shoulders.
Without restraints of any kind in her new life,
she began to lead a more sedentary existence. A lack of exercise and an increase
in calorie intake began to show on her hips and stomach.
She started to lose her youthful figure, and before
long she resembled some of her women friends, who were much older.
The quarreling began in earnest in those years.
It started because of her lack of self-control, and then became worse, when
he discovered that he had married a truly domineering woman.
She hated herself for what she had come to look
like. And she became even more cold and less of a loving person. He in turn
withdrew from her. They went days without talking to each other. And he did
not show her any outward affection for weeks at a time.
It was at this point that they were posted to Norton
Air Force Base, San Bernardino, California. He was there for the purpose
of receiving training in the operation and management of an aircraft repair
depot.
An Air Depot Wing, as it was called, was forming
in the spring of 1950. It would later split into three groups; each one would
form a cadre for three wings, one of which would be stationed at Château
roux. The other two would be in Germany and French Morocco.
The tour of duty at these new bases was a year
and a half. If you took your wife with you, it was three years. She chose
the first option. Just like that. He had no say in the matter. She did not
want to go traipsing all over the world. She wanted to stay right where she
was with her new friends where she was comfortable.
He was powerless to persuade her to change her
mind, so he gave into her demands. It was not the first time she had made
a major decision on her own that would have a major effect on their lives.
It was the continuation of a pattern, which would prevail throughout the
rest of their marriage.
She had exercised an old weapon she had used against
him many times before. That is, she would just make up her mind to have her
own way, and then refuse to negotiate.
It was either her way or it was divorce. She had
no interest in even discussing the matter. But what she did not realize was
that she was destroying his love for her. His love was slowly turning to
hatred and his feelings one-day would get the better of him. Then all of
his pent-up emotions would translate into action, and the consequences would
have a devastating effect on all their lives.
Chapter 9
As the chemical imbalance in the neurotransmitters of his brain, which had been responsible for a near nervous breakdown, changed back to a more normal state, St Ives was able to recognize that he had been in a deep trance.
He slowly came to realize that the events of the
past two hours were not real but had taken place only in his mind. It was
like awakening from a deep sleep. Yet he realized he had not been asleep;
this was something quite different. It had been far more real than a dream.
It was, he thought, when analyzed in the cold light of day, when he was completely
rational, much like watching his life unfold on a movie screen. That was
the best he could do.
He was quite shaken at first. But as he sat there
in his car, now quite lucid, he began to contemplate the singularity of the
thing and he wondered if it might not happen again.
As he continued thinking about what had just occurred,
he realized that the psychiatrist, testifying for the defense at the CourtMartial
he served on years before, had pretty well described what had happened to
him. He thought that perhaps the court had made a mistake. Maybe in their
ignorance and smugness, they had convicted an innocent man.
There was nothing he could do about that now. Anyway,
he told himself, all he wanted to think about was Elaine. He just wanted
to sit there and savor the moment.
It was as though he had been in her very presence.
He thought if he concentrated, he could again smell her hair and the sweet
scent of wine on her breath.
He finally drove off, confident he could control
the vehicle. When he reached Barstow, he debated for a moment whether he
might stop by the hospital. But then he quickly abandoned the idea.
What exactly were they going to do for him? What
did he want them to do? Frankly, he thought to himself, as a smile crossed
his face, I don’t want to be cured of anything. He figured they would probably
look him over and conclude that he had a stroke or something. Worse yet,
they would not understand. And not taking any chances, they would notify
the police and they would take away his driver’s license, leaving him stranded
out there in the desert.
No, he was all right. In fact, he said to himself,
I am better than all right. I feel better than I have felt in years. My mind
is clearer than it ever was. And he thought that maybe for the first time,
he would be able to put together the pieces of the plan he had been mulling
over for months.
By the time he reached Las Vegas, he had a rough
draft in his head. He knew generally what he was going to do and he was filled
with enthusiasm at the thought of doing it.
He would take an overnight driving break. He would
treat himself to a good meal and rest-up. He was very tired in a pleasant
sort of way and he was still feeling the euphoria he had experienced at seeing
Elaine again. Yes, that is what he would do. And then on the next leg of
the trip, he would finalize the details of the plan in his mind. But for
now, all he wanted to think about was Elaine.
The depression, which had nearly consumed him,
had vanished. The thought of Elaine, and the realization that he had at last
a workable plan to solve his family problems, had a calming effect on him.
The first step was to determine how much potato
money he had. Next, he would meet the custodian of his mutual fund and have
him turn it all into cash. The money would be placed into a checking account,
minus several thousand dollars he would need for expenses.
He would visit with his brothers, but before he
left them, he would ask them to redirect the trust money to some one else
in the family. Maybe they could set up an educational fund; that would be
a nice touch. But the real objective was to have all future monies vanish.
It must appear to any investigator that it never existed at all.
After a warm and friendly two-day visit with his
family, and having given instructions to his broker and banker and to his
brothers, he motored south to Idaho Falls. He bought an airline ticket to
Lucerne, in French speaking Switzerland. He had to change planes in Denver
and New York and then again in Zurich. But after a pleasant first class flight,
in which he whiled away the time thinking about Elaine, he arrived in Lucerne.
He took a taxi to a good hotel in the heart of
the city. Although it was early in the evening, he went straight to bed.
He told himself that he had a busy day tomorrow and he wanted no problem
with jet lag.
He slept about ten hours. When he awakened, he
ordered the complimentary breakfast, and read the English language newspaper
that was delivered to his door. He then walked down the street and sat down
outside at a quaint side walk cafe. He ordered another coffee and watched
the passing parade of busy people on their way to work.
He thought to himself how he was enjoying this experience
as much as any tourist. But he was reminded by another thought: his purpose
there had nothing to do with sightseeing.
He noticed a sign on a building across the street
that spelled out Banque du Lucerne. He walked across
and entered the marble foyer. He noticed that the interior of the structure
was well appointed without being pretentious. It was the way a bank ought
to look, he thought. He decided on the spot that it had the stability he
was looking for.
He was ushered to the desk of one of the vice presidents.
He told the banker that he wished to open a numbered account in the amount
of ten thousand dollars. Further, he told him, he wanted all of his money
transferred from his Idaho account. When asked if he knew the amount, he handed
him a deposit slip that indicated there was well over two million dollars.
He asked how long it would take to complete the
transaction and he was told that it should be done before the closing of
the next business day. He then signed the necessary papers.
He left, satisfied that they would live up to the
Swiss reputation for being competent and discreet. He had asked his new banker
friend during the course of their conversation, if he could recommend a reliable
private investigator.
He was given the name of a firm the bank had used
in the past. They called and arranged an appointment for him two hours hence.
This gave him just enough time for lunch at another sidewalk cafe. With twenty
minutes to spare, he hailed a cab for a spirited ten-minute ride thru traffic
to his destination.
He was introduced to a detective who offered him
a glass of wine. This is a French custom calculated to break the ice and
to put the new business associate at ease. St Ives remembered that this ice-breaking
period could be quite lengthy. Sometimes it was used to render the customer
at a disadvantage by offering him several more glasses than was appropriate.
While the Colonel sipped the wine, the detective
sat back and listened without interruption. St Ives told him what he wanted
without telling him why. He told him he wanted him to find a certain French
woman from the town of Château roux. He gave him her full name and then told
him he wanted to know if she was deceased. If she was living, he wanted to
know her address. If she had moved, he wanted to know that too. These were
the absolute essentials, he told him. But he would appreciate knowing anything
else he could find out, including her marital status.
He told the investigator that any further employment
would depend on his findings. If he found she was living, and by a stroke
of luck was single, he was to hold himself available to act as St Ives agent
and courier. The specifics of any follow-up activity would be explained to
him later.
They discussed the agent’s fee and then he signed
a contract. He then gave the investigator the name of his hotel and the room
number. They shook hands and he told him that he wanted to hear from him
in two weeks at the most. He also told him he wanted his case given priority
attention and that he would stay in Lucerne until he reported back.
He sat around the sidewalk cafes while he waited.
He did not feel like participating in anything, which would interrupt his
chain of thought. He preferred to just sit and think about his plan and of
course about Elaine.
He thought endlessly about what his life was going
to be like, if perchance she was single, and what he might do if she were
married.
All good plans have a fallback position, he told
himself. And he spent hours in conceiving and discarding options. Of one
thing he was sure; he intended to make his permanent home in Château roux.
If for some reason his plans did not work out with Elaine, and it was odds
on that they would not, then he planned to seek out another woman as near
like her as he could find. He was locked into the idea of finding another
French woman and falling in love with her.
He would not consider that this option was fraught
with pitfalls. In his present state of mind, he was unable to come to terms
with anything which might dissuade him from what he viewed as the solution
to his problems. His next mate must not be a dominating shrew and she must
above all be a friend and a companion.
He would kill two birds with one stone: the perfect
scheme. He would disappear, and he would make a new home where the women,
he believed, were less worldly. Elaine at any rate was less worldly and he
supposed the others were the same way.
If he could not have her, he would try for someone
else who would love and respect him. What he did not want was another ungrateful
competitor to complicate his remaining years.
The week he spent waiting for the investigator
to return from France was one of the best he could remember in a long time.
With his depression all but over, he was sleeping well. He had not given
serious thought to his family in several days or to any of his other problems
for that matter. He had put them all out of his mind. But he knew it was
just temporary.
This particular morning, he was sitting as usual
in his favorite sidewalk cafe. His mind had seldom left Elaine for a moment.
Now as he watched the passers-by, he was thinking about the first time he
saw her. She had been a young girl in her teens She had slipped into his
room in the Catherine Wheel to wash and dress the many wounds and abrasions
he had suffered during the crash landing of his bomber. Then too, he had
been badly beaten by his captors when they attempted to extract information
from him.
Her mother had sent her. She reasoned, and rightly
so, that the girl stood a better chance of persuading the guard to allow
her to enter his room. He had been brought there by the Gestapo and turned
over to the Army when they were thru with him. What they intended to do next
was uncertain. But Elaine knew her mother was privy to information that he
might be shot as a spy. Her mother had also told her that his captors might
stage a fake escape and shoot him as an escapee.
He had just ordered a hot chocolate, which was
the specialty of the sidewalk cafe, where he sat basking in the sun. His
mind was still on Elaine and the role she and her mother played in his escape.
The two of them slipped into his room the following
night. For some reason the guard had temporarily left his post. The older
woman gave him a knapsack, which contained food and money. When he saw the
guard was missing, he remembered the conversation he had with the two British
intelligence officers several days before. They said they had inside connections
within the Vichy government and he was told not to worry about escaping.
It would be arranged, they said.
The two women wished him good luck and then Elaine’s
mother kissed him on both cheeks but Elaine did not. She put her arms around
him and kissed him on the lips as she started to cry. Later, he was to think
about this for the longest time. But in the end, he would chalk it up to
the times, and the stressful situation. Then too, she was young and impressionable,
and perhaps in the short time she knew him, she had taken pity on him. And
then again, she might have developed some kind of crush on him, an older
man, he thought.
Elaine’s mother had escorted him down the quiet
stairs and out the back door into the stable behind the hotel. As they passed
the kitchen, they saw the sentry sitting at the table drinking coffee and
eating something. St Ives was surprised at the sentry’s behavior and he began
to worry. It was almost as if the Germans were encouraging him to escape.
It was almost too easy. He thought that any moment soldiers might appear
and shoot them all for some reason he would never discover.
He sat in the dark stable long after she left thinking
about what the mother had told him. She had cautioned him about talking to
any Frenchman other than those referred to in his verbal instructions. She
only told him where to meet his first contacts and not who they were. Whatever
questions he might have should be directed to them, she said. She was obviously
part of the plan to help him escape. But whom she worked for, he did not
know. And when he asked, she would not tell him.
She handed him a bundle of clothes and then slipped
back into the hotel without another word.
He had been directed to report to a house on the
Rue de St. Cyr. And even now he could remember the two men who were waiting
for him. He was given a glass of wine and then hustled into a dilapidated
Citroen and driven south. He never could remember much about the car trip.
He slept most of the way as the car sped thru the night and the dark countryside.
It was not until the sun was coming up and they reached the Garonne River
that he felt awake. When he thought about it later, he suspected he might
have been given a sedative in the wine. The drivers had no interest in making
friends. He guessed they did not want to be recognized and later identified,
if they encountered trouble along the way. Their job was to get him to a
point on the river where they would turn him over to the crew of a small
barge. And the less he knew about them, or what they did and looked like,
the better.
The trip to Toulouse took the better part of three
days. During this time he was kept below decks. The crew did not contact
him nor did any one on board speak to him. He had been told the Vichy had
penetrated the Resistance. And from time to time, cells were being uncovered,
and anyone involved with assisting downed airmen was summarily shot. The
whole operation from beginning to end was very dangerous.
He was dressed as a civilian. He had left his uniform
at the hotel and was wearing some of Elaine’s father’s clothes that her mother
had given him. And now if the Germans captured him, he would be shot as a
spy. And so would any Frenchman suspected of helping him. He thought, as
he sat in the dark hold of the barge, that if there had been any plan on
the German’s part to let him escape, it had all gone by the wayside now.
The Resistance certainly knew of no such plan, he reasoned. And from the
beginning, he had been in extreme danger. But why did that surprise him.
He was being quite naive if he thought he was entitled to any special treatment.
How far did the protection of British intelligence extend, he wondered? And
then the answer came back to him; not anymore than it did for any other downed
flier. He had accomplished what he was expected to do, and as soon as he
left the hotel, he was in the hands of the Resistance. He was dependent on
them exclusively for survival and they had little to do with the British
or the Americans at that point.
The British had not exactly deceived him but they
had not been frank with him either. The entire mission was shaping up as
being far more complicated and dangerous than he had ever been led to believe.
He sat now, sipping hot chocolate, watching the
passing sidewalk traffic, and thinking back to the tortuous escape route leading
from Chateauroux to St.. Girons. And then to the arduous and dangerous fifty-mile
trek that was planned across the Pyrenees Mountains to the Spanish village
of Esterri d’Aneu. And as he thought about those years, he could not help
but think about Elaine at that young age, and how she had grown into the beautiful
woman he knew in the early years of the fifties.
He would learn after the war that the planned route
over the Pyrenees was the same route that hundreds of airmen had used to
escape from France. It was known then as the “Chemin de Liberte”
or “Freedom Trail” to Spain, a neutral country.
It had been a time when Resistance members, many
of them no older than the twenty year-old aircrews they helped, did great
heroic deeds. And many lost their lives and all of them lived in constant
fear of being discovered and shot.
For these heroes, the times demanded action. They
weighed the dangers and decided to act. They chose not the way of the saboteur
but the equally dangerous activity of helping to place aircrews back in the
cockpits to fight another day. An enemy army occupied their country and they
chose to fight the only way they knew how.
That is how he met Marcel. That was not his real
name. But he was his first contact after he left the barge at Toulouse. He
explained how he would be taken inside his hay-wagon and turned over to a
woman, who Marcel referred to as Madame LeFevbre. St Ives suspected it was
not her real name. But he was not to find out until after the war and now
he had forgotten. She was responsible for the fate of almost every airman
who made good his escape over the Pyrenees. And after the war she would be
singled out as a National hero.
Many survivors would pay
tribute to her and many would journey back to thank her personally. St Ives
was not one of them. He could not bring himself to do it, because of the
things that later happened. He suspected they were most necessary. But still
they did happen and he was slow to forgive. In some cases, he found he was
unable to forgive at all for many of the things that had happened in his life.
Upon his arrival at Madame Le Fevbre’s home, he
recalled, he was fed and given a place to sleep. He expected to immediately
move into the processing organization responsible for the actual transit
across the mountains; but it did not happen. In fact, he soon came to realize
he was in semi-confinement. He was locked in a room where he was fed and
given little else. No one talked to him. And he remembered seeing armed guards
inside her home. They wore no uniforms and carried no firearms that were
discernable. But they were there to guard him nonetheless. Madame Le Fevbre
said absolutely nothing to him during the two-week period he stayed with
her.
She was a middle-aged woman, who wore her hair
in a straight combed-back bun. It gave an appearance of being more severe
and business like than she actually was. Later, he would be told she was
quite charming and that she had a rather droll sense of humor. But as far
as he was concerned, she was aloof and uncommunicative. At one point he became
rather forthright in his demands to know what was going on. Madame gave him
absolutely no answers, but simply nodded to one of her guards, who produced
a German machine pistol and pointed it at him.
Later, she would apologize for her actions, telling
him why they thought he was an infiltrator. She explained how they took no
chances with their guests. They assumed each one was a potential Vichy or
German agent. And, until their identification tags had been verified by intelligence
sources in London, everyone was considered to be an enemy. In the case of
St Ives, verification took twice as long as did the others. And now as he
thought back on the incident, he concluded it was because his case had interest
at the highest levels of the American and British governments. But, he remembered
Madame telling him that whatever the reason for the delay, it increased her
suspicions, and it almost got him shot. But the fact that she would have
had him shot then was not what would ultimately bother him the most.
Her dark dress and manner allowed her to blend
in with the other women in the community. She made daily trips to the market
place for fresh produce, which she paid for with money given to her by the
Resistance, who in turn received it from agents of the American OSS. On her
way home, she often stopped at a specialty wine shop. The business of the
owner was indeed, wine. But he was also a master forger, who had served time
in a French prison before the war. Now he had been drafted into the Resistance
movement. And he well knew the consequences, if he did not cooperate. But
they were not taking any chances with him turning them over to the Vichy
for a price. So to ensure his continuing loyalty, he was paid large sums
of money. He in turn, supplied Madame with excellent documents. Her guests
would use them to penetrate German checkpoints on the road from St Girons
to the starting point, and beyond, in their forthcoming trek to Spain.
Madame kept a large sum of money in a secret safe
under a bidet in her bathroom. The fixture was not functional. But only Madame
knew this. Now, on the night of the two-week anniversary of his entering
her home, St Ives recalled being assigned a “companion.” He arrived after
midnight, and was later introduced to St Ives, who was awakened from a sound
sleep, when he heard them speaking rapidly in their native tongue.
One of the required classes
at West Point was French, because at the time, it was considered to be the
international language of diplomacy. All the courses at the Academy were
taken seriously. But when he saw the French course on the plebe schedule,
he thought perhaps it would be treated like most language courses in other
American schools. That is to say, he thought he might get by with a few hours
of study a week. This would enable him to use the rest of his time in the
pursuit of the requirements of the sciences, which he suspected were going
to give him the most trouble.
But he was soon to find out that a mere effort
was not going to see him thru. And in fact, he was told by several upperclassmen,
one of the quickest ways of being sent down was to founder in French.
When he failed to get passing grades on the first
two of his weekly tests, because of this misunderstanding, he became fair
game to the upperclassmen bent on hazing him. They had been directed to do
so by his instructor who’s sole interest was to get him started out on the
right foot. But their practice of verbally testing him in French continued
throughout his first year. He was thankful for the attention, when one of
his close friends failed his final first year examination, and he was returned
to the ranks of the Regular Army.
He was thankful then he had received a firm grounding
in the subject but he was always a little reluctant to agree that the time
and effort he was forced to expend was ever going to be worth the effort.
He continued in this thinking after graduation and right up to the present
time. Now he was grateful for the experience and the training.
But he soon realized when he fell into the hands
of the Resistance that he had never been all that proficient in the first
place. But within a few days it started coming back to him. And he found
he was rapidly adding more words to his vocabulary.
Now, at this late hour, the two of them were loudly
discussing money. He could just make out the words. What they were talking
about was whether his escort was to be paid more money. The guide felt he
was entitled to more money, because payment was based on rank, and St Ives
was not only a Captain, but he was also someone special. And because he was
special, the escort suspected the Germans would be more on the lookout for
him than they would have been for someone else. One of the main discussion
points, he could just barely make out, was whether Madame’s people had actually
observed some newly reported roadblocks between St. Girons and Aunac.
As St Ives continued to eavesdrop, he got the definite
impression that the Gestapo and the German Army intended to mount a search
for him well into the foothills of the mountains. He thought he recognized
enough of the conversation to understand that the man talking to Madame knew
of such roadblocks and that they had not been there until a short time before
he arrived. But whether he was just telling her this to get more money, or
whether there was actually trouble ahead, he could not tell
But whatever they had decided, the business at
hand was concluded, and the two of them entered his room with the announcement
they were ready to start immediately.
She introduced his guide, whom she referred to
as Henri. He was a couple of years younger and a few inches taller than St
Ives was. He wore a black beret, and as he stood silhouetted against the
light of the naked bulb in the hall, with a French cigarette dangling from
his lips, he was an imposing figure. He looked to St Ives as though he might
be trying to affect the persona of the movie version of what a working member
of the Resistance might look like. Then he saw the Sten machine gun carried
across his shoulder, and a muslin bag, which he referred to as a musette,
crisscrossed over the opposite shoulder. He suspected it contained grenades
and extra clips of ammunition. This was no movie character from one of a
number of movies being made these days, he thought. In fact, he made a bet
with himself, as he stood up and shook his hand, that this man might be able
to count on his fingers the number of moving pictures he had seen in his
lifetime.
He was right about Henri. He was not born to the
city. He had been a shepherd for most of his life. When France fell he left
his father’s farm in the Pyrenees and became engaged in the smuggling of
contraband from Spain across the mountains. And then he naturally gravitated
to the smuggling of Allied airmen. He was used to being alone. He had spent
most of his life by himself and St Ives realized at the outset that he was
not going to be much company.
Henri was in excellent physical condition and his
lungs were adapted to the high country. He was used to carrying heavy packs
at a blistering pace. Once he started out, he preferred to continue climbing.
And he resented the frequent rest stops often demanded by his charges.
St Ives was given a pack, which contained enough
food to see him thru to the next stopping point at Aunac. He remembered Aunac
and the trip from St. Girons, as being one of the most trying ordeals of
his life. It was worse, he thought, than the most brutal day he ever spent
in the fields at home. The hike took only four hours but it was up past the
foothills and into the mountains. He was not in the best of shape. Long hours
in the cockpit and then several days as a guest of the Gestapo had taken
their toll. And the ensuing walk was almost too much for him. His guide chided
him good naturedly for going to war in such poor physical condition. St Ives
replied that he never in his wildest dreams believed, because he was an aviator,
he would be called upon to walk halfway across France. Still, he would not
be the first one to do so and he supposed he would not be the last.
Henri watched him with more than passing interest.
If they came upon a patrol of German soldiers, or worse yet, a group of Vichy
bounty hunters, St Ives was going to be a definite liability. And he wished
now that he had demanded more money from Madame.
He was thinking about the quaint farmhouse where
they stayed the first night, as the waiter at the cafe took his order for
another cup of chocolate. He did not indicate he was interested in St Ives
ordering any thing more. Sidewalk cafes are something of an institution in
France and Switzerland. If you order and choose to sit in the open on the
sidewalk, you must pay extra for the privilege, and then you generally can
sit as long as you like. It has always been that way as far back as anyone
could remember.
The farmhouse at Aunac reminded him of the childhood
home of George Sands, and the time he visited there with Elaine, many years
before. The stable and the barn were part of the house, where he and the
guide slept, buried in the hay above the animals below. He was completely
worn out. And he wondered out loud to Henri about the condition of his feet.
His military street shoes had been worn inside
his fleece lined flying boots. The combination made them too heavy for sustained
walking. But Madame had replaced them, not because they were unsuitable particularly,
but because they were too conspicuous. She had procured new work shoes from
the man who made the identification cards and they had not been properly
broken in. Henri told him to stand in the horse trough until the leather
was thoroughly soaked. Then, he said, the next morning they would be dry,
and they would not only be softer, but they would fit better.
He had an old football injury to his knee. It had
completely healed two years after it happened, or so he had thought. And
then on an elk hunt with his brothers thru the mountains near his home, he
discovered after two days, that he could go no further. The knee began to
swell and they had to return home. He wondered as he lay in the stable, if
it would happen again.
The terrain on the hike to Aunac was much like
the mountain areas of Idaho. In fact, he had remarked to Henri about how
similar the countryside was. The foothills of the Pyrenees were crisscrossed
with ravines and gullies, just like the wilderness area at home, where he
liked to hunt and fish. And the trees and brush were the same; it was thick
and difficult to walk thru when off the trail.
They had left the road hours before. Henri explained
to him how the Germans liked to surprise escapees walking along the road,
just when they thought they were in the clear.
St Ives, for want of something to talk about, as
much as anything, explained why they were not seeing German spotter airplanes.
He told Henri that the American bombing forces had shifted their priorities.
They had originally set out to destroy German aircraft factories. But the
Germans had dispersed them. They had hundreds of mini-factories scattered
throughout Germany. Many of them had been set up in the basements of buildings
and some even in homes. And actually, he told him, reports back from OSS
operatives indicated that bombing had had very little effect on overall production.
When Henri looked puzzled, St Ives told him that
the Allies were still bombing all right; but they were bombing different
targets. He said they had switched to oil refineries and transportation.
Not only had they all but curtailed oil production but they had crippled
the railroads as well. Even if the Germans had the fuel for their aircraft,
there would be no way to transport it to the fighter bases in France, he
said.
Henri told him they may not have fuel for their
aircraft but they apparently had enough to patrol the roads in their automobiles?
He phrased it as a question. And then he made the remark that, come to think
of it, the cars they were using had been converted to gas, which came from
charcoal made in the local area.
About half way between Aunac and Subera, his knee
did begin to swell. They were now well past the foothills and into the high
mountains looming ahead. The pace had all but come to a standstill, as the
terrain became even steeper. At one point they stopped walking altogether.
Henri made camp by a cold swift running stream. He told St Ives to remove
his trousers and to immerse his entire leg into the near freezing water.
This helped some, but when he tried to walk again, the knee had stiffened
up. He found that it would not bend. And he was forced to walk stiff legged.
St Ives asked Henri if they could stay where they
were for a couple of days. Henri replied that it was not possible. And then
he told him there was a good chance they were being followed. He said the
bounty hunters could not be everywhere at once, so they hired informers from
among the general population. He supposed they had been spotted moving towards
the mountain trails and no doubt had been seen and reported. In the past,
he said, they always assumed this had happened. But they did not pay too
much attention, because the hunters were at a disadvantage. By the time the
informers were able to make contact with the hunters, the escapees were miles
ahead of them. But because they had been going so slowly they might only
be a few miles back, he told St Ives.
Henri went on to say that he had no intentions
of abandoning him unless they were ambushed. And then if it happened, he
was on his own. They sat talking for another half-hour and all the while
Henri was becoming more apprehensive. In fact, St Ives thought he was beginning
to look extremely agitated and nervous.
As Henri sat and smoked, St Ives could not help
but think about how much money he was being paid for the two-week’s work.
He guessed it was plenty and that Henri was quite well off by the standards
of the time and place, anyway. And he then he thought again that he might
really be doing quite well financially.
He was not exactly interested in Henri’s personal
affairs. But in this case they affected him. He wondered when they arrived
in Spain, if he was going to be asked to sign a receipt. And would Henri
then take the paper back to Madame to collect the remainder of his fee? If
they had such a procedure, it might well decide what the next step might
be. If he had already been paid the total amount, Henri might just walk away,
telling him that he should wait until his leg got better, and then try to
get back to Madame’s home on his own.
Henri stood up and shouldered his weapon. He knew
St Ives could not walk, so he must be going to leave him. Then he surprised
him when he said he was going back down the trail a few miles and wait. If
there were bounty hunters in the area, he intended to ambush them. But he
told him under no circumstances was St Ives to move for at least two days.
Henri said that if he was not back by then to turn around. St Ives did not
think he even had to say it, because the idea of moving further into the
mountains on his own was just too preposterous to contemplate.
Even with Henri carrying his pack and St Ives hobbling
along behind, they were doomed to failure if they tried to go on. Henri figured
they could not even get to the five thousand-foot level before their supplies
ran out. That would leave them days from the Carberous Pass at the eight thousand-foot
level. Then there was the Clauere Pass, which would have been another two
more days at the rate they were going. And it could be reached only after
climbing thru some of the most difficult terrain to be found anywhere. The
Clauere was the Spanish border. From there it was downhill to traveled roads
leading thru villages to the town of Esterri de Aneau. But they could expect
no help until then.
They could not delay another hour, Henri told him.
If the hunters did not get them then the ice and snow covered mountain would.
They had no choice but to abandon the trail. But first he must check to see
that the way was clear back to Aunac.
He removed some cheese and salami and a large part
of a loaf of crusty bread from his pack and placed it inside his musette
with his extra ammunition. The rest he left with St Ives along with a Luger,
a large knife, and some francs. They shook hands and Henri started down to
a place where he intended to wait for anyone who might be coming up the trail.
But before he left, he sat back down and lit yet another cigarette. St Ives
remembered the conversation that followed as if it were yesterday, because
what Henri told him next sent chills down his spine. He told him not to trust
Madame. Never one to mince words, Henri simply blurted it out that she would
not hesitate to have him shot if he returned.
The only other way, he said, for him to get out
of France was by railroad. And as far as he knew no one had made it that
way before. The Gestapo congregated at the railroad stations and several
of them were aboard each train going and coming from the coast. But he confessed
he did not know how many had tried. But the point was, he said, Madame would
not take the chance of him being captured and revealing the escape organization
to the Gestapo.
St Ives thought several
times of telling him what his mission had been. He thought Henri might be
able to contact some OSS operatives, and to tell them to contact London.
How important his information was to them, he could only speculate. But in
the end he said nothing. It was too dangerous. If Henri were captured, the
Gestapo would have tortured him before he was shot. So he said nothing, as
he waved good by, and wished him luck.
Henri had only been gone about an hour before it
dawned on him that Henri was not coming back. Even if he could get back,
there was nothing he could do to help him. He could not carry him. And it
was not likely that he would be able to find someone he could trust. The
big problem was finding somebody you could trust. He had to make up his mind
he was on his own. He must start thinking for himself, rather than reacting
to what others had planned. Now he was not only in danger from the Germans
but the Vichy and the Resistance as well. He could not go back to Madame’s
home.
He was a cripple and there was no way back to England,
which did not involve a good deal of walking. He was a liability, and in
his present state of health, he was viewed as a danger to her and her organization.
His mind left Henri and the Pyrenees Mountains momentarily.
And he began thinking about other things. He had been sitting at the cafe
in the warm sun for about and hour. He was very comfortable and enjoying
a kind of peace of mind. The kind, he thought, which had eluded him for so
many years. Then, for some reason, his thoughts drifted back to the conversations
he had with his good friend Rasmussen.
Funny, he thought, how you could become lifelong
friends with someone in a relatively short time. He had seen it happen to
several of his friends. It was quite common in combat, he knew. It had even
happened to him once or twice. He wondered if it was the way people were
put together or if it was some kind of gift reserved for soldiers. He speculated
that civilians, of course, made friends with each other. But he was willing
to bet those friendships were not the same. They did not have the same ingredients.
He told himself he was no psychologist. So he supposed any conclusions he
might come to about this would probably be in error anyway. He just knew
it happened. And he knew it was one of life’s great
pleasures.
He had talked about this with Rasmussen once and
they had concluded that sometimes military friendships were actually stronger
than family ties. Rasmussen admitted he was out of his field, as well. But
he did say that maybe the reason why St Ives had not tried harder to gain
the love and respect he wanted from his son was because he found this need,
this fulfillment, as he put it, elsewhere. He called it sublimation, a word
St Ives had heard in school, but had all but forgotten.
Maybe the Service had been his family, after all.
Maybe the Service satisfied the role a family played in the well-adjusted
psyche. The old saying, “you found a home in the army” was not too far off
in his case. And maybe in a lot of others as well, he thought.
There was no question about it; his family life
was a tragedy. The thought tended to ruin the good feelings he had awakened
with that morning and he vowed in the future to try and rid his mind of anything
depressing.
St Ives, for some reason, had told Rasmussen something
about the role he had played in “Operation Overlord,” the code name for the
Invasion. He supposed it might still be classified but who knew. And at the
time, he felt he had to tell someone. He had to tell someone who was close
to him and who cared. Rasmussen was about as close to him as anyone, other
than his brothers.
It was during one of their
evenings at the Stag Bar that Rasmussen had asked him how he managed to get
out of France. He replied that it really had less to do with the Resistance
than it did with luck and training. Not training exactly. At least not the
kind of escape and evasion training they had nowadays for downed aircrews,
he said.
In those days, Hollywood had put together a team
of actors, directors, and producers at the suggestion of the Army Air Corps.
It was not long after Pearl Harbor, when their first films began showing
up at basic training centers around the country. In the beginning, they were
just extensions of the lectures on such things as hygiene, handling of firearms,
and the like. But then they started to produce some real classic pictures
about how to escape from a prison camp and how to survive in places like
the Arctic and the Jungle. One of their best, he told Rasmussen, was nearly
a full-length feature. He said he remembered it well. It featured several
recognizable movie stars.
The film centered on several groups of escapees
from a prison in Europe. Each one selected a different method to try and
get away. Most of them went directly to the closest railroad station where
they congregated. He said they were so obvious that the Gestapo had them
all rounded up before nightfall. Those who made it onto a train faired little
better. Then he said those who chose less obvious ways had the highest probability
of success.
The film cautioned about forming up in large groups.
The fewer the better seemed to be the message. And even better yet, you should
strike out on your own, when you got the chance; anything to keep it simple.
He told Rasmussen about one crewmember who succeeded
in getting back. He remembered how it was done. He said the incident was
not only worth knowing about, but at the same time, it was very entertaining:
This fellow, after several false starts, which
almost got him captured, stumbled upon a bicycle. He did not know what else
to do so he started pedaling away. He was in plain sight of everybody and
he expected to be stopped at any moment. But it did not happen. Not the first
or the second day either, for that matter. And to his great surprise, it
did not happen at all. He worked his way across France, waving at German
sentries and people working in the fields. Dozens of patrols passed him without
even giving him a second glance. He made an effort to appear conspicuous,
and by doing so, he blended into the background of the towns and villages
he passed through. He foraged for food at night, and he even milked a cow
he found loitering nearby, in a field where he planned to sleep.
In his case, he told Rasmussen, he could not ride
a bicycle. He could not even walk. So the first order of business, after
Henri left him, was to figure out a way to use his swollen leg. He stayed
put, as he had been instructed to do, for two days. When it became obvious
that he was on his own, and his food supply was getting low, he looked around
for something with which to build a crutch. He found a suitable tree limb
and then spent most of the day whittling and scraping. Not only must it be
functional but also it could not be conspicuous either, he said.
Rasmussen interrupted him to ask him if he knew
what had happened to Henri. The Colonel told him that just hours before he
decided to move towards civilization, he heard the rattle of a machine gun
in the distance. He never knew, he said, whether Henri killed his pursuers,
or they killed him.
He made a simple splint to keep his knee from bending.
He did not want anyone to question him about it, so he placed the splint
inside his trousers. His plan was to let the French think he was a returned
war veteran. If anyone asked, he was going to say simply, Le Gare. These
few words would convey the idea and would not be enough for them to detect
an accent. And since he could get the jist of most conversations, he intended
to just nod his head.
German patrols, who routinely checked papers, could
not speak as well as he could. If he was confronted by them, and found himself
in some kind of a situation, he intended to speak rapidly. He did not intend
to pay much attention to what he was saying. He expected them to catch a
few words, enough to understand that he was trying to get to the next town,
and that shrapnel had shattered his knee.
It worked too, he told Rasmussen. They always wanted
to appear more knowledgeable in the language than they really were these
German soldiers. So if his papers were in order, they acted as though they
understood, and they let him pass. It had happened several times. And after
his first encounter and he had gotten control of himself, he suspected he
might say anything as long as it was French.
He hobbled along for several days on a road that
paralleled the Garonne. And then when he thought he could walk no further,
he came upon a fisherman, who was the owner of a small very old and dilapidated
rowboat. St Ives acted like he could not talk, because of a throat wound.
He pointed to his throat and then to his knee and mumbled a very guttural
Le Gare. The Frenchman understood. And then he asked St Ives how he could
help him. He pointed to his boat and to his fishing pole and then he fidgeted
around in his pocket for the money Elaine’s mother and Henri had given him.
The Frenchman told him he did not want to sell. And anyway, he said he did
not have nearly enough. He then paused, as though he was about to change
his mind, and then asked if he had something else of value, maybe some cigarettes?
St Ives shook his head and then he thought about the pistol that Henri had
left him. The Frenchmen knew it was worth much more than the boat. So much
more that St Ives thought an even trade would cause him to suspect he was
not who he said he was. He realized he might be in danger of being reported,
so he nodded his head, indicating to the fishermen that he wanted something
back in return. He had some francs, which he offered St Ives, who hoped it
was enough to make the transaction appear to be legitimate.
At any rate, he told Rasmussen, he had no choice.
He hurriedly accepted the fishing pole that was offered to boot, when St
Ives hesitated. And then he acknowledged the trade by shaking the Frenchman’s
hand. He untied the boat and paddled out into the slow moving current, leaving
the man on the bank with a slightly quizzical expression on his face.
The Frenchman walked along side of him for several
yards and then motioned him to come back to the bank. He told him he had something
else to say to him that was of considerable importance. St Ives complied
by tossing a line to him that was coiled up in the bottom of the boat. The
Frenchman gestured for him to climb out and have lunch with him. They tied
up the boat and sat in the shade. His new friend, or so he hoped, gave him
a piece of his bread and a large slice of cheese and he opened a bottle of
wine he had been dangling over the side of the boat.
The Frenchman began to speak and to immediately
allay St Ives fears that he was anything but a Free French sympathizer. He
told him he knew who he was. He said he suspected an American, even one that
spoke fairly good French, who was this close to the trail over the mountains,
was a downed airman. He said it was quite obvious he was going to try to
use the boat to get to Bordeaux. Furthermore, St Ives could forget about
being turned over to the Vichy. True, he would receive an award. But turning
him in would no doubt place him in jeopardy of his life. You see, he said,
the Resistance knew just about everything that took place as far as the Gestapo
and the Vichy Police were concerned. If he were to turn him in for a bounty,
both he and his family would no doubt be shot before St Ives would. So he
said if he would relax and tell him what his plan was for escape, he would
try to help him with information, which could be essential for his survival.
St Ives was cautious about the offer being made.
But there was no doubt the Frenchman knew who he was and a continuance of
the charade was pointless.
He told him he had no immediate plans. The only
one he had, he said, was to use the boat to get near the Atlantic and then
to possibly get aboard a ship belonging to a neutral country. He said it
had been done before. But, he told him; he had not been planning anything
so daring until he just now saw the boat.
The Frenchman was not going to help him until he
saw the pistol. Then he realized the American could just as easily have shot
him. That way he would have had the boat free and there would have been no
danger of being reported. All things considered, the Frenchman said, he was
indebted to St Ives. And he was, therefore, prepared to give him any help
he could.
St Ives was elated. His friend presented a case
weighing heavily in his favor. He figured he could be trusted, anyway the
odds of getting much further without some kind of help, were too much against
him.
Look, the Frenchman said. It is obvious you cannot
walk more than a few miles on that leg so you must use the boat. But you
have a long and dangerous journey ahead of you. We are on the headwaters
of the Garonne River. It flows from up there in the mountains 400 kilometers
to the Dordogne where it becomes the swift and treacherous Gironde. There
it opens up quite wide, becoming a tidal river before disappearing into the
ocean.
But the big problem with the Gironde is that the
entire estuary empties and refills with the tide. This is very important.
It means there is a much stronger current running, first one way and then
the other. It is more dangerous than anything that you will find here. The
current is rather swift though on this river after it is joined by several
more good-sized streams. But after that you will have a long rest where it
flows thru rather flat farmland country for a distance of some 50 kilometers.
The current becomes stronger and then subsides again until after you pass
Toulouse. After that it picks up before it reaches Agen about another 140
kilometers down stream. There are a few dams along the way but they will
be no problem; you will have no trouble with this boat. But if you have any
problem at all it will be if you are asleep when you go over one of them.
Then you might get a rude awakening.
St Ives interrupted him to say that he came up
from a town, probably Agen, on a barge and the current did not seem to be
too strong.
The Frenchman smiled and then told him that he
had not been on the Garonne but the Lateral Canal. He said mostly motorized
barges and horse drawn boats used the canal. He said it ran parallel with
the river and was located about a mile east. He went on to say that it had
over 50 locks, which reduced the current to almost nothing. He told him he
was glad St Ives had brought the subject up, because after he had been drifting
on the Garonne for a few days, he was going to be tempted to switch to the
canal. But he cautioned him against it, because the locks were sometimes
guarded. And often, anyone not recognized by the guards was checked, he said.
In this case, the guards were Vichy Police, and his accent would be easily
recognizable. But there are no locks on the river proper and, therefore,
no such danger, he told him.
He said his best opportunity to get provisions
would be to tie up at one of several floating docks he would see before entering
Toulouse proper. He said it did not make much difference which one he chose,
since a Vichy sympathizer might be running any one of them. I cannot help
you there, he said.
The best I can do for you now is to give you the
rest of my food and wine. He told him the water was safe to drink and would
be until it mixed with the Lot River further on down stream. He said he was
about two miles above St. Martory now and about 120 kilometers from Toulouse.
They sat and talked for another half-hour. St Ives
was reluctant to go and the Frenchman understood. Then he said something
to St Ives, as though it were an afterthought. You know there is another
way you might consider. The Canal du Medi intersects the Garonne at Toulouse.
It runs the other way to the Mediterranean. The problem is getting somebody
to let you travel with him on his barge. There are many locks between there
and the sea. And anybody caught with you will be shot for a traitor. So,
I guess, perhaps your original plan is the best. But you have a long time
to think about it. Then too, when you get used to the river, you will have
a better idea of whether you want to chance the Gironde.
Speaking of the Gironde, he said, your best bet
to get out of France is on a Swedish freighter. Spanish will do just as well,
though, he said. But you have it figured right; your only hope is to get
aboard a neutral vessel. The size does not particularly matter; just so long
as it is leaving France and does not put in at a German controlled port.
St Ives asked him what chance he thought he had
if there were no neutral vessels in the estuary when he got there? You mean,
he asked, what kind of chance will you have if the current takes you to sea?
Well you will not have a problem with breakers but you will run into some
very large swells and choppy water if you catch the tide wrong. Either way,
it will take several hours after you enter the ocean before the current carries
you past the mouth of the estuary. What ever you do, it is going to be dicey.
There is one big problem that we have not discussed,
he said. The Allied Air Forces make low-level sweeps and high altitude raids
on Bordeaux all the time. For that reason, a captain does not want to bring
his ship up into the river during daylight, nor does he want to get caught
in the open ocean during the day. Whatever you are going to see if you see
anything at all, will be at night. And with a real strong current running,
you are going to have a tough time getting aboard. If they see you, they
will no doubt help you. But you can bet all hands will be turned too. They
may not even have a lookout. What is the use, he told him. There will be
no lights showing, anyway. They will be in one big hurry to get their cargo
off loaded and to get out of there.
The only way you are going to succeed is to plan
ahead and to anticipate the worst, which is to float out to sea a couple
of miles until the current brings you around and into some place near San
Sabastian. It has been tried many times by Frenchman, who wanted to join
up with De Gaul. And yes, many have gotten messages back. So we know it has
been done.
My last word to you is not to panic. If you can
keep up your courage, and just go along with the current, you have a chance.
With this last statement, he stood up and thanked
him for what he was doing for France. And then he shook his hand and walked
away.
St Ives could tell that Rasmussen was very interested
in what was going to happen next. And he remembered the look on his face
with a kind of nostalgia, as he sat reminiscing, and watching the people
of the Swiss city walking by. He was aware that if things worked the way
he had them planned, he might never see his friend again.
He remembered finishing the story. But he could
not remember whether it was at that time or later. Anyway, he told Rasmussen,
he began floating down the river to Saint-Girons. Here the river was quite
shallow and very fast. It was only suited to rafting and swallow draft sturdy
boats like the one he had just purchased. When he was not fighting the current,
he lay basking in the warm spring sun. From time to time he would awaken
from his doze to set the prow back into the center of the river, which was
now becoming busier with small boats. But he knew when he reached Toulouse,
he was going to start seeing larger craft, like the one that brought him
up to Toulouse. He realized he was going to have to pay closer attention,
or run the risk of being sunk
He told Rasmussen he was
getting low on food and water so he planned to take the Frenchman’s advise
and pull in at Toulouse. But he had no real idea of how much further it was.
He had been passing thru some of the most beautiful
countryside in the world. This part of France had not been torn apart by
the armies of World War 1. And they would remain pristine for another two
months before the Invasion. But for now, he viewed the lazy float trip as
being one of the best times of his life. One day followed another and he
actually could not remember how far he had come. He would tie-up to a branch
along the riverbank at night and then move out into the stream several dozen
yards after the sun came up. He seldom used his oars, letting the river do
the work. When somebody looked him over closely from the bank, he would dangle
his pole into the water. He would make believe he was float fishing, just
like on the Snake River in Idaho.
One morning about sun-up, he saw a large city.
He suspected it was Toulouse. He saw a floating wharf projecting out into
the river and he made to tie-up. The swelling in his knee had almost subsided.
But he knew it would return if he did any more serious walking. He did not
intend to. All he wanted was some provisions and some water. And he hoped
he could find a store close by. He wanted to make his purchases and be on
his way. But it did not work out that way, he told Rasmussen.
When pressed for details, St Ives told him he had
removed the splint from his knee, but retained the makeshift crutch, as he
climbed the ladder up to the dock. He pulled the boat back fifty yards or
so and hid it against the bank underneath some shrubs. He walked back to
the wharf and entered a bait shop of some kind. He went into his now rehearsed
act about being unable to speak. He paid the proprietor a small tie-up fee
and then with sign language inquired where and how far it was to a shop that
sold food. The shopkeeper told him in rapid French that it was about two
blocks away. But when he saw his crutch, he suggested he consider stopping
on the corner about a half-block away and taking a cab. St Ives nodded a
thank you and went out the door. But for some reason, he told Rasmussen,
he thought the bait man was acting rather strangely. Then on impulse, he
turned around and went back. He was in time to see him dialing the telephone.
He did not hesitate. He knew instinctively he had not bought his act and
that he was calling the Vichy police. With out hesitation, he struck the
man on the head with his heavy crutch. And as he fell forward on the counter,
he struck him again.
He said he did not know what to do. If he left
him and got back in his boat he would be sure to be picked up. He did not
want to kill the man. But he said he would if needs be. He could not just
leave him. So he dialed Madame LeFevbre, without thinking about whether or
not it was a good idea. She came on the phone immediately. And when she heard
his voice. She told him to give her the address of the bait shop. And then
she hung up without saying another word. A scant ten minutes later, a 1937
Citroen classic, with a white inverted “V” painted on the grill, pulled up
to the wharf. Two of Madame’s men loaded the proprietor into the back seat
and then invited St Ives to join them.
He remembered the fine meal that night and the
down mattress he slept on. The next morning, before the sun was up, he climbed
back into her automobile and was driven back to that same wharf. His boat
was still in place and the closed sign was still hanging in the door window.
All was quiet, as he kissed Madame good-by on both cheeks. She had become
extremely friendly the night before, after he told her his plan. She realized
immediately that he did not intend to become a burden to her. And so there
was no need for her to devise an alternate route, with all the attending
dangers. The point was moot anyway, because anything short of a train trip
to Bordeaux, required miles of walking, which she realized, was out of the
question. And anyway, the trip to the coast by train was too dangerous. She
had never heard of escaping to Bordeaux by rowboat before. But when she heard
about the details of his plan, she smiled and pronounced it to be good, maybe
even masterful. It was then he felt relief. He was not going to come missing
after all, as he suspected the shop proprietor would.
They did not speak about Henri. He preferred to
think he perished or that he had at least done everything he could to help
him. At any rate, he was not high on his list of people he wanted to meet
again, so he let the matter lie.
Rasmussen asked him if he suspected Madame was
going to really let him go? There was still the danger of you falling into
the wrong hands and exposing her organization, he said. Why then would she
bother to let you go? He asked the question much like an attorney would ask
a witness.
I thought a lot about it, he answered, and I thought
a lot about what Henri had told me.
What did you do, just paddle on out and hope for
the best?
No. I loaded the supplies she gave me into the
boat. I stayed hidden that day and the next, waiting. If she was going to
send her people looking for me, they were going to wait until they could
see me coming down stream before they paddled out to intercept me. Of course,
when I did not come by the first night, I rather suspect they thought I had
crossed over to the far side of the river. But I had no idea if they knew
anything about what Henri had told me.
I waited until the next night just to be sure and
then I did paddle directly across the river. I had to point the bow almost
up stream and then I had to pull hard on the oars in order to keep from floating
down to where I suspected they were waiting for me, he said.
The city of Toulouse is built up on both sides
of the river. He told Rasmussen that when he got close, he changed his disguise
from a fisherman to somebody who was just interested in proceeding thru the
city via the river.
The river traffic started to subside as he again
came into farmland surrounding both banks. He said he was hugging the West
Bank as best he could. He said he was scared to death, because he could not
get the conversation with Henri out of his mind. The river was becoming broader
as several large streams emptied into it. But he was still well within easy
rifle range, if somebody on the far side wanted to do him in.
He said he was floating along thinking he had misjudged
Madame and her people when a shot rang-out. And then there was another. This
time a rifle bullet made a small hole a few inches above the water line and
narrowly missing his outstretched leg. When he heard a third shot, and the
bullet zipped by his head, he fell sideways into the water and held on to
the boat for protection.
And then much to his surprise he heard the distinctive
sound of a German machine pistol and then everything was quiet.
Why would the Germans shoot the people following
you, Rasmussen asked him?
I don’t know if they were Germans? He said. In
fact, to this day, I have no idea who it was? All I know is that the firing
from the East Bank stopped as quickly as it started. I always thought it
was Henri, who had been following along looking out for my interests. You
know there is more than an implied relationship between guides and their
patrons in Europe, he remarked. It is well understood among alpine guides.
But maybe not so strong among the wartime mountain guides, who were mostly
shepherds. Still, he said, he thought he and Henri had become good friends.
And for sure, Henri did not approve of Madame’s tactics. The killing of an
American officer in cold blood was something that might be rather difficult
to cover-up. Then too, the war was winding down for the French. And who wanted
to become involved in this kind of business at this late date. So maybe it
was Henri after all. But for sure, he said, it was somebody.
Rasmussen asked him if he thought Henri might have
been planning to ask him for a personal favor, like sponsoring him for citizenship
or something like that.
St Ives told him there was always that possibility.
But nothing ever came of it if he did, he said.
He remembered telling his friend that for the longest
time he thought the Resistance had abandoned him on purpose. And in later
years when he became depressed, he actually came to believe that it had been
planned all along. He thought that his game leg had been just the excuse
Henri had been looking for. And maybe even British Intelligence wanted him
out of the way at that point. He knew for a fact they did not want the story
to surface again later, if the plan was other than that which he had been
briefed. And something else, he told Rasmussen, he could never understand,
at the time, why the Allies divulged the Normandy Invasion Plans to the Vichy
by sending him over there in the first place.
British Intelligence did
have a parochial interest in protecting their various schemes, which involved
the Resistance. And it was no secret, he told Rasmussen, that the Resistance
was riddled with traitors to France. The whole story had never been told
and the French people preferred it that way. So here again was another potential
source of embarrassment, if he were allowed to return to England.
And what better way to reinforce the German mind-set
about the whole thing then for you to get shot, Rasmussen commented.
That’s right, he said. I wondered for years after,
if perhaps there might have been enemy spies reporting back to Germany. Certainly,
if I did not come back, they would report the fact that this was further evidence
the Invasion was coming at Pas de Calais and not Normandy, as he had been
so eager to tell them?
Anyway, he remarked to Rasmussen, there was a half-dozen
scenarios he came up with while he continued floating down river. All of
them were quite plausible. Everybody’s interest would be best served if he
never returned to England. At least that is how he saw it. And he would continue
thinking and worrying about it well after the war was over. The need to confide
in somebody became almost too much at times. The person he should have been
talking to was his wife, and on some level his son, but that just never happened.
So, as he sat at the sidewalk table in Switzerland,
he could not help but think how he was going to miss the conversations he
had over the years with his friend Rasmussen.
He went around to the bank
the next morning and he was assured that his funds were in order. True, the
interest rate was considerably lower in Switzerland, but his money, as far
as the US was concerned, had all but disappeared. And with a two million dollar
principal, the tax-free interest would guarantee him a comfortable living.
A week later, he was awakened from an afternoon
nap by a knock on his door. It was the investigator, who announced that he
was prepared to brief him and to submit his formal report.
He began by telling him the good news. Elaine was
a widow who still lived in Chateauroux. She had inherited the Catherine Wheel
from her Mother and had sold it two years ago when the old building became
too expensive to maintain. After the Americans left, the restaurant had fallen
on hard times and was just barely breaking even.
After she sold the hotel, she opened some kind
of shop about two blocks away. She was in good health and was the mother
of two grown children.
He paid the agent the remaining money he owed him
and then retained him for another trip to France.
He returned to the bank the next day and talked
to his friend. He asked him for a safety deposit box and was given one gratis
for life. He then executed another document making Elaine co-owner. Inside
the box, he left a letter to her and enclosed the number of his bank account.
The banker was given instructions to open the box
and to contact Elaine in the event of his death or incapacitation. His written
instructions read that he was to presume one or the other, in the event that
he was not contacted by a letter or a telegram, at least every two months.
Otherwise, if all was in order, he was to make monthly interest payments
at a place St Ives would specify at a later date.
The banker could not help but feel that his client
might be in some kind of trouble. He prided himself on being a rather keen
judge of people with a lot on their mind. This was particularly true of Americans,
who usually banked with the Swiss when they were interested in secluding
large sums of money from their government. But this American was somehow
different. There was something about the way he was trying to cover his tracks,
which made the banker believe he might be in serious trouble.
The purpose of the investigators second trip was
to make contact with Elaine. He was to explain these things to her and to
give her the name and telephone number of the banker in Lucerne. He was also
asked to give her a copy of a Trust to pass on to Elaine with an explanation
that she was the trustee and that her children were the beneficiaries of
his estate. He also gave him a personal letter for her expressing his love.
And he told her he would be seeing her soon.
Chapter 10 California, 1970
When he was suffering most from depression, there
were a number of times when he was not thinking too rationally. It was during
one of these times that he settled upon what he thought was a foolproof plan.
He would rid himself of the depression demons plaguing him, and at the same
time, it would insure him that his wife would never receive more than a monthly
stipend from the Government.
It was the simplest, that was for sure, he told
himself. And in his confused state, it was perhaps the best he could come
up with.
He had been thinking about taking his own life.
That is how strongly he felt about depriving his family of their continuing
life of privilege that his hard work had provided for them. But if he was
a professional planner, as he held himself out to be, having worked with
the Nation’s War Plan for fifteen years, then on second thought, he ought
to be able to come-up with something better than that.
But after his strange but vivid encounter with
Elaine, any such course of action was out of the question. For the first
time, he knew exactly what he was going to do, having put the first stage
of his plan into operation. And now he approached life with a new found enthusiasm,
having put the idea out of his head forever.
A week after he came back
from Switzerland, he drove out to the Palm Springs area. He nosed around
several small airports until he found a helicopter pilot who had a reputation
for being skilled while not being too particular where he employed those
skills.
He gave the man one thousand dollars cash with
a promise of another thousand when the job was finished. He had to agree
to listen to his proposition though. If he did not like the idea, he could
keep the money and he would be sworn to secrecy.
He agreed, which came as no big surprise to St
Ives.
He then went to the local blood bank and told them
that his doctor had told him he suffered from something sounding like hemochromiosis.
He said he had read in a magazine where men with this condition had an abnormally
high incidence of heart attacks. The only way you could keep it under control,
he told them, was to give blood frequently. This, he said, reduced the amount
of iron in the blood, and kept it under control.
The problem was, he said, he had hepatitis once
in his life, and that made his blood contaminated. They confirmed all he
had told them. But they were quick to point out why there was nothing they
could do for him.
He told them he would pay for the extraction at
the going rate, or if they preferred, he would make a substantial donation
of money. He would even volunteer some of his friends, he said.
This was not the first such request they had received,
since the recent study had been published. And they said they expected their
policy to change sometime soon.
After talking some more, they told him they were
quite busy. But, they said they would remove 500 cc. They refused to take
any money, probably, he thought, because they had no accounting procedures
in place.
He watched closely as the technician made the collection
bag ready. He watched the man on the next bed to see how they shut-off the
bag before they removed the needle. When his own bag was a few minutes from
being full, he waited until no one was watching, and then he removed the
needle, undid the bag, and slipped out with the bag under the sweater he
was carrying. He strolled out into the parking lot, bypassing the ladies
with the punch and cookies in the next room. He opened the door to his new
light pick-up truck and stored the sweater and the sealed bag behind the seat.
He had purchased the truck a few months before.
He had traded in his older second car for the truck, telling himself he would
use it to go back and forth to work. After he retired, he would give it to
his son, who was about the age to get his license. But even as he thought
it, he knew it would never happen. He had no intentions of ever giving the
lad anything again. And as he thought about it, he was reminded all over
again of how hard he had worked for his first automobile. And there was no
doubt about it, if his son was ever to own a car or anything else, he was
going to have to earn it.
He went to a sporting goods store and told them
he was going to take up camping as a new hobby. He asked them to lay out
all the things he would need, such as a tent, cot, stove, and lamps. When
he left, he had all the trappings of a real enthusiast. He loaded all his
new gear into his truck along with an old motor scooter, which he had stored
in the back of his garage.
When he was a boy he had bought an old scooter
and overhauled the engine with the help of his older brothers. He rode it
all over, preferring it to a horse, which was the mode of transportation
used by his friends. He rode it to school in the spring and the fall and
he even tried it once or twice without much success, when he missed the bus
in the winter.
He was feeling nostalgic once, two years back,
when he saw an old scooter advertised for sale. He bought it on a whim with
the idea of fixing it up. He thought it might be a good project for him and
the boy to do together. He figured he would teach him a little bit about
engines and the two of them would have some fun riding it around. But it
worked out the same way all of their other mutual projects had worked out.
That is to say, it did not work at all. His son had no interest in mechanics
and no interest in spending time with his father. He preferred his friends
and hanging out doing absolutely nothing, further eroding his father’s respect
for him.
He thought about selling the scooter a couple of
times but he never got around to it. He was glad he had kept it; he had a
use for it now, that was for sure. But he had to know it would work when
it was needed.
He had gone ahead and made the necessary repairs
to put it in running order years ago but it had been sitting collecting dust.
So it was anybody’s guess whether it would run.
He took the carburetor apart and cleaned the fuel
lines. And then he pulled the spark plug and cleaned that. When he fired
it up, it ran with no problem. He adjusted the needle valve so that it would
not over heat. When he was satisfied, he loaded it in the truck with his
other equipment.
He had one last thing to do, and that was to have
a tooth looked into, which did not feel just right every once in a while.
But if it didn’t start aching, he knew he would procrastinate until it did.
Chapter 11
An automobile pulled alongside the curb in front
of St Ives house. Two men dressed in coats and ties sat in the front seat.
They sat for two or three minutes before either one spoke and then a brief
conversation ensued. It appeared as though they might be rehearsing a scene,
which would be played out momentarily.
The doors of the car opened and both of them emerged
with brief- cases in hand. They moved easily thru the maze of junk out in
front of his place, as though they may have been athletes.
They stepped upon his porch and rang the bell several
times. Finally the door cracked open and she asked them what they wanted.
“My name is Special Agent Welker of the Air Force
Office of Special Investigation and this is Special Agent Franklin of the
FBI,” he said.
“What do you want with me?” She asked them with
a hint of irritation in her voice.
“If you are Mrs. St Ives, we would like to ask
you some questions.”
“What about?”
“May we come in?”
“Now is not a good time,” she said rather coolly.
“Would you rather come down to the office?” Franklin
asked her, leaving no doubt by the tone of his voice that they might becoming
a little out of patience with her attitude already. “We will wait until you
get dressed.”
She opened the door and stood aside. As they walked
in, they looked at each other knowingly. They could see at a glance why she
was hesitant to invite them in. The place was a shambles. Not merely in disarray
but it was in need of a thorough cleaning. They could see into the kitchen
area as they stepped thru the living room. Dirty dishes were strewn around
and an empty liquor bottle was sitting on the cabinet.
They sat down without being asked. They had no intentions
of being intimidated by what they had been briefed to expect was a domineering
woman.
“What exactly do you want with me?”
Franklin asked her, “When was the last time you
saw your husband?”
“So that’s what this is all about. He went gallivanting
up to Idaho to see his worthless brothers. Nutty as fruitcakes, the whole
bunch of them if you ask me. Oh, a couple, no, maybe three weeks ago. I don’t
know. Actually, I have seen him since then. Now that I think about it, he
went up there for awhile and then he took off again. I haven’t seen him since.
Don’t tell me he has gotten himself lost or worse. It wouldn't surprise me
any. He goes around half the time in a daze.”
Welker asked her if he had said goodbye or if he
had told her where he was going.
“No he didn’t.”
“Didn’t you think that’s strange?” Franklin asked
her.
“He was always doing something strange. For instance,
don’t you think it’s strange that a grown man runs off without saying anything?
And when he comes back weeks later, he starts playing around with a motor
scooter? What exactly is this about anyway?”
“We have reason to believe he is missing,” said
Welker.
“What has that to do with you guys? I thought things
like that were the business of the cops. Anyway, I haven’t reported anything
to anybody so what’s the fuss?”
Both of them wondered about her lack of interest
in his welfare, as though she knew something that she was not telling them.
Why had she not asked straight away if there was a possibility that he had
been injured? Why no showing of any outward emotion? Either they were dealing
with a very cold person or she was mixed up in something that might yet turn
out to be something she could be held for as a material witness, or worse
yet, an accomplice.
“Mrs. St Ives, what do you know about what your
husband did while he was on active duty?” Welker, who was a Commissioned Officer
and a plain-clothes agent, asked her, as he prepared to take over this part
of the questioning.
“I never knew or particularly cared.”
“Well then, let me tell you. Have you ever heard
of the SIOP?”
“What’s that?”
“Skip it for now. I‘ll come back to it later.”
“Mrs. St Ives, is there any reason why your husband
might want to fake his death and then disappear? Before you answer, I would
like agent Franklin here to read you your Miranda rights. Do you know what
that is?”
“Sure she replied flippantly, I watch TV.”
“Just the same,” said Franklin, as he began to
read her the rights against self-incrimination.
Her eyes began to brighten as she took a new interest
in the conversation. “Did Ed really try to make you think he killed himself?”
“We think so.”
“Why?”
“We were hoping you could tell us,” said Franklin.
The demeanor of both agents had taken on a sense
of urgency from the time they walked in. It was all out of proportion to
a regular missing person’s inquiry. As far as she was concerned, something
like this should have been handled as routine. And given his track record
for eccentricity, it should be all the more reason to be low profile. But
she was beginning to suspect that something might be radically wrong. She
did not have the slightest interest in his whereabouts. But if anything had
happened to him that might have caused his death, well that was another matter
entirely. She knew about the widows Survivor Benefit Program and she knew
it was substantial but it was several steps down from her present financial
position. Still there was nothing to get excited about, she told herself.
But she better start playing things closer to the
vest. If there was anything amiss that involved high-level security, they
might just try to hang something on her, she thought.
“Mrs. St Ives,” Franklin continued, “let me tell
you what we know and then you tell us what you know and then we will get
out of your hair for now. But we are in a tremendous hurry. If you know anything
about what we have been talking about, I would strongly recommend you tell
us. If we think you are holding back or if we think you have played a role
in any of this affair, we will arrest you immediately. Do you understand
us?”
Welker began by telling
her that the SIOP was the most highly classified plan the Air Force had.
He said that it was an acronym for Single Integrated Operations Plan and those
that worked with it possessed a Top Secret Crypto Security Clearance.
“Because of this, he might have been abducted or
he might have met with some other kind of foul play. Somebody might have
taken him and tortured him. They might have killed him and then staged a
suicide, after they got what they wanted, to cover their tracks.”
“Is Ed really dead? Have you been kidding me? What
are you guys up to anyway?” She asked them with the sound of absolute shock
in her voice.
“They have to find him and prove him dead before
they stop his retirement pay don’t they? Are you telling me that somebody
killed him and that you can’t find him? How long have you been looking for
him?”
“We are telling you nothing of the kind,” continued
Franklin.
“Well that’s a relief,” she said with a sigh. “Don’t
scare me like that.”
They both looked at each other. They were working-up
more and more of a dislike for her.
“Do you know,” Welker asked, “that he redeemed
his paid-up NSLI life insurance policy and a twenty thousand-dollar annuity
he had been carrying on the children?”
“He did that? He can do that?”
“I am afraid so,” one of them replied.
“And then he closed out your joint checking and
savings accounts, as well. All you apparently have left, is a few hundred
dollars in your personal account,” said the other one.
“That is really none of our business but you should
be aware that you’re going to be writing some hot checks.” Franklin told
her, with just the trace of a smile on his face.
All of a sudden it dawned on them both: what they
were actually investigating was a family who had a husband and father who
had abandoned them. Still, they could not rule out certain behavioral patterns
that smacked of defection for a large sum of money.
“Mrs. St Ives do you know a Major Rasmussen?” Welker
asked her.
“ I know his wife. Why?”
“Well your husband mailed him a letter. But actually
it could have come from anybody. Do you know of any reason why your husband
would not have wanted you and your children to attend his funeral?”
“You can consider that letter authentic, if that’s
what you’re getting at. That sounds just like him.”
“Anyway, it gives Rasmussen power of attorney to
dispose of your husband’s personal items and to see that he is properly buried,”
he said.
They suspected that when Rasmussen contacted them
about St Ives suicide story, they might be involved in a case of sell-out
and defection. The information that St Ives had was still current and it
involved highly sensitive procedures regarding command and control of the
Strategic Air Command’s bombers and missiles. He was also an authority on
the SIOP as well as NATO plans.
They had to assume, until it could be proven otherwise,
he had been kidnapped or that he had defected. Because of the large sum of
money, which had recently passed from Idaho to Switzerland, it had to be a
consideration. All they had to go on at this point though, were preliminary
reports from agents working in Europe.
Franklin had never worked on this type of investigation
before. In answer to his question to Welker about why time was of the essence,
Welker explained to him that when an officer with St Ives’ security clearance
disappears under suspicious circumstances, a Red Flag alert sets in motion
a series of events. The Air Force and the Central Intelligence Agency are
eager to find out, as quickly as possible, if any procedures affecting the
War Plan have been compromised.
These kinds of alerts are infrequent. But when
they do occur, a whole host of agents from other organization are available
to support the OSI thru the first few hours. Once it has been determined
that no damage has been done, support diminishes accordingly.
Welker and Franklin, working as part of a composite
team, saw as their immediate objective, the breaking of the news to her about
her husband. They planned to do it in such a way as to determine her duplicity,
if any. She might also have information that might tell them exactly what
he was up too. How they intended to go about doing this in the shortest possible
time was what they were discussing in the car. So far, she had not told them
much. And they had to confess, they were not completely prepared for her
“do not care” attitude.
If he had not defected, there was still a question
of whether any laws had been broken. But assuming he was still alive, was
it a crime to stage your death just to stop payment of your retirement pay
to your spouse?
“The Government must suffer a loss.” Franklin,
who was a lawyer, volunteered his opinion to Welker. “There has to have been
some kind of fraud perpetrated.”
“Yeah, the only fraud perpetrated here is on her
and I don’t care,” added Welker.
The two of them had read the dossier on St Ives
that had been put together by several security agencies over the years. The
one thing that stood out was the temperament of his wife and their poor relationship.
Welker commented that it was so poor as to be a
problem with getting the clearance. But they also recognized that parts of
it had been indexed with a code indicating there were extenuating circumstances.
When Welker explained this to Franklin, he made the comment that he wondered
what it could be. And then, as an after thought, he asked Franklin, who wasn’t
sure what he was talking about, if he had any ideas.
The two of them had been
whispering while she went to put on some clothes. She had been sitting there
in front of them in her negligee, trying unsuccessfully to keep them from
staring at her. But she was far from stirring the imagination of either one.
Later, one would remark to the other how thankful he was. He said she guessed
she had no idea what a spectacle she was making of herself. Maybe, the other
one said, with a certain lack of graciousness, she thought she was pretty
sexy.
While she was still out of the room, Welker told
his partner that it looked to him as though whatever the Colonel had in mind;
he botched the job.
“Mrs. St Ives,” Franklin began again as she sat
down, this is apparently what happened.
“He went to Switzerland after he saw his brothers.
We now know he deposited a large sum of money while he was there.”
She interrupted him to ask how much.
“In the neighborhood of two million dollars,” said
Franklin.
“Nice neighborhood” replied Welker, trying to be
funny.
But all of a sudden the fiery temper they had read
about in the security dossier asserted itself. She swore an oath and then
lit into Welker. She told him to grow up and to shut up, if he could not
be more professional.
She was not mad at him as much as she was her husband.
She had been snookered and the large sum they referred to was from his inheritance
not from any defect money. In an instant, she realized that the odds of getting
her hands on any of it was nil; once it was squirreled away in Switzerland,
it was gone.
“How do you know how much it is?” She asked Franklin,
who had been doing most of the talking.
Franklin told her they had people getting the necessary
legal papers to force the Idaho bank to reveal the exact amount. But the
tally was off considerably from the amount his brothers told agents in Idaho
was deposited and the amount that one teller told the FBI had been transferred.
“He went to Switzerland, because we know that he
bought a first class ticket there. And we know he transferred some mutual
fund money to a bank in Lucerne. The possibility that all of it was not from
a mutual fund is what has us worried.
“If you know something, feel free to jump right
in,” Franklin said to her.
She was still quite angry and would not speak.
That was all right, because as long as she remained reluctant to talk to
them, they would suspect her of knowing something, she thought. She did not
of course. But if they thought she did, then they might suspect the whole
thing was far more complicated then it was. In the meantime, as long as they
suspected them of doing something real bad, they would continue to look for
him. That was her only chance of ever recovering any money. But just how
that was going to take place, she had not figured out yet. Things were just
happening too fast to suit her.
“Mrs. St Ives, do you know where the extra money
came from? Unless it was from a pay-off, you would have had to know. Remember
what I told you about going to jail for obstructing an investigation?” Franklin
warned her once again.
“We are just trying to find out whether we have
a case of espionage here or just another screwed-up marriage. If you get
my meaning,” exclaimed Welker.
She shot right back at him, “Oh, I get it all right
but I don’t like it.”
“We don’t care a whit what you like or don’t like
but my patience is wearing thin,” said Franklin.
She did not reply but her body language indicated
that she was becoming less aggressive. She wanted to talk to an attorney
but she did not have the slightest idea what about.
Franklin continued on with his story in the hopes
that he might say something that would trigger a reaction from her, which
might in turn lead to something. “After he came back from Europe, he hired
a helicopter. It picked him up way out in the desert and flew him to a spot
on a road. He had a motor bike or scooter stashed out there. We know this
because we found where he had it hidden and we saw the tracks. Anyway, he
used it to get back to civilization.”
“Why, what for? I mean what was he doing out there
in the desert in the first place.”
“Because he wanted us to think he had killed himself,”
Welker said.
“He drove a truck about ten miles off the road,
after he unloaded his motorbike,” continued Franklin.
“Then he hung around out there for a couple of
days. He shot off a pistol and left the gun and the shell casing where we
would find it. After he did all that, he set the truck on fire. He might
have done it before he fired the gun. We don’t know all the details but it
doesn’t really matter.” Welker said.
“The only reason we can figure out for destroying
the truck, was to keep you from recovering it,” Franklin added as an after
thought.
“Now, this is what doesn’t make too much sense.
He poured a lot of blood on the ground; it was his by the way. We guess it
was to make it look like he shot himself. Then he dragged something about
the size of a body out into the desert, sprinkling some more blood along
the way, while brushing out his footprints. Then the chopper picked up him
and the thing he was dragging and hauled them both away,” said Welker.
“Why would he do all that?” She was fascinated
by the ingenuity of her husband, yet growing angrier by the minute because
she figured it was an elaborate ruse to cheat her out of what was hers.
“To make us think he was dead and the coyotes got
him,” explained Franklin.
“How do you know they didn’t?”
“Because coyotes don’t hunt in packs, at least
around here they don’t. If a couple of them found him they would have eaten
him on the spot, at least some of him. But we can’t find a single body part
and that’s where he outwitted himself.”
Welker added, “a body that big would have been
too much for a coyote or a pair of them to drag very far. No, agent Franklin
is right.”
“Yes it appears that your husband is alive and
well,” said Franklin. “Now will you tell us what you know about his whereabouts?”
Her answer to that was “so then in your report
you are going to say he is alive?”
Her mood had instantly shifted from wary and sullen
to one of exuberance and elation once she realized she was not going to have
to rely on the widow’s Survivors Benefit Program.
“I’m afraid my report, unless something changes,
will read that your husband is alive and presumed to be living out of the
country.” Franklin told her.
“But for the record, I want to ask you once again,
was your husband rat-holing a large sum of money, which would be of interest
to the IRS people and did you at any time have any knowledge of it?”
“You must be out of your mind,” she answered.
“I take that as a negative,” Franklin remarked.
“You can take it any way you like,” she said, her
old belligerence asserting it’s self once again.
She sensed that the two
agents would very much like to charge her with something. She also knew they
could not, so she did not care much what she said to them. She was beyond
their reach and she was enjoying herself. It didn’t hurt, she thought, to
know that she was going to have a satisfactory income for the rest of her
life.
“Well in that case, we will be leaving,” said Franklin,
as he nodded to his partner.
“Oh, by the way, your husband maxed out his credit
cards and he ran up a few thousand in bills that you are going to be liable
for. And, come to think of it, he intentionally missed the last payment on
your car and the truck. If you don’t look into that, they are going to repossess
the one and attach something for payment of the destroyed truck.”
Welker was determined to have the last word. As
he turned with a shrug of his shoulders, he told her that her husband never
left her a thing.
“You never had any Survivor’s Benefit like you
thought you did. Your husband never joined the program before he left the
Service.”
“Any other good news?” She asked sarcastically.
“None that I can think of,” answered Welker.
“You will be sure to let me know if you do think
of anything?”
“Count on it, Mrs. St Ives,” said the other agent.
After they left she could hardly contain herself.
She started to laugh out loud. What do I care about any lousy SBP, she told
herself.
Can you believe him, faking his death in order
get back at me? And then botching it up like that.
That stupid Ed; he can’t divorce me and he can’t
ever show his face around here again. He must owe the IRS a fortune. And
what they won’t take, if they get their hands on him, I will.
No divorce and no split, and without him around,
I’ve got one less mouth to feed, and none of his expenses. It looks like
things worked for him exactly opposite of what he had planned.
So I don’t get any of his inheritance, which by
rights is half mine, since it was earned during our marriage. So what, the
kids and me are going to be okay.
She continued telling herself how well off she
was thanks to his stupidity, as she made her way to the shower and yet another
luncheon engagement.
“Listen,” Franklin said
to Welker, as they departed, leaving her absolutely ecstatic over the way
things turned out. “There are a lot of things which don’t make sense to me
about this whole mess.
“I’ll tell you for sure, I think we are underestimating
his intelligence. I’ve got a kind of an itch deep down in my kidneys. I can’t
put my finger on it but that’s the way it is.”
“What’s bugging you anyway?” Welker asked him,
as he negotiated a turn on the way back to their office. “It’s pretty simple
the way I see it, he said.
“St Ives is just another
guy in the Service,” Welker continued, “who would have gotten ripped off
by the unfair divorce laws had he stuck around and gotten rid of her like
any body else would have. But I sense he was not much like anybody else, so
he split the way he did. Not exactly your average scenario, but then, as
I said, he is not average anything. And something else, he may not have had
both of his oars in the water, either.
“Congress, and particularly their Armed Forces
Sub-Committee, is responsible for these unfair divorce laws that really cause
a lot of problems. And that’s not the only thing. They have been jacking
around with these people for years just because they can. Let me take a minute
and tell you what I am talking about,” he said, as he parked and shut-off
the engine.
“You’ve got a gut feeling that St Ives sold out
and then split? You may be right, I won’t argue with you. What surprises
me is that it doesn’t happen more often.” Welker told him.
“I’m not defending him or anybody else but the Congress
sure doesn’t look out for his or her welfare and it’s bound to result in
some grudges.
“Let me be more specific and I think I can show
you that you have a better case than you think you do.
“Back in fifty-seven, somebody told Congress that
the Country’s balance of payments was out of whack by several billion dollars
and had been for a lot of years. Do you know what they did? Well they didn’t
do anything, really. But they figured they had to make some kind of an effort,
so they restricted overseas travel to military dependants. That meant that
some poor slob had to go overseas for a year and a half with- out his family.
The Congress figured that if they weren’t there they couldn’t spend any money.”
“You got to be kidding me” chided Franklin.
“No I’m not. I know, because I was newly commissioned
and just out of school. I had been married about three months when I was
posted overseas. While I was looking around for some place to live, my commanding
officer told me I needn’t bother looking further, because I couldn’t bring
her over.
“How was that going to appreciably help the balance
of payments?” He asked Franklin, not expecting an answer. “Do you really
think that kind of stuff endears Joe blow GI to his Government?
“I’m not kidding you. In fact, every screwball
idea that comes down the pike, the flaming liberals on the Armed Forces Sub-Committee
will try it out on the Military. Take women in the Service, for example:
Have you talked to any field commanders? They were told to make it work and
when the Congress asks them how it is going, they reply ‘just fine sir.’
What else are they going to say? The job of the Services is to kill the enemies
of this country. Do you really believe enlisting some fat little female is
going to enable some commander to do it more efficiently? Do you ever wonder
what effect that politically correct baloney has on the morale and loyalty
of men like St Ives?”
Listening to him spout off like that made Franklin
feel a closer kinship with him. Maybe, he thought, I could get to be real
friends with this guy.
“There are some other things too that keeps the
blood boiling of the St Ives of this world.” Welker started up again. “Take
the gay problem. There didn’t used to be one until that Committee got mixed
up in it. Time was, if somebody was queer we kicked him out. If he was queer
and didn’t do anything or tell anybody about it we ignored it. Quite obviously
he wasn’t queer was he? He was as welcome as the next guy. Nobody went around
playing like they were affiliated with the old Japanese Thought Police.
“Now you wait and see, sooner or later men are
going to be forced to soldier along side of the openly gay and that is going
to cause a bigger rhubarb than those dim bulbs ever believed. Yet, when some
Committee member asks how things are going they will hear, ‘just fine’ and
like as not, she will answer back, ‘see I told you.’ And then she will tell
the newspapers, ‘you see, this military business is not all that complicated.
Why anybody can run it and those know-it-all officers have just got to start
listening to a benevolent Congress, who knows what's in their best interest’
“But the big thing lately is divorce. No segment
of society has been singled out for more special attention by the Congress
on this subject than has the Military. You haven't and you’re an employee
of the Government. Why not, because your ‘Union’ wouldn’t stand for it, that's
why.
“What representation does the dogface have? It’s
supposed to be this same Armed Services Committee but they are the problem.”
Welker continued warming up to his subject. “You
know Frank, we in the OSI sweat nails that some disgruntled kid, who is making
a little more than a minimum wage, and who is sore at the Government, won’t
run into a Russian agent someday and make himself rich.
“These guys get worked over all the time. And when
they feel like throwing in the towel, what is to stop them from seeking out
some KGB agent waiting in the wings?
“You know you FBI weenies spend most of your time
chasing down criminals. We, on the other hand, see a lot of espionage stuff,
things that you can’t always put your finger on, but they are there never-the-less.
Let me give you a couple of examples and then I want to make a point.
“This sharp Captain came into my office one day
when I was working out of Headquarters, Eighth Air Force. He was down from
Thule, Greenland, on another matter. He came by my office to talk to me about
an incident of suspected espionage. He said that on New Year’s Eve around
midnight, some of his people came to him with a story about a civilian who
was working for a contractor on the Ballistic Missile Early Warning System.
He sought them out and started a conversation with them about what they were
doing up there. He thought they were drunk, or that they should have been,
and he was asking all kinds of questions they felt were very inappropriate.”
Franklin interrupted to ask him what they were
doing.
“Well they were aircraft mechanics who were part
of a support organization for a special reconnaissance unit, he said. “They
were using modified jets with special camera equipment to map Russia. We
needed more accurate maps in order to target our new ICBM’s that were still
in the production stage.
“Anyway, this guy gave himself away by asking them
questions about things that were highly classified. But in some cases they
didn’t even know about it themselves.
“Here is an American or a Canadian, who was pumping
others about one of the most classified projects we had going, and he was
doing it right on an American base. See what I mean?
“Sit still for another minute,” he said, “I want
to tell you some more. I want you to see that this is a real problem and
perhaps St Ives and his activities, if that is in fact what he is involved
with, is not so unique.
“We built a repair depot a few years back at a
place called Nouasseur outside of Casablanca. The commanding general had
a civilian working for him. He was supposed to be a facility engineer, whatever
that is. This guy either bought or made a model of what the base and it’s
facilities were going to look like when it was finished. The General was
really proud of him and his model. The guy made endless pitches to visiting
dignitaries. He created a job for himself. He became the expert on how the
thing was going to be built.
“He claimed he had to coordinate his activities
with other construction experts up in Germany, so he goes up there about
once a month for three or four days at a time. The General sees nothing wrong
with this. He figures he is just doing his job of getting ready for construction.
“On one of his trips, he falls prey to the KGB.
And when he starts going up there more often, some people back at the base
get suspicious. Another junior officer goes around the General, because he
figures this guy has him completely snowed. Well, he calls us on the radio
up in Germany and tells us of his suspicions. The next time the facility
guy comes up, he lets us know and we put a tail on him. We get pictures of
him entering and leaving the Russian Embassy.
“We arrest him with some good-sized money in his
brief case. He confesses and tells all, implicating a ring that included
some military and German civilians as well. When we asked these lower ranking
airmen we caught how they could get mixed up in these kinds of things, they
cited as reasons some of the very things I have been talking about.”
Welker paused for a second to give Franklin a chance to comment and then he started again. “This jabroni made off with thousands of dollars of the Russian’s money. It turned out to be a big joke because the Depot was not important at all in the great scheme of things. The important thing was the long reinforced runway that was to be used by SAC’s global bombers and tankers. That was really the main purpose of the Base. He didn’t know that the depot was one big excuse to build an airbase to support SAC’s War Plan. So, he was filling them up with a lot of useless information they were paying plenty to get.
“Do you want another laugh? When we told you guys
about it, you told us that you were on to him all along. You said you were
just waiting to make your move. You’re as bad as those CIA hotshots, always
looking for the credit.”
Franklin had a laugh and then he said, “all you
have managed to do with your stories is to make my itch worse.”
“I guess what I have been trying to tell you is,
that this kind of thing happens,” said Welker, starting all over again. “That
it doesn’t happen more often is what surprises me. But the Russians are always
there with their money to take advantage of the weaker ones who are disillusioned
from something or other.”
When he was thru talking, Franklin asked him if
he thought some of the money in St Ives account got there because he sold
secrets. Welker told him he did not know. But, he said, they had better find
out before the CIA did or the guy that they had grown rather fond of in the
past few days might meet with an unavoidable accident some dark night.
As they sat at their desks wondering where to start
on their preliminary report, Franklin asked him why the Russians would pay
such large amounts of money to somebody like the Colonel. Welker stalled
him with some evasive answers before deciding to tell him that it was because
of the SIOP and the command and control information he had access too.
“What exactly is that?” he said, “I have heard
you use that expression before.”
“I believe I told you that it is an acronym for
the Single Integrated Operations Plan. It is the Top Secret plan that outlines
the details of all the bomber, submarine and ICBM targets in the USSR. Any
more than that, I can’t tell you, even if I knew.
“But almost as important, is the command and control
procedures of our bombers and ICBM’s in the under ground silos and in subs
cruising around the oceans. You see SAC has bombers headed toward their targets
around the clock. They have to be stopped and turned around at some point
or there is no more Russia. Wouldn’t you like to be a Russian General and
to know where those bombers were at all times and to know and to have the
capability to turn them from their targets?”
Franklin did not quite understand, so he asked
him. “Do you mean they are actually thinking of attacking us?”
“Who knows?” He answered. “But they would like
us to think they will. But they also want us to know they can. It lets them
believe, whether true or not, that they are world players.”
“Maybe that is what Detente is all about,” Franklin
stated, with a certain finality to his voice, which meant that maybe they
ought to get to work.
“Just one more thing though before we put it to
bed,” said Franklin. “We have been kicking this two million bucks around,
thinking that his brothers gave it all to him.
“That is a lot of potatoes, pun intended. I believe
you have just started to scratch my itch. I can see for the first time why
we can’t rule out a pay-off, even if we don’t like considering the possibility.
“What I think we had better do before we jump to
any false conclusions, is to take another look,” he said.
“Another look at what exactly?” Welker asked.
“Well take that camping trip for instance. Did
you ever see anything so obviously staged in your life? Do you really think
he was trying to fool us? I think he was trying to make us think he was trying.
“Look, this investigation
had to fall into somebody's lap, either the CIA or us. And we both know where
the sharks swim. I have been giving some thought to this thing and it always
struck me as being too pat. It was always too slick, always so neatly done-up.
It seems to me, he wanted us to conclude early on that he had marital problems
and wanted to do a number on his wife and kids. Why would he want to do something
like that? I mean, why would he want us to think in that direction?”
“Go on,” said Welker, “I’m listening.”
“St Ives knew the first thing we would do was to
check the dossier on his background investigations. And he knew we would
see that he had been on the edge of divorce for years.
“He reasoned if we came to the conclusion we did,
nothing was going to happen. I mean, he knew it was unlikely we would have
done anything at all. He knew we would figure it out that what he was actually
about was only a wild scheme to cheat his wife. And if we did that’s all
there would have been to it. But if he had done nothing at all, I mean if
he had just run off with all that money, the Company would have concluded
the obvious: he was a traitor and a defector, and they would have put out
an international contract on him. Right now they don’t know a thing about
this. And when they see our report, this incident will go into their computers
as routine.”
Welker had a look on his face that said I believe
you but I don’t want to believe this of a fellow officer.
“Wait, there is more,” said Franklin. “They have
what is best described as a bounty fund. People in the intelligence community,
as they euphemistically call themselves, are aware that they will payout
large sums of money for information on defectors like St Ives. There doesn’t
seem to be any place you can hide if they want to find you.”
“Just like the Old West,” commented Welker. “They
post you to the wall of the sheriff’s office. I guess St Ives’ major interest
was to stay off the sheriff’s wall.” He chuckled to himself. But he really
didn’t see anything very funny.
“Exactly,” said Franklin. “He could care less about
us. All we represent to him is capital gains income tax problems.
“I know an easy way to confirm it all.” Franklin
told him.
“How?”
“Let’s check the bank up in Idaho again.” Franklin
said.
“Welker old buddy, I’ll bet you a dollar to a doughnut
there were two checks deposited. One came from the brokerage firm and the
other was a cashier’s check from another bank. And that second check represents
the pay-off.
“There had to be two checks because he could not
have made more than a mil from his mutual funds, in spite of what his brothers
are saying. One of our agents reports it like that, anyway. I had the Idaho
Falls’ office check on his father’s recorded Trust. And although it doesn’t
specifically state how much will be paid in each year, it does speak of a
percentage. Using this figure and the brother’s income tax returns over the
years, we think we have the figure at about a million. The Swiss are paying
about three percent so it gives him an annual income of about thirty thousand.”
“The last I heard, it wouldn’t go too far on the
Riviera,” said Welker, apropos of nothing.
“But he wanted us to believe there was no pay-off
and the two million total deposited in Switzerland was all from his mutual
funds. So the pay-off gets laundered and we report it just the way he planned.
And the sharks are none the wiser,” observed Franklin.
A week later, while they were writing their final
report, a young CIA agent walked into their office.
“My name is Jensen,” he said. “I’m down from Langley.
Doing some things in L.A. and my boss asked me to pop over here. I understand
you two are single point on the St Ives thing.
“Listen,” he said. “Let me touch base with you.
Here it is quick and dirty. Got to get the Red Eye back tonight, so I've
got to get back to LAX.
“That Colonel you’re looking for is a Russian Mole.
The skinny is, but wait, how about a little Quid Pro Quo from you guys? Never know when you can use it.”
They both were absolutely astounded at what they
had just heard. But they did not interrupt him. As they listened, Welker
could not help thinking that these Ivy Leaguer’s are all the same: cute beyond
belief. Look at him, Brooks Brother’s suit, button down collar and the whole
nine-yards. Super smart and super savvy. No wonder the Russians are having
such a hard time keeping up with them.
“You guys know by now that he was stationed at
a place called Chateauroux. Did you know he was a card carrier? Right, got
mixed up with them thru that French babe.
“That whole airbase locale was the area headquarters
of the party. Big trouble in River City; they had some real dust-ups with
our guys.
“Why more than half of the local civilian employees
were Commies. It was a bad situation. Here we are training Communists to
work on our aircraft, we even had to let them in on some classified stuff.”
Listen to him, said Welker to himself, he was hardly
born yet and he sounds like he was there. You have to give them credit though,
they are sharp and they do their homework.
“The Colonel was real sweet on her, he started
hanging around outside after the meetings just to get to talk to her. Had
big trouble with her mama. She was going to have him roughed up a little
if he didn’t stay away.
“Sweetie parlays the old “Dialectical Materialism”
with him. She thinks he is as interested in politics as he is with her. She
talks it up with the party chief who tells the NKVD or KGB or whatever they
were calling it then.
“They feel him out and then they think they have
used the persuasive power of the buck to convert him. He signs up and they
sweeten the pot. About that time he gets in touch with us. Good thing he
did or he would have spent the next ten years in Leavenworth prison, because
we had penetrated those cells and we knew his every move.
“He played along with them for the next twenty
years. He always managed to give them stuff, which had just become obsolete.
“We weren’t working him though. Like I said, he
was a Mole. The file on him says he wouldn’t have it any other way. We stayed
out of the way for a couple of reasons: we were transitioning from the OSS
in those days and we still had a lot of Frenchmen on board he didn’t trust.
Thought maybe he would be compromised and terminated. Can’t say as I blame
him. The second reason was that we didn’t understand the War Plan. It didn’t
matter even if we did; the Air Force wouldn’t let us have access to it anyway.”
Franklin interrupted him to ask if he knew about
the Swiss bank money.
“Oh yeah but understand, what information we have
we found out just a couple of weeks ago. He hired a private dick to do some
snooping around for him over in France. This guy turns up some major war
time bad feelings. And this guy with the bad feelings tells him more than
he ever expected to find out. He goes back to the Colonel. He gives him the
info he paid for and then he figures the rest is his to do with as he pleases.
“The guy who had the bad feelings had it in for
the girl’s mother on account of some collaboration with the Germans and some
squealing that went on in the Resistance. You know they got a lot of credit
for things they didn’t do. They weren’t that effective, simply because they
couldn’t get organized. The Vichy penetrated them and informed to the Germans
who shot a lot of them. There are a lot of hard feelings and accusations
to this day about who was in bed with the Vichy. Must have been a real sporty
course, if you ask me.
“Oh, you asked me about the money. Well the Swiss
PI gets in touch with us. You know it’s generally known we are always in
the market for reliable stuff.
“The French guy the dick contacts thinks he is
getting St Ives in trouble with us, kind of payback for the mother. When
he shows up over there, that’s where he is you know, the French guy calls
the PI and tells him that St Ives is not just another run of the mill tourist
and that we might be interested. The PI calls us and they both get a few
extra francs for their trouble.
“We sent one of our agents over to talk to him.
He isn’t a bit bashful, he tells us everything he has been doing. Now get
a load of this: he has been pocketing the Russian’s money and putting it
in a mutual fund along with his savings. That’s right, he has been investing
in the market a little at a time to make it seem as though he has a legitimate
reason for his growing account. We knew about it in case the IRS got snoopy.
He finally deposited the whole thing in a bank in Idaho. And then he put
it all into a Swiss account, which I presume you already, know about.
“We have warned St Ives about the French. Somebody
who we think is the French has made him. Anyway, somebody has told the Russians.
And they are going to be really mad when they find out what he has been doing.”
Agent Jensen stopped talking for a minute as he
gathered his notes. He placed them in his briefcase and then he started again.“That
production of his in the desert was not for our benefit but for the Russians.
But now it looks as though it was for nothing. Even worse, since we didn’t
arrest him for espionage, after we discovered it was a sham, the Russians
rightly surmised that he was with us all along, and not them. But he has
nothing to worry about from us. That is one of the things my boss wants you
to understand. The KGB, though, that may be something else. He also wants
you to look at putting him in the Witness Protection Program.
“One thing more before I go. When our agent saw
him a couple of weeks ago, he looked like he was under a lot of strain. He
might have been for a long time.
“Really, the quicker you get moving on that protection
thing the better. This guy is a real hero. Tell him we will support you and
to bring the girl along if he likes. And tell him he can stay in Europe if
he wants too. But tell him to get out of that part of France and to do it
quick.”
“I have a question for you before you go,” said
Welker. “How come you let people operate on their own like that?”
“Because the Russians were determined to infiltrate
certain key positions in the Air Force. Their objective was to get somebody
inside our war planning operations no matter how much it cost.
“When somebody like St Ives falls into our lap,
we have to make the most of it. We bring them along, knowing that they are
spying for the Russians.
“We ultimately work them
into a sensitive position, knowing they are going to be able to give out
information that is outdated and virtually useless for a long time to come.
And there is no way the Russians can check on it.
“Another reason we didn’t put a control on him
is because we didn’t want a double agent like in the movies. What we wanted
was to know that somebody else was not giving them information they could
use. It was just one less worry for us.
“And again, we let him go his own way, because
none of us knew what he was doing, and he was the best qualified to know
what the Russians thought they wanted.”
As Jensen shook their hands and headed toward the
door, he turned around and said, “We have always let him keep the money they
paid him. But they have probably figured it out by now that they got badly
shortchanged.
“He is really quite wealthy you know; but would
either of you care to change places with him?”
Following the defeat of the British at Dunkirk, and the surrender of the French Army, the town of Chateauroux had been talking about nothing but the new Vichy Government, which had been formed, and what effect it was going to have on all their lives.
Rumors were rampant about how the Germans had been
rounding-up Frenchmen for transport to slave labor camps in Germany. Those
who had professional and technical skills were being taken first. The skilled
and then the unskilled laborers, as might be expected followed on the heels
of these people. There was also talk about how some of the laborers were
going to the Normandy area, others were going to work on the submarine pens
at Brest, and still others on the fortifications at Pas de Calais.
The population was split on whether France should
have given up after Dunkirk without a fight. Many could remember the horrors
of the Great War and they would have done anything to avoid the carnage of
1914-1918. Still others were patriots, who would have died before they would
have allowed another German soldier on French soil.
Talk was endless on this subject. It could be heard
in the brasseries, cafés and in the market place. Wherever
two or more people congregated, there was usually an argument in progress.
Harsh words were being exchanged. Sides were being drawn up that would eventually
tear France apart and take her to the brink of civil war. Some believed,
in retrospect, that this would have happened, if it had not been for the
German occupation forces.
Some, like old Marshall Petain, the hero of Verdun
in the last war, hated the British for refusing to commit their Air Force
against the invading tanks of the German Field Marshall Geuderian. Even though
they saw the inevitability of France’s downfall and the military logic of
the British commanders in not sacrificing their Air Force for a lost cause,
they still blamed the British. Their grudge went all the way back to Verdun.
The British, in that war, had their hands full
with the Germans on the Somme and they refused to aid the French at Verdun.
The French saw what they thought was a needless loss of several hundred thousand
men. And they realized they would have lost the war, if the Americans had
not come to their relief. And now, as some of them
saw things, the British had managed to betray them again.
Why fight for England, some of them asked? Wasn’t
it England who started this war over that Polish Corridor thing? Who cared
about the stupid Poles anyway? We lost a whole generation of our young men
over that Sarajevo incident in the last one and now we are going to do it
all over again. Its insanity some said, while others berated them for their
cowardice.
But what will life be like under the heel of the
Bosch, asked some? Others answered by pointing out the progress and prosperity
enjoyed by the German people under Adolph Hitler. And they had wondered,
even before the German invasion, if the French might not be better off if
they too had a champion like him.
Still others who had joined the Communist party
and had sworn allegiance to the philosophy of Karl Marks, were not so much
interested in a National Socialist or a Free France as they were a Socialist
France.
And the loudest of all, and certainly the most militant,
were those who hated the Germans, and who were willing to back their beliefs
with action. Some were talking among themselves about forming into bands
and resisting the occupation forces now streaming into France. Many of the
younger ones were hiding-out from the Germans, who were even now, rounding
them up for transport to slave labor camps. They were waiting to be contacted
by the Free French forces they had heard about on the outlawed British radio
stations. General De Gaulle, the French commander in exile, was telling them
nightly to escape France and to join up with him in England.
Loosely formed bands of young Frenchmen had come
home after the surrender and were just standing by waiting to be contacted
and told what to do. Some would later make their way to England, others would
stay and join what would come to be called the Resistance, while still others
would make their way to the large cities and join the Maquis.
Those patriots, who stayed in France and avoided
the police and the Gestapo, were the most militant of all. The social unrest
that existed during the early days of the occupation can be laid squarely
at their feet. The pitched battles in the streets and the brawls that started
in the bars and cafes were usually started by these determined young men,
who took out their frustration on German sympathizers and their declared
supporters.
Former friends and even close relatives, in many
cases, were pitted against each other. This situation would exist thru the
duration of the war. Each side would denounce suspected supporters of the
other. The Gestapo would take hostages loyal to DeGaulle for immediate execution,
in the event of civil disobedience. And members of the Resistance, targeted
for assassination, those suspected of sympathizing with the Germans.
Marshall Petain was broadcasting daily on the radio,
telling the population to remain calm. His message was one of peace thru submission.
He called on all good Frenchmen to go back to work
and to take up their usual routines. And he told them if they did this, everything
was going to be all right. The Germans are our benefactors, he said, and resisting
them in 1914 was a mistake that should not be repeated.
He also told them he had established a new government
in the city of Vichy and that one Pierre Laval was to be their President.
Working hand in hand with the Nazi Government in Berlin, a New France would
rise from the ashes, he proclaimed.
More than half of the Nation listened to Petain
and supported him. The rest hated their former hero from that time on and
they would continue to do so for generations to come. But these people kept
their thoughts and ideas to themselves. They feared reprisal from the Gestapo
and the new Vichy police, who were working undercover throughout the country.
Thousands lost their lives to German firing squads
and to bands of Resistance fighters. Not since the Revolution, and the days
of Murat, Robespierre and the Guillotine, had the Nation seen such a bloodbath
of Frenchmen killing Frenchmen.
While the larger cities were being torn apart,
the town of Chateauroux, which was unoccupied, was pretty much going about
business as usual The cows still had to be milked and the crops harvested,
regardless of the turmoil going on around them.
Yvonne Martin was riding in her horse drawn cart
down a country road outside of Chateauroux one warm sun-shining morning.
Her young daughter Elaine accompanied her and the two of them were bringing
back cheese, wine and vegetables for the hotel restaurant. This was a monthly
trip to the farmhouses, which Yvonne looked forward too. She chose to take
Elaine with her this day because school had been suspended due to a teacher
shortage. Many of the teachers had left, supposedly to join the Free French
forces.
Her mother was grateful for the company but she
was more interested in keeping her daughter as close to her as she could
during this time of unrest. Elaine did not object. She was looking forward
to the noon picnic that she had been promised. And then too, she preferred
most anything to the alternative of working with her grandmother in the hotel
kitchen.
The two of them were chatting about nothing at
all, when Elaine called her mother’s attention to a loud deep rumble coming
from behind them. In an instant, the noise engulfed them and startled the
horse. He began to shy and pull at the reigns. It was all that Yvonne could
do to stop him from bolting and spilling the cart into the ditch that ran
between the edge of the road and the hedgerow.
She instinctively pulled the horse and cart as
far to the right of the road as she possibly could, thinking that a large
lorry was attempting to pass. She glanced out of the
corner of her eye, while fighting the horse, and there almost beside her was
a German officer in a scout car, with a column of tanks and support vehicles
following immediately behind him.
The officer motioned to one of the soldiers sitting
behind him. The man jumped from the car and grabbed the halter of Yvonne’s
horse to steady him. Then responding to the officer’s nod, he led him down
and off the road at the entrance to a farmhouse.
As the Germans passed, the officer looked approvingly
at Yvonne and touched his hand to the visor of his peaked cap. Their eyes
met for only a second but in that instant, Yvonne felt only contempt for
herself for what she was feeling.
She had a handsome and devoted husband at home,
and here this hated German, who was obviously ten years her senior, had made
her blush. This casual encounter would affect her life in a very perverse
way thru the next five years and it would become the subject of lengthy remarks
in her diary and journal.
She hated the Germans or at least she told herself
she did. And to take her mind from the incident that had just occurred, she
forced herself to think about her husband. He and his two brothers talked
about joining DeGaulle but they were not serious, she could tell. It was
not so much a patriotic gesture, as it was a means to escape the German draft.
In fact, a number of their relatives living in some of the larger cities
had already been taken into slave labor battalions.
But all they did was talk.
He told Yvonne, he did not want to leave her and the child with the sole
responsibility of the hotel. And in the end, they did nothing.
Later that afternoon, as they were passing thru
town, she saw part of the German column parked in front of her hotel. She
could not miss the scout car and she could not help looking among the armed
soldiers for the Officer. She saw him now, standing apart from the others.
And as he turned, she could see that he was wearing the epaulets of the rank
of Oberst.
A large crowd had gathered across the street. And
she was horrified to see several hundred young Frenchmen lined-up in a military
formation. As she continued to stare at the scene, she was horrified when
she saw they were being loaded into the same trucks she had seen earlier
on the road.
She drove the cart around to the stable behind
the hotel with growing apprehension. She had just started to unhitch the
horse, when Elaine came crying from the Hotel, telling her mother to come
quickly. Yvonne ran thru the kitchen and out the front door just in time
to see her husband and his brothers in the back of one of the covered trucks
that was pulling away.
As she stood in the street crying and screaming,
she vowed revenge on all things German. When the trucks left, Elaine and
some of their women friends walked her mother back inside the Hotel. She
went into her bedroom, where she stayed a full week before she came out.
It was as though her husband had died, for indeed it was the same thing,
for neither he nor his brothers were ever seen again.
Chapter 13 California, 1970
Before agent Jensen left Franklin and Welker, he gave them a letter from his supervisor to Franklin’s superior. The text of the letter recommended in the strongest terms that a representative of the FBI leave immediately for France, and that he contact St Ives and explain to him in the most convincing terms possible that his life was in extreme danger.
Jensen also gave him a dossier. It contained, among
other things, copies of the wartime diaries and journals of Yvonne Martin.
They had been translated into English and placed in narrative form for ease
of reading. There was also a synopsis of CIA involvement in the Communist
activities of Chateauroux. It covered the period from three years after the
war, thru the mid 1960’s.
Jensen told the agents that they could expect resistance
from St Ives, based on the CIA’s conversations with him a few weeks earlier.
He was unaware of the danger he was in. He thought the Russians had lost
interest in him, now that he had retired, and they believed he was dead. But
even if they had, which was doubtful, there was still a bigger danger from
another source that he knows nothing about, he told them.
“It’s all there in the briefcase, the complete activities
of the mother and why she did what she did. But the most important thing
is how it affects the life of the Colonel now.
“I don’t know which one or maybe even both of you
are going over there. However, I have been instructed to tell you that if
either the French or the Russians suspect who you are, and that you are associated
with him, then you can kiss him good-by. I suggest you read this material
before and not after you get to France.
“When you make contact, you should do it in private.
Don’t trust anybody. And don’t contact him more than once. Explain to him
why the girl’s mother had so many enemies and then get out.
“You will find some info in there about how come
he made a few himself. He probably won’t remember if he ever knew. But they
do exist and they are dangerous.
“Try to convince him that we think the Russians
have a contract out on his life. But then maybe the French will do it for
nothing. I’m not kidding. We have good reason to believe this is highly probable.
It might be a race to see who gets there first. But again, they may be working
together. The town is half Commie still; nothing has changed since he was
stationed there. Our thinking and why, is all in the dossier,” he said.
Welker thought over Jensen’s comments. And as he
began reading the journal of Yvonne Martin, he reflected from time to time
about what he had been told.
Franklin did not come with him. The FBI and the
OSI had put their heads together and decided that Welker, being older, would
pass easier for a tourist and would, therefore, be less conspicuous. Anyway,
they reasoned that fewer people would be involved, if Welker went. The fewer
the better, Welker thought, as his aircraft climbed to cruising altitude.
Just Welker and his supervisor knew what he was
doing. He had been given verbal instructions and verbal
authorization to make the trip. He had been placed on what was known as basket
leave. If anything happened to him, the leave papers would be put into the
system and both of the officers would be formally covered. Compensation for
his expenses would be paid from a small contingency fund that his supervisor
had available. This fund greatly increased the effectiveness of his unit
by decreasing response time to an emergency. Welker thought intelligence
units the world over operated this way.
Chapter 14 France, 1939
The next time she saw him was in the hall, two
days after she left her room. In spite of what he had done, she still got
that peculiar feeling when he looked at her. While she was secluded, her
mother had brought her meals to her and had told her the German had made
the hotel his Headquarters.
The Oberst knew she was in her room but he said nothing to her mother. He would later tell Yvonne he understood her feelings and that he deeply regretted his actions. The men who had been transported were on a list that was given to him by the Gestapo when he got there. That list, he said, was compiled weeks before, and was based on the reported political views of those who were detained. He realized it was not totally accurate. But he hoped that Yvonne would understand there was nothing he could have done. He was under orders, he told her, and he was being watched closely by the Gestapo. He also told her that he would have tried to do something if he had known who her husband was. What exactly he would have done, he was at a loss to say. He said he understood her feelings towards him but he could not help himself. He hoped she would in someway understand, he said. And he hoped the two of them might become some sort of friends, because they would be living under the same roof for the foreseeable future.
When Yvonne heard his remarks about a prepared
list, she immediately began thinking about the possible enemies they might
have. And she wondered who among the Vichy sympathizers might have heard
them bragging about going to join DeGaulle. She settled on one family by
the name of Duffy. They were high up in the Communist party and she believed
they were in sympathy with the Resistance only because they wanted a Socialist
government for France. But the real problem was, that a few years before;
the elder Duffy had made unwanted advances toward her. He stopped, only after
she threatened to tell her husband.
She saw the officer every
few weeks. She suspected the reason he was not at the hotel more often was
because he was out of town visiting those installations, which were part
of his responsibility. She had no idea what those responsibilities were. But
she thought that because of his rank they must be important. She also thought
several times of becoming friends with him in order to find out something
about her husband.
During one of the periods he was away, a stranger
who had been spending some time at her bar approached Yvonne. He offered
to buy her a drink. She accepted and poured a glass of Calvados for him and
a glass of wine, which she diluted with water, for herself. He paid for the
drinks and left her a large tip, which made her suspicious, because that
is the usual procedure when requesting assistance of hotel employees in France.
He told her he represented the forces loyal to DeGaulle.
And then he said he wanted to talk to her later that evening in private.
She was not particularly interested and told him so. Then he said something
that changed her mind. He said she would be interested in what he had to
say, because it concerned the whereabouts of her husband. She agreed to meet
him. She gave him her room number and the time that night she would be available.
When she opened the door to let him in, he immediately
put her at ease by explaining that he had no connection with the Resistance.
He told her what she already knew; it was tricky to do business with them,
because you might unknowingly be talking to a Vichy informer.
He explained how his organization was different.
Everyone was screened thoroughly before they were recruited and no one knew
more than two people. They knew the one they reported too and the one who
reported to them. That was all, he explained.
She asked about her husband and he fended her off
by telling her she would be told every thing he knew in good time. But before
anything more is said, I must give you a warning, he told her. He said she
must promise to say nothing to anyone regardless of whether she agreed or
refused to help them. He said that if she said anything then or ever, he
would summarily shoot her. There would be no questions and no appeal of any
kind. All she had to do was to conduct herself in such a way as to cast suspicion
on him and his activities. He went on to tell her he had no personal information
regarding her husband’s whereabouts. But if he were being held captive in
that part of France, she would be able to find out for herself. He told her
not to take the assignment if her husband was the only motivating force behind
her actions, because it was too dangerous. He told her she should do it for
France.
When he was sure she understood all he had told
her, and she had acknowledged her understanding and agreement to the conditions
as he had explained them, he began to discuss her role in the intelligence
operation of the Free French. Actually, they did not act solely on their
own. Their activities were integrated into the allied network, he told her.
Information she provided him would be supplemented with information from
other sources. It would then be integrated into a bigger picture and used
in the planning of allied operations.
He explained how it was she had access to information,
which only the Germans had. Put a different way, he said, she had access
to the German Chief of Intelligence for the southern coast of France, and
he had access to information they wanted. It was an ideal set-up, he told
her. She had a legitimate interest in her husband’s welfare. This gave her
the reason to query the German about the specifics in which they were interested.
She was in a unique position to do this without him becoming suspicious.
That is, he would not become suspicious if she followed the program, which
he said he would outline for her.
The first thing she was to do was to make friends
with the Oberst by acknowledging that it was not his fault her husband was
a slave laborer. She was to pretend she understood the officer had been placed
in a situation, which was none of his doing. She was to sympathize with him
and with the Vichy regime. And she was instructed to encourage him to talk
to her about the plans the Vichy government had for the new combined German-French
society after the war.
She was to become his friend and in due time his
lover. He of course would confide in her when next he planned to leave and
for how long he expected to be gone. This would be her opportunity to ask
him where he was going in hopes of finding out where her husband was. She
was to keep badgering him to tell her where her husband was working. And
she was to ask to be informed when her husband was moved to a different location.
She was also told to talk to him about the area where her new friend was
spending most of his time and about any personnel problems he was having.
They wanted to know who his superiors were and anything else, which appeared
to be of a routine and personal nature. Whatever she could find out from
him about anything, without making him suspicious, was what they wanted to
hear.
Later, they expected he would fall in love with
her. She was to convince him she loved him. And that her interest in her
husband’s welfare was not so much because she still loved her husband but
because he was the father of her daughter.
The Allies wanted her to eventually find out anything
she could about fortifications in the south of France. They were particularly
interested in Normandy and Point du Hoc. He said it was most important they
acquire the status of the heavy guns at Point du Hoc. This was to be her
first priority. But he told her that she was to be the judge of when she
could approach him on these sensitive subjects.
As he got ready to leave, he enlisted her in the
Free French Army. Her duties were as he had outlined them, he told her. He
would see her approximately every two weeks. When he came into the hotel,
he would go to the bar. That was her signal to meet him in her room that
night. If any one asked who he was, she was to tell them he worked for the
Vichy Government, which he said he did. She was to say that he made frequent
trips from Vichy to Paris on Government business. And because of the length
of the trip, and the uncertainty of the transportation, he often found it
necessary to stop overnight at Chateauroux.
As he prepared to open the door and to check the
hall, he told her she was walking a tight rope. The people in London had
figured it was impossible to keep her future relationship with the German
unknown to the Resistance. Yet, even though she was working in their behalf,
she was not to let on in any way. It left her vulnerable to a Resistance
assassin, he told her. But she had already figured that out.
He never came on the same day of the week and never
on any set schedule, which would draw anyone’s attention to him. When the
employees of the hotel discovered he was a Vichy official, they gave him
a wide birth. No one would gossip about him, even to friends in the Resistance.
They knew if anything should happen to him, they would be the first to be
taken hostage by the Gestapo.
When he came to the hotel, he would go to the bar
and order a Calvados. She would retire early and leave her door unlocked.
If the lights were out in her room when he came by, they remained out. If
the door was unlocked, he would slip into her room. He would receive a quick
report from her and be gone to his own room within the hour. If the door
was locked, he would assume she was entertaining the German, and he would
try again the next night.
Meeting the officer was deceptively easy, as she
knew it would be. She was a beautiful woman and he was lonely and away from
home. She asked him if it might be possible to get a letter to her husband
whom she thought might be working for the Occupation Army in Normandy. She
purposely left out all reference to the term slave labor or anything of the
kind, which might prove offensive. He said nothing at all to her. But two
weeks later, he asked to be invited to her room. He told her he had something
of importance to tell her.
This was the first of their many trysts to come.
He would come to her room on the night he came back from one of his trips,
unless she told him not too. He told her he could not get a letter to her
husband. But he said he knew where he was and that he was well. She had no
way of knowing if he was telling her the truth. But it gave her the opportunity
and the excuse to pursue the subjects allied intelligence was interested
in.
In the beginning, she suspected he might be making
up the stories he told her about her husband, in order to curry favor with
her. But as time went by, they became friends. And then their first attraction
for each other blossomed naturally into a full-blown love affair.
Elaine was the first to recognize the change in
her mother and to suspect what was going on. But she said nothing to her grandmother
for fear that a slip of her tongue might result in reprisal by the Resistance.
And then later she said nothing, because she was embarrassed and ashamed.
She looked on her mother as a traitor to France and as a wife who was unfaithful
to her husband. And she struggled hard just to treat her cordially.
But Yvonne could not help but notice the change
in Elaine. She suspected that she knew. And she came to realize her new attitude
toward her was prompted by feelings of contempt. But there was nothing she
could do about it now, not even if she wanted to. And she did not want to.
That was a big part of a growing problem with her conscience. What she was
doing was immoral and reprehensible, she knew.
In the beginning, she told
herself she was doing it for France. But that was a long time ago. She had
been doing it for herself for many months now and she liked her assignment
beyond anything she could have imagined.
Regardless of how discreet they were, the Resistance
began to suspect her. They were inherently suspicious of a situation involving
a handsome young officer and a French woman living under the same roof. But
the walls of the Catherine Wheel were old and thin and what went on behind
them was difficult to conceal for very long. An observant employee of the
hotel was soon to confirm that which was suspected. So what began as a rumor
around the town, was now common knowledge and everybody's business.
There was one Frenchman who had more of an interest
than the others. He was the father of Raoul Duffy, the young friend of Elaine.
He was the one with whom she refused to have an affair. And now the bestowing
of her favors on a Bosch officer was more rejection than he was willing to
endure. He nursed his pride for two weeks and then went to the leader of
the Resistance and asked him to do away with her.
They met in a wine cellar. They were ten in number
and were dressed in dark clothes with black berets. One of the young women
present had contacted the leader of the group, using a rather cumbersome
and admittedly dangerous method of notifying the members of the organization.
Her mother, who worked at a bakery, had received
information that afternoon from another women who worked for the railroad.
She in turn had heard it on the telegraph.
Soon after the Resistance formed, they began to
train specialists. One of the areas they were interested in was the dispatch
and switchyard office. One of the Resistance clerks, unbeknownst to the Vichy
telegrapher, could understand Morse code. It was she, who passed on the information
about a large shipment of tanks, which was being moved from the French coast
to the Eastern Front.
The Germans erroneously believed that the telegrapher
was the only one qualified, so they did not waste time encrypting and decoding
classified information passed on to the center at Chateauroux.
Each evening, members of the group would stop by
the bakery for a loaf of bread. If the bread handed them was dark instead
of the more expensive white, it was the signal to meet at a member’s basement.
The leader of the group, who owned the bakery shop,
began to speak. The tanks were coming thru Chateauroux later that night.
The plan, which had been hastily formed, was to blow the rails in the middle
of a bridge about 10 miles from the town.
Normally, in a case like this, they would have
set the charges well in advance. But tonight it had to be done within minutes
of the approach of the train and the Leader was going to ask for volunteers.
They realized that the Resistance would be held responsible. But they planned
for the Vichy telegrapher to be blamed for passing the information on to
the saboteurs.
Who else could they blame? There was no doubt about
it, he and his family and a half dozen of his friends, depending on the number
of German guards that would be killed, would be taken hostage and shot.
They had no qualms about engineering such a plan
for fear innocent Frenchmen would lose their lives. On the contrary, they
were laughing and joking at the plight of the telegrapher for being a Vichy
sympathizer. If perchance any of his friends were taken hostage, well that
was their tough luck. It served them right for being friends with the hated
Vichy in the first place, they told each other
They took great pride and enjoyment in planning
raids with a dual purpose. Not often did an opportunity come along like this,
which was worth the risk and the expenditure of the hard-to-come-by explosives.
This one was going to be fun. They would blow the track in front of the train
and the locomotive, cars, tanks and Bosch would all go careening into the
river below. As an extra bonus, they would watch the train destroy the bridge
trestle as it fell. And of course the Germans were going to have to find
another trained telegrapher.
The Leader knew better than to ask for volunteers.
He actually needed only two others beside himself. They would have all volunteered.
And they were all equally suitable for the job. He decided to draw lots.
The two picking a piece of paper with a black pencil mark were to meet him
in an hour outside of town at a designated place. They were not to divulge
who had the marked paper. Those who were not chosen to participate were better
off not knowing the names of the ones who had been picked.
He did not always go out on these sorties, as they
were called. But tonight he must, because he was the one who had the transportation.
Some of the others had vehicles but they had no fuel. Gasoline was severely
rationed and was all but non-existent for private use. He had an essential
business permit. The Germans allowed him a couple of gallons a week, in order
for him to transport flour and other supplies for his bakery.
The three of them crowded inside his small two-cycle
engine Simca truck. The Torpex plastic explosives they were going to use
were hidden inside of a sack of flour, which along with a dozen others, would
be used for the next days baking. They had never used the truck before, because
it was too conspicuous. They preferred to walk to their objectives whenever
they could or to use bicycles when that was not practical. Always they stayed
off the main roads to avoid German patrols.
They hid the truck in a copse of alder bushes about
one mile from the trestle. They made their way along the riverbank, in the
moonlight, in single file. The three of them knew the area well. They came
here often as boys to swim and fish. Many times they would go up the river
as far as the bridge to climb among the girders and to write their names
on the steel beams. There was kind of a pecking order among the boys of the
town, depending in part, on how high up the name was placed on the trestle.
This boyhood game had been abandoned a few years
back when one lad fell off a slippery girder and drowned. Since then, the
authorities posted the bridge and a stiff fine was levied against any father
whose son was caught climbing on the bridge.
But tonight the authorities were Vichy. And hopefully
they were all home tucked peacefully in their beds. As they made their way
up the girders, they passed the bundle of Torpex up from one to the other
because it was too heavy for one man to carry up by himself
The plan was to blow the rails while the train
was crossing the bridge. They could have blown the support beams below but
that would have required more explosives than they had. They chose to climb
the bridge rather than to approach from down the tracks, because the Germans
had sentries posted at either end of the bridge.
They knew from observing
the sentries that they were required to inspect the track every hour and
just before the train arrived. The idea was to wait until the sentries made
their last inspection before climbing over the solid guardrail. When the
two sentries met in the center of the span, they would exchange a few pleasantries
and then move off rapidly. The last thing either one of them wanted was to
be caught on the bridge at night with a speeding train bearing down on them.
They could have shot the guards as they talked
but this would have required them to carry Sten guns, which was their weapon
of choice. Handguns in the dark were extremely inaccurate and required a
great deal of skill at any time.
Rifles and Sten guns were too heavy and cumbersome.
And anyway it was just too risky. A patrol or somebody who would have reported
it to the authorities might hear the shots. In general, saboteurs preferred
stealth to violence and avoided the latter whenever possible. The main reason
though, was that the guard on the end where the train was approaching was
required to actuate a signal. The signal was studded with reflectors and
could be seen by the locomotive engineer and by the guard riding on top of
the first car behind the coal car. If the signal was not in the horizontal
position, as the train approached, the engineer pulled the steam lever to
the off position and applied the brakes in an emergency stop procedure.
They could see the two sentries’ faces as they
lit cigarettes from one match. The leader thought to himself that one of
them was hardly more than a boy. The Eastern Front must be taking a terrible
toll on the youth of Germany. Just like Verdun in the last war, he thought.
They turned and began walking back to their respective
posts at either end. The leader waited until he had counted to fifty and
he could no longer see the glow of their cigarettes. He then touched the
shoulder of the man lying beside him and the three of them crawled over the
guardrail onto the tracks.
They figured they had less then twenty minutes
to set the charges and to climb back down. This type of operation would have
been all but impossible a few months ago. It would have necessitated the
stringing of wire back down the trestle and hooking it up to a magneto detonator.
There just would not have been enough time. But they had recently been supplied
with a pressure type detonator that was secured to the top of the rail. When
the locomotive made contact, the rail and the wheel were destroyed.
Ironic he thought, but he had heard German engineers
specifically designed this device for destroying Russian trains on the Eastern
Front.
The leader was the first to begin the climb back
down the girders. He observed that dew had begun to form and the steel was
beginning to get slippery. He whispered to the others to be extremely careful.
But careful or not, when the party was nearing the bottom, the top man on
the girders slipped and fell to the riverbank below.
Although he had broken his leg and injured his
back, he had the presence of mind not to cry out. The others, seeing his
predicament, hurriedly put a makeshift splint on his leg, using their belts
and a piece of driftwood. They carried him about three hundred yards back
toward the truck when they had to stop and rest
They were discussing what to do and as they sat
there they heard the locomotive and almost at the same time a loud explosion.
They heard, but they could only imagine, the spectacular sight of the mass
of steel that was pummeling into the river gorge. The sound was deafening
and it seemed to go on forever. But under the circumstances it was of only
passing interest.
They could not wait any
longer. They expected the guards might have already notified their command
post. And they realized that patrols would soon be coming along the riverbank
to search for them and to look for survivors. They were exhausted. The climb
up and down the bridge, and the energy expended in carrying their companion,
had left them fighting for breath. What should have been a time for a brief
moment of relaxation and a glass of wine was in reality a time of confusion
and near panic.
The leader stated the obvious; they could not carry
him back to the truck. If the patrol discovered the truck before they could
get there and drive it away, they would all be caught. The only solution
was to hide him. They would make him as comfortable as possible under a blanket
of leaves and driftwood and hope the German patrols would overlook him in
their haste to reach the bridge.
The leader explained the situation to the injured
man. They would return for him the following night when things quieted down.
What he failed to say was that guard dogs would surely accompany the German
patrols.
If the Germans missed him in the dark, they would
find him the next morning. They would scour the area from the truck tire
tracks to the bridge looking for clues. The three of them realized there
was little hope of him not being found. But there was little to be gained
by talking about it further.
A notice was published in the Town Square two days
later. It listed the names of the three saboteurs, the telegrapher and his
wife, and a number of others who were to be shot for wrecking the train.
It stated that the execution was to be carried out within the next forty-eight
hours.
Raoul Duffy was beside himself.
He had no idea about what to do. The man who had broken his leg had been
tortured by the Gestapo and had identified Raoul’s older brother and the
baker as his accomplices.
All he could think of was
to ask Elaine if he could talk to her mother. He tearfully explained to Yvonne,
the circumstances of his brother’s plight, of which she was already aware.
He asked her to prevail on her lover to intercede. Yvonne acted as though
she was shocked at the boy’s remarks. She suspected the entire town knew
and had for some time. But now she was forced to admit she had no more secrets
from herself, more importantly, she had none from Elaine.
She dismissed the boy, telling him that he and
his friends did not know what they were talking about. She would have liked
nothing better than to have been able to help him. But if she had tried,
she would have had to admit that she was in sympathy with the Resistance.
And now more than ever she feared for her life and the life of Elaine.
Elaine recognized the situation her mother was
in and held the Duffy family at least partially responsible. This was the
beginning of a life long feud between the two families that was fed by the
events of what was to happen next, she told her diary.
Yvonne reported to her Contact that she was now
sure the Resistance knew about her and the officer. He told her not to worry,
that everything would be taken care of.
One of the women who worked for Yvonne was a relative
and a close friend of the Duffy’s. Yvonne did not know the woman had been
spying on her and that she had been talking to the Resistance about her and
the German. But her Contact knew thru his information sources and a few days
later the woman was found shot. The town’s people were at a loss to understand
why she had been killed; she had no apparent enemies that anybody knew about.
But young Duffy and the Resistance knew what had happened and why. They saw
it as a clear signal to leave Yvonne alone, which it was meant to be. But
Yvonne knew who was really responsible. She knew it was not a signal from
the Vichy or the Germans, as the town supposed it was. But for the rest of
his life, young Raoul blamed Yvonne, and by association her daughter, for
being the cause of the death of the women and his brother.
Yvonne was racked with guilt over these events
and others that were to follow. Often when the Gestapo took a hostage to
insure compliance with a civil directive, or as a warning to the Resistance
to cease and desist in their sabotage activities, she was asked by some one
to intervene. She never honored any of these requests, although she believed
she might have succeeded, because by now the officer was willing to do almost
anything for her. And the Gestapo, who also knew of their relationship, would
have honored any personal request he might have made. Truth be told, the Gestapo
never cared that much about whom they took hostage and later shot, just so
long as they shot someone, as an object lesson to the others.
But Yvonne could not afford to show preferential
treatment to anyone. She could not save them all, so she never tried to save
anyone. This made perfectly good sense to her. But it made many enemies among
her former friends.
As time went by, the Oberst became more and more
enamored of Yvonne. And she had become more in love with him. He reported
to her one day that her husband had fallen ill and had died of natural causes.
She did not want to think about what the definition of natural might mean.
She did not want to think about the pain and suffering he might have endured
at the hands of her lover’s countrymen before he died.
She mourned her husband’s loss, to be sure. But
not nearly enough to assuage her own conscience and not nearly enough to
satisfy Elaine or her grandmother. Even after the war, when they were made
aware of the truth behind her war time activities, they never completely
forgave her for forgetting her husband.
The Oberst planned to divorce his wife after the
war. A few months after the death of Yvonne’s husband, he proposed marriage
to her and she accepted. This was known only to her and to her diary, which
she intended to leave to Elaine. Her acceptance filled her with more guilt,
which she sought to lessen with the thought that she was confessing to Elaine
of her indiscretions and frailties.
During one of their meetings, he took Yvonne into
his confidence. He poured out his feelings about his distaste for the Army.
He told her how, as an officer, he had been obliged to join the Nazi party.
And he told her how badly he felt about the loss of life, which had occurred
as a result of their occupation. He said that he sided with the French against
the Vichy Government. He also told her of the sadness he felt, because of
the damage to the relationship between her and her daughter, which he realized
he had caused.
As the war began to wind down, and the German forces
acknowledged privately that they were fighting a war they could not win,
many of them felt like confessing to somebody. The officer looked to Yvonne
for forgiveness and restoration of his peace of mind. He was probably a good
man, she reflected to her diary, but he was one of countless thousands, which
were caught up in the insanity of the times.
But Elaine knew nothing
of his feelings, and she would not have been as forgiving as her Mother was,
even if she had known. She held the Germans responsible for the death of
her father and her uncles. And there was another Frenchman that was not interested
in forgiving any repentant Germans or collaborators either; his name was
Raoul Duffy.
As time passed and the Invasion became more eminent,
the Oberst’s problems increased. This was due to a marked increase in sabotage
throughout the geographical area of his responsibility. His superiors in
Berlin looked to him for an immediate solution to the problem. When he was
unable to provide them with even a plan to stop the destruction of goods
destined for German factories, he was threatened with transfer to the Russian
Front. He had explained to her how court martial and demotion had been the
common solution to these kinds of problems in the early days of the war.
But as the problem escalated, they began to threaten those they viewed as
incompetents with transfer to penal battalions, and then to units on the
Eastern Front. This unjust pressure made him more disillusioned and made
him even more receptive to Yvonne’s promptings for information. If he ever
suspected her of spying against the Germans, he never said. And if he had,
by that time, she was confident he would never have turned her over to the
Gestapo.
She became more brazen in her questioning. She
still had not discovered whether the heavy guns at Point du Hoc had been
installed and she was receiving a great deal of pressure to find out. It
was during one of the times they were alone together; she asked him if he
thought German forces could stop a major landing if it came at Normandy and
Point du Hoc? He told her not to worry. He said the Invasion was coming at
the shortest distance across the channel, either at Pas de Calais or at Dunkirk,
as it had once before. That area was not his responsibility. He was in no
danger of being transferred to the Eastern Front on any trumped-up charge
of negligence in that sector, he told her.
She began to play a game with him. What if they
decided to come at Normandy instead of Pais de Calais? Could we stop them
from just walking up the beach? What is at Point du Hoc that could stop an
invasion fleet? He responded by telling her that he had seen over a dozen
heavy field pieces with heavy fortifications on top of the bluff at Point
du Hoc. That, he said, would be sufficient to sink any capital ship before
it got within firing distance of the shore. So he said, she could put her
mind at ease on that score.
There will be no Invasion, he said. The Allied
forces will not attempt such a foolhardy operation. Why should they, their
airpower is systematically destroying Germany and her capability to continue
the war. She did not agree with him, although she did not say so. She believed
they would attempt it in order to stop the Russian forces before they could
occupy all of Europe.
We will both survive this war. You can sell the
hotel or lease it as you choose. We can go back to Germany to an area untouched
by the war. My family has money in a Swiss bank that will allow us to live
comfortably until things return to normal, her diary read.
Yvonne reported to her Contact that the heavy guns
were in place at Point du Hoc. And she also told him that the Allies could
expect heavy casualties unless they were silenced.
Her diary went on to tell how her German officer
was relieved of his duties within hours of the Invasion. He was one of a
number of high-ranking intelligence officers who were blamed for not determining
that the Invasion was coming at Normandy. He was subsequently reduced to
the lowest commissioned grade and assigned to a forward rifle company. He
never survived the war but was killed a short time later. One of his friends
wrote her a long letter explaining the circumstances. His friend berated
the system, and in doing so, he told her that it would not have made any
difference what the Oberst had reported. Nothing he could have said or done
would have made the slightest difference in the outcome of the Invasion,
he wrote, because Adolph Hitler and the high command had made up their minds
it was coming at Pas de Calais.
His death affected her far worse than the death
of her husband had. This did not go unnoticed by Elaine and her grandmother.
Nor did hotel personnel who were eager to report it to the Resistance overlook
it. Without the support of the German, she was now in real danger.
The months that followed were a terrible time for
Yvonne. She was in deep mourning for her lost love, plus she was in mortal
fear for her life, and the life of Elaine.
She was receiving threatening letters from former
friends. And to make matters worse, the Germans had moved out of the hotel
leaving her with no way of replacing the lost income. On top of it all, Raoul
Duffy was making Elaine’s life miserable by telling her that her mother was
a traitor to France, and that her mother was on a list to be killed by the
Resistance. He taunted her by asking where her mother’s benefactor was now.
He told her over and over that the Vichy police could not save them.
With her German lover dead, and the Invasion landings
at Normandy a reality, Yvonne’s usefulness to the war effort had come to
a standstill. She never saw or heard from her Free French contact again.
She confided to her diary that the reason she was not acknowledged for her
sacrifices was because she had given Allied Intelligence erroneous information
about the guns at Point du Hoc.
The Americans believed her reports about there
being heavy artillery encased in fortified bunkers on the top of the bluff
overlooking the sea, which was a scant few miles south and east of the Normandy
beachhead. She was later told that the sixteen-inch guns from the battleships
had scored direct hits on the bluff during the opening salvos of the Invasion.
But the Americans could not be sure they had silenced all of the German guns,
or if in fact if they had silenced any of them.
A battalion of Special Forces infantry climbed
the cliffs. They expected to find the guns out of action and the defending
Germans in route or too stunned by the shelling to resist. What they found
was resistance in force. The Germans lobed grenades down on top of them and
cut their grappling lines. Men fell off the lines on top of those below.
And those that gained the top were machine-gunned and fell on those waiting
their turn on the ropes. Only through outstanding leadership and an exemplary
display of courage, did they finally secure the bluff, but not without a
tremendous loss of life.
When the Americans finally secured their objective,
they took the remaining Germans prisoners. They then saw to their horror
that the highly touted artillery was in place, all right. But the guns were
not real; they were mock-ups. They had been fashioned out of wood and colored
artillery gray to fool the French Resistance and the American reconnaissance
aircraft.
Her supposedly first hand information from the
Oberst had been passed on to Allied Intelligence, by her Contact. And it
corroborated what the Allies had been erroneously told by the Resistance.
She was left to wonder for the rest of her life, if her German lover had
been using her all along for just that purpose. Had she been set-up? Did
he know for sure whether the guns were real or was he just going by what
he saw from a distance, as had the French?
He was Chief of German Intelligence in that area
or at least that is what she had been led to believe. How could he have not
known? Did he concoct an elaborate ruse to use her when she approached him
requesting information about her husband? Was her Contact actually with the
Free French or was he loyal to the Vichy? And was he working hand-in-glove
with the Germans? Was he a double agent, working for the Free French but
actually passing on intelligence to them from the Germans and pretending
all along that it came from Yvonne?
Yvonne stayed awake many nights after the Invasion
and her lover’s death, trying to determine the answers to these and other
questions. Because, if he was using her to feed false information to the Allies,
then there was a very good chance he had been using her for every thing else.
Did he really love her? Had this very important part
of her life; the part that was filled with the fondest of her memories; those
that she wanted to savor for the rest of her days; had it been nothing but
a sham?
How could he have done this to her? Was he a kind
and generous man, whom she intended to take as her husband for the rest of
her life, or was he a Nazi officer, who was the personification of the stereotypical
Bosch monster. Yet, why should she be so quick to judge him? How could she
have made a mistake like that? How could she have been so mistaken about
his professed love for her? Was it nothing but pure
lust? Why did he have to propose marriage? And why did he have to lead her
on about his true feelings for her and the French people? This was not necessary,
if his main purpose had been to use her as an agent for his organization?
Of one thing she was certain, he knew the exact
status of the gun emplacements on the Normandy coast. But did her love for
him make her willing to accept without question anything he told her, including
the whereabouts and the physical condition of her poor husband?
She would always hold herself partially to blame
for the loss of life at Pont du Hoc. And her relationship with her daughter
would never be quite the same again. But all in all, she comments in her
diary, compared to millions of others, the war left her life relatively unscathed.
But it left her forever wondering about the sincerity of her one true love.
And this would cloud her memories and never give her peace of mind again.
As the Allied Armies approached Chateauroux from
the south and from the west, what few Germans were left in the town simply
vanished. Officials who supported the Vichy Government left close on their
heels. Those who left early survived to live out their lives in another part
of France. Some of the more notorious that were responsible for assisting
the Germans in the execution of their innocent countrymen were hunted down
and tried as war criminals. Still others, who waited believing they could
ride out the aftermath of the war under the benevolent protection of the
Americans, lost their lives to lynch mobs, which were comprised mostly of
former Resistance fighters.
Women who had collaborated or fraternized with
German soldiers, found their names on a list prepared in advance of the departing
Vichy. Round up of these people by mobs of revenge seekers, and just plain
revelers, who were drunk on anticipated victory, was swift. They were unceremoniously
and rather roughly marched to the Town Square where they were made to stand
in a group in full view of all their relatives and former friends. When all
of them were assembled, they were made to kneel while their heads were shorn.
This was done with a great deal of catcalling and hooting and hollering,
which added to the discomfort of the victims.
Yvonne Martin was on this list. Her nemesis, the
elder Duffy, saw to that. When her time came, the roar of displeasure from
the unruly crowd grew in intensity. Duffy was offered the shears and as he
stepped forward and grabbed Yvonne's head, Raoul, who had been allowed to
accompany the mob, cried out to his father to let him do it. He was handed
the shears to loud cheers of approval.
Yvonne would write in her diary that night how
the whole scene was reminiscent of the guillotining, in the days following
the Revolution. Raoul Duffy had the zealous look of approval of a young Madame
Dufarge, she wrote.
From the outset, Yvonne was considered to be as
guilty as the rest. No one believed she was acting for France; she just enjoyed
it too much. If she had done what she did for France, as she said she did,
then she got what she deserved for letting the German dupe her. And if she
had done it for love, no one felt sorry for her, including her family.
It took Welker the better part of an hour to read
Yvonne’s diary and journal. And another ten minutes to read the CIA’s appraisal
of the problems that might be encountered by those who were negotiating for
the building of the Depot in 1950. There were a number of them. All of them
required a solution before the project could be started. And many of them
had their roots in the politics of the war, which soon became evident to
the reader of her diary.
The major hurdle was securing building permission
from the French Government. This could be accomplished with money. But in
no way did it address the issue of how to overcome the objections of the
town’s citizens. Chateauroux was chosen for its location and accessibility
to France’s railroads. But preliminary studies did not take into consideration
that it was also the Headquarters of the Communist Party in that area and
it had been since before the Second World War.
The CIA recommended dealing exclusively with the
local head of the Party. They realized he would take his marching orders
from the Soviet Union. But an all-out effort must be made, the report read,
to persuade him that it would be more to his personal advantage to side with
the Americans than it would be with the Russians. The CIA saw no advantage
in requiring him to quit the Party. On the contrary, it would be better if
he stayed where he was.
They first thought about
offering him an out-and-out bribe. But their final recommendation was to
offer him a highly paid job with a lucrative salary and an opportunity for
advancement. This was settled on as the cheapest and best option.
The report mentioned the name of Duffy as the head
of the Party. It also mentioned the name of his son, whom they recommended
be given a job as well, to secure the cooperation of the father.
According to a profile analysis of the two, neither
had been much of a success in life. They were just getting by. The Party
was giving the father a small stipend while the son had a small delivery
business, which afforded him a frugal living while allowing him to pay his
debts. The probability they would consent to work for the US to get the Depot
approved was excellent. They recommended the two of them be hired immediately
as “consultants.” Their employment should be kept confidential, the report
said.
Welker skipped the next two years, to the part directly
involving St Ives. He read where there had been trouble brewing from the
beginning between the enlisted personnel and the young men of the town. There
were not that many good places off-base for the airmen to go in there off-duty
time. Unfortunately, the same places were the haunts of the French, who usually
outnumbered the Americans. Besides culture and nationality, there was the
problem of divergent political views, and also resentment that the Americans
had interrupted the routine of their lives. There seemed to be no consideration
given to the fact that having the Americans in their town meant jobs and
prosperity.
It started as name calling in bars. Then it erupted
into scuffles and isolated brawls. Then the French in large organized bands
began roaming around the town seeking out and assaulting smaller groups of
airmen, who were apparently minding their own business.
The CIA suspected the Russians were involved. If
enough trouble with the locals could be fomented, then public opinion nationwide
might be brought to bear to have the Depot shut down.
Several meetings were held with the mayor and a
committee of prominent businessmen. Duffy was there as an observer but he
was expected to speak for the Americans. St Ives represented the Air Force.
After an hour or so of finger pointing, they formulated what they thought
was a workable agreement. But it was not practical, not as long as the KGB
was allowed to roam freely among the local party members, keeping them in
a continual state of agitation.
The Director of Maintenance
of the Depot called Duffy into his office. He told him in no uncertain terms
that he was dissatisfied with his efforts to keep the peace. And if there
was any more violence that could be directly attributed to members of the
Communist Party, he told him, he and other key personnel in the maintenance
organization would be discharged.
Nothing changed, if anything it got worse. Then
the situation in the town erupted. A large group of airmen, who were tired
of being bullied, banded together and invaded a bar where Party members were
known to congregate. A pitched battle that followed spilled out into the
street and ended up in a major riot. The French were badly beaten, with some
of them having to be taken to the emergency room of the hospital.
The incident received press coverage throughout
Europe and the United States. The French Government in Paris realized for
the first time that they had been dragging their feet when a major investigation
was called for. They were severely criticized for not acting sooner when
the local police first made them aware of a potential problem. And enemies
of the Communists in the Parliament called for the removal of all French
Communists from the American base. There was much posturing and speech making.
But in the end nothing was done.
Behind the scenes, the French realized they must
have a sacrificial lamb in order to assuage the hurt feelings of the American
public. They were at a loss to understand how the French could be so inhospitable
to the American Air Force, especially when the French owed them so much for
their involvement in the past war.
An investigation by a combined team of locals, nationals,
and the Air Force was made. St Ives again represented the Air Force. He singled
out the Duffy’s as the principle troublemakers. That was the formal charge
levied against them at any rate. But be that as it may, in reality they had
become a liability. They had stopped representing the interests of the Air
Force soon after the Depot was in operation.
The fall-out ended up being
little more than the mayor recommending dismissal of some of his political
enemies. At the Air Force’s insistence, he included the Duffy’s as well.
Others of the ringleaders, who did not work for the Air Force, were given
strongly worded letters to either keep the peace or risk going to jail.
The report was signed and
hailed as still another example of old friends joining together in the spirit
of camaraderie, which had prevailed thru two wars. The bonds of friendship
were stronger now than ever they had been, ran one editorial.
The corrective action taken was a success. It was
not because of anything they did. But it was because the French were so badly
beaten-up that they wanted no more fist fighting with large groups of young
American airmen.
The Duffy’s held St Ives
responsible for the loss of their jobs. They had become accustomed to the
good life and now it was gone and they vowed vengeance on St Ives.
Welker looked for an update of the intelligence
synopsis and found it as a written report by the agent who had recently interviewed
St Ives in Chateauroux. He stated that he suspected the Frenchman, the one
the Swiss detective had contacted, and who had voiced such a hatred for Elaine
and St Ives, was in fact Raoul Duffy. And if his suspicions were correct then
St Ives could be in real trouble.
When Welker finished, he thought how lucky he was
to be an American. But when he returned to the business at hand, he had a
greater appreciation for the counsel agent Jensen had given them about doing
something fast to get St Ives out of Chateauroux.
When Welker arrived in town, he went directly to
the Catherine Wheel and rented a room. He made no effort to contact St Ives
or to draw attention to himself in any way. He asked
the concierge if any of the Martin family still lived in the area. He made
it sound more like a comment than an inquiry. He told her he was a tourist
and that he had been stationed there years ago. He commented about how he
had liked the town and the food at the hotel as an excuse for asking about
the Martins.
They exchanged some more pleasantries and then
she told him Yvonne had died and that Elaine was living in town. She told
him that Elaine had married and a number of trivial things of which he was
already aware. But when she mentioned Elaine’s name, in passing, he said
it over in his mind a few times to commit it to memory.
He found her name in the telephone book and called
the number from a telephone outside the hotel. Her son answered in English
and told the agent that his mother was not at home.
Welker introduced himself to the Frenchman. They
chatted amiably for a while after Welker told him he had business with the
Colonel. Then on the spur of the moment, he told him what he was doing there.
Her son was astounded by what he was hearing. And he was hearing it for the
first time, the agent could tell.
Then Welker asked him to get in touch with St Ives
and to have him come to his room later that night. But before he hung up,
he asked him for his name and then he gave him his phone number at his office
in the US. He told him to get in touch with him, if any life threatening
accident happened to either St Ives or to his mother.
He said that if something did happen, he could
provide the police with enough evidence to point the finger directly at Raoul
Duffy. Either Raoul would have been acting on his own, or the Russian Secret
Police would have hired him, he told him. The young man was becoming angry
at what he was hearing and he wanted to know what could be done about it
before his mother became involved any further.
Welker said he did not know. At any rate, he told
him, he was a visitor to his country and that he was there strictly to warn
and to advise the Colonel. He said the he was sure St Ives would want to
sit down and have a long talk with him after they had discussed the problem.
Later that night, St Ives called. He agreed to
meet with Welker but not at the hotel. He told him he did not want to be
seen there, because the concierge and most of the employees were Party members,
he said. St Ives suggested he walk to a small cafe about two blocks away.
He gave him the name and the directions and told him it was closed for the
night but the owner, who was a friend of Elaine’s, would let him in.
They met a half-hour later. The owner directed
him to a table in the back where St Ives was waiting. She set out a bottle
of wine and some bread and cheese and then left them alone while she went
to clean up.
Welker began by telling him he was in extreme danger.
He said, “you know the CIA has it on good authority that a Frenchman told
the Russians who you are weeks ago. We suspect them of putting a contract
out on your life.”
“I wasn’t aware of it.”
He said. “I was under the impression they believed I was dead. That is what
the newspapers in the US said and I figured it was reported to Moscow that
way.
“But if some Frenchman has recognized me and told
the Communist Party I’m here, then it might be a different story altogether.
But I don’t think the Russians are mad enough to kill me, even if they believe
I’m alive, and I’m sure no one in town remembers me after all these years.
And anyway, what do these people have against me?”
Welker continued his story, in an effort to convince
the Colonel he was in danger. He covered the war time role Yvonne had played
in the history of the town. He emphasized the part about young Duffy blaming
her for the death of his brother. And he told him why he blamed Elaine as
well. Not only because she was Yvonne’s daughter but also in his grief, he
believed Elaine could have had more of an influence on her mother than she
did. Then too, he felt helpless and just needed to blame somebody, Welker
told him.
St Ives recognized the logic in all he was told.
But he still did not understand why Raoul Duffy hated him so. Yvonne and
Elaine yes, but why him? Not until Welker spent another fifteen minutes or
so refreshing his memory about the trouble that they once had in Chateauroux,
did he understand?
To make his point even clearer, Welker told him,
“it was not only the loss of their livelihood when they were discharged but
it was the loss of respect, which had caused them to harbor a grudge against
you all these years.
“ When the Americans hired Raoul’s father, he became
a somebody for the first time in his life,” he said. “And when you let him
go, he really was nothing more than a Communist flunky after that.”
Welker ask him if he remembered the violence, which
had been part of the early Depot history?
St Ives replied that he did.
St Ives then remarked, “I remembered at the time
how the almost exact same thing happened in Los Angeles during the war. I
was overseas at the time. But I remembered reading about it in a British
newspaper.
“Hundreds of young Mexicans, who were for the most
part in the country illegally and not eligible for the military draft, had
formed into gangs. They were referred to as Zootsuiters, after a peculiar
style of dress. They stood out from everybody else, because of their pegged
trousers and long suit coats and exceptionally wide brimmed hats. Their attire
clashed with most of the rest of the young men who were in military uniforms.
“They formed into gangs and called themselves the
Pacheco’s. They roamed the streets of Los Angeles assaulting individual soldiers,
sailors and marines. This went on for months until a Marine battalion; scheduled
to go overseas to combat went into the city one night en masse.
“The marines and the army uniform of the day had a wide leather belt with a large brass buckle. These young men were famous for removing their belts when in trouble and winding them around their hands with the buckle swinging at the end. It was a formidable weapon, indeed.
“Well, to make a short story even shorter, dozens
of marines went into the known Pacheco hangouts and assaulted anybody wearing
these peculiar clothes. The idea apparently caught on, because the next night
and the next, soldiers and sailors joined them. They went marauding all over
the city; beating-up on anybody dressed in a Zootsuit. The Pacheco’s finally
got the word. And like the communists in Chateauroux, they found something
else to do in their spare time besides harass servicemen.
“Anyway,” St Ives said,
“we don’t have much time left. The owner is going to want to go home and
I don’t want to be seen with you on the street. What exactly do you want
me to do?”
“We want you to borrow a car and you and Elaine
leave here tonight. We want you to take her to some place out of town where
she will be safe for a couple of weeks. Then we want you to take a plane
to the States. We want you to go to this address and identify yourself. This
is the office that handles the witness protection people. They know who you
are and they will be waiting to help you. But you must remember one thing,
do not come back to Chateauroux. Not for anything, do I make myself clear?”
“Answer me one question? What makes you so sure
the Russians have hired this Raoul Duffy guy? Why don’t they use one of their
own?”
“Because there is more to this than just get-even
time.” Welker said. “It may be for Duffy but not the KGB. They want this
Duffy, because he needs the money and he hates you and Elaine and everybody
knows it.
“The way the CIA sees it happening is something
like this: Duffy kills you and then gets caught. That’s why they want him.
They want him to get caught. They will say that Duffy was acting on his own.
But during the ongoing investigation, they will let it slip out that you
have been an agent stealing their secrets. They will tell everybody in Europe
and Russia who you are. They will tell them you are an officer who has been
part of a Cold War plot for many years. They will enlarge on the point that
our goal has always been to embarrass them and to contribute to the game
of brinkmanship we both play. And they will say that this shows again why
America talks a good game but that we don't really want peace.
“By making the connection between you and Duffy,
it will get them off the hook.” Welker explained. “And in defending themselves,
they can dredge up the whole war mess again.
“And if you think the cesspool
that was wartime politics has dried-up, I mean Frenchmen killing Frenchmen,
you had better think again. For example, how about that Klaus Barbie thing
over in Lyon right now? Thousands of French Jews turned over to the Nazis
and transported to Germany were gassed. And it was all engineered and carried
out by other Frenchmen. The Russians are saying that Barbie was the perpetrator,
and that the French Government is protecting him, and that we are behind
them. Well, this is going to be more of the same thing.
“They will play this for a while and just when
it is about to run out, they will infuse new life into the story by breaking
the news that you really work for the CIA, which you don’t. But they will say you do. And then they will say the purpose
for your coming back here is to set up a network so that you can observe
and report on communist activity in the town.
“And what about Duffy? They
will use him as a patsy. They will disavow any tie to him and leave him swinging
in the breeze. They will say that he was mad at Yvonne and that you caused
him to lose his job and that’s why he killed you and on and on, adnauseum.
“Am I getting to you Colonel,” he said with an
edge to his voice?
“I got it but what can we do about it?” he answered
“Do as I have told you. If I can have your assurance
now that you will, the FBI has assured me they will go to work on the KGB.
They will start by sending them a letter thru the highest channels outlining
in detail what we have been talking about. They will try to get the contract
cancelled by threatening an immediate expose before anything happens. Then
if it does, the Russians will be left with egg on their face. That is the
one big ace in the hole we have. They will do almost anything to avoid looking
foolish on the world stage.
“We know the Russians are going to want your guarantee
you will stay out of Château roux and that you will keep what we have been
talking about to yourself. If you do this, I believe the FBI will be able
to convince them it is in their best interests to leave you alone. And as
for as that other thing goes, without them, Duffy hasn’t a chance of finding
you.
“Assuming all goes as you say it will, why do the
Russians care if I stay in Chateauroux or not? Why can’t we just buy off
Duffy and let it all go at that?” St Ives asked.
“Because you don’t understand the Russians completely.”
Welker told him. “In any deal they make, they have to believe they have gained
the upper hand. They need to get more than they give. We plan to let them
put this thing you desire so much on the table as a bargaining chip. We will
work it so they will agree to let you live here. That’s about all we have
anyway.
“And there is something else; they will think your
continuing presence here, living with the good party members and all, might
yet embarrass them someday. You of all people know how paranoid they are.
“We pretty well know that they don’t want to kill
you. It will make them look bad when we tell the world you were stealing
war plans secrets for them. You see, once we tell them what we know, they
will have lost the advantage and maybe, just maybe, they will lose interest
in you.
“Look, don’t worry. If they don’t go for this,
both the CIA and the FBI have other fish to fry. I don’t know what they are
but they have them. Most, if not all of this espionage game, is scratching
each other’s back.” Welker stopped talking for a moment as he looked at St
Ives. He had a smile on his face that meant he had won him over. But the
look on St Ives face indicated to him that maybe he had not. But what neither
was very sure of was whether the unpredictable Russians would go along with
the plan.
“All right, but I can’t leave just like that.”
The Colonel told him.
“Why not?”
“Because, for instance, I have a dental appointment
the first thing in the morning. I have a tooth that has been bothering me
and Elaine’s son Jean has prevailed on his dentist to work me in before his
first appointment. I can’t take a chance on getting it fixed when I get to
the States. And if I’m am not coming back here, when am I going to get it
done? And there are a couple of other things too.”
“All right then,” Welker said, “we will continue
to be in touch with you thru the FBI. And we will let you know the lay of
the land, Okay? But don’t mess around here. For your sake take me seriously.”
As they finished the glass of wine in front of
them, they both left a generous tip. Welker turned and asked him if there
was anything he wanted him to say to his family. He stopped short as though
he was going to be angry. And then he said, “you know so much about me, how
come you don’t know the answer to that?
“Wait a minute, there is something. You can tell
her she has won. She finally got what she has always wanted. She has gotten
rid of me.” Welker smiled knowingly, as he shook his hand and left. But he
really had no idea what he was talking about.
One month later, she was again lounging around
the house in her negligee. It was just before noon when she glanced out the
window to see an automobile with government markings pull up to her curb.
Franklin and Welker got out and made straight for
her door. They rang the bell and she let them in without hesitation.
“Mrs. St Ives” began Welker. “We have some questions
and then we have something of the utmost importance to tell you.”
“Shoot,” she said. She was still feeling high from
the last time they were there. They could hardly blame her. It was not every
day someone brings you news that all your problems have been solved and that
all of your financial worries in life are over. “Give me the important news
first and hold the questions until later,” she said, with a big smile on
her face.
“I will. But first though,” said Welker, “have
you ever heard of a place called Chateauroux, France?”
“Yes I have. Ed was stationed there some twenty
years ago. Why, what’s up? Why do you want to know?” A look of panic was
slowly creeping across her features and was beginning to replace the big
grin she had been sporting since they came in.
“Your husband was killed in an automobile accident
there three days ago.” Welker told her this with a genuine look of sorrow
on his face.
“Interpol will probably notify the local police
in a day or two. There was a fire and a problem with identification. The
son of a friend of his notified us.” The rest of the conversation was a blur
of words. She heard: car crash with a large delivery truck...round about
under suspicious circumstances…friends will make the arrangements, if you
like?”
“Under the circumstances it is better that he not
be brought back,” Welker went on to tell her.
“What friends are you talking about? Oh, never
mind, I don’t care,” she said, as she collapsed on the sofa.
She could hardly think. All of a sudden her world
had come crashing down upon her. Then a silly line from a child’s story crossed
her mind. “The sky is falling...the sky is falling,” cried Chicken Little.
And then a more serious thought replaced it. “What am I going to do? What
am I going to do?” She asked no one in particular, as she thought about poor
Mrs. Arnold.
The line from “Gone with the Wind” came to his
mind but Welker kept it to himself, as was befitting the occasion.
A shadowy figure emerged from an alley and walked
down the narrow cobblestone sidewalk. He was dressed for the cold blustery
night, common to that part of France this time of year. A light rain had
been falling for most of the day and the cobblestones were slippery, as he
picked his way along. There was no one about this hour of the night and only
an occasional automobile, with its amber parking lights on, could be seen
moving down the brick lined street.
He had planned it that way. The last thing he wanted
was to meet someone he knew. He would have had to explain to them what he
was doing wandering around the deserted streets at this hour and on a night
like this.
He was not all that sure himself exactly what he
was doing. He was tired he knew that. He had not had a decent night’s sleep
since an American by the name of Welker had called him about his Mother’s
friend. What he had told him was somewhat melodramatic, he thought. But now,
in recent days, he had changed his mind.
He had been on his way to her apartment three nights
ago. She was out of town and he was going to check-up on things and to water
her houseplants. As he drew near, he saw a large white delivery truck belonging
to Raoul Duffy, pull up along side the curb across the narrow street. He
knew who it belonged to because of the name painted on the side and because
he had seen it about town many times.
Seated beside Duffy, was one of his employees and
drinking friends. He did not know his name but he knew that the two of them
seemed to be inseparable. If you saw one of them, you were likely to see
the other. He could see them both clearly now, from the light of a street
lamp, a few feet away. They had positioned themselves so that they could
observe both the apartment and St Ives rental car parked down the block.
He moved back into the shadows of the building,
where he waited for two hours until they moved off. They were waiting in
the same place the following night and the night after that. It was obvious,
he thought, they were waiting for St Ives. But unknown to them, he was out
of the country.
This appearance of Duffy in the lorry had set his
mind to thinking. Why were they wandering around in a heavy truck? He knew
he had a small three-wheeled pick-up. Why wasn’t he using it for transportation,
as he usually did? Was whatever Duffy had on his mind in some way connected
to the lorry? It had to be.
Well, whatever it was, he had to figure it out
on his own and then do something about it on his own. St Ives was in the
States and his mother was someplace in the south where the Colonel had taken
her. And he did not expect the police to help him. He had told them of his
suspicions about Duffy. And all they managed to do was to tell him why they
had to have more to go on than what he had given them.
If you were going to murder a couple why not make
it look like an accident? And the best way to do that, he thought, was to
wait until they were together and then run into them with a heavy lorry?
And if this was Duffy’s plan, why if he had it all figured out, could he
not stop him?
Was there another way besides killing Duffy? He
did not know. But as he stood watching him, he wondered what honest law abiding
citizen would not kill to protect his mother? But would he kill to protect
the life of the American? He did not know the answer to that either.
Jean Burgoyne met his mother’s old friend the first
night he came back to Chateauroux. He liked him. In fact he liked him a lot.
But he was incensed that he had placed her life in danger. What was he thinking
anyway? He knew St Ives must have a plan. But what if he didn’t? Something
had to be done to stop Duffy. He was convinced, having read his grandmother’s,
diary, that nothing short of violence was going to dissuade him. But murder
in cold blood? Even if he could do it, he thought, more than likely St Ives
would get the blame.
He thought the two of them were planning to leave
the area. But now he was not so sure. She had telephoned him several days
ago, so he knew they were coming back. But for how long, he didn’t know.
Maybe, he thought, they would leave eventually. But Raoul Duffy was here
and now. And Jean was convinced he was going to act as soon as he got the
chance.
That is what had him out on a night like this,
playing like he was some kind of agent provocateur, which he
guessed that maybe he was. But he had a plan of his own. It was not complete
by any means. But at least it was something.
He had taken two weeks vacation from his work as
an electronics technician at a radio and television repair shop. He was going
to need the free time to do what he knew he had to do.
Earlier in the afternoon, he had entered the local
medical dental building, which housed most of the few medical professionals
in the town. He made his way into the basement and then to the furnace room.
He climbed upon the pile of stoker slack and unlatched the coal chute window
before making his way to the foyer and out again to the street.
And now hours later, as he again approached the
building, he could see the watchman talking to the cleaning woman behind
the glass entrance door. He turned away and walked down the delivery alley
toward the unlocked coal chute window. He opened it and crawled thru into
the basement. Using a small penlight with a focused beam, he moved out of
the basement to the stairs and then to the third floor to his dentist’s office.
His dentist had been in practice in this office
for years. He numbered among his patients, many members of the older families
of the town. Jean had seen Raoul and several members of his family there
before. They were not on speaking terms, so they sat across the waiting room
from each other.
Jean examined the lock on the door and then inserted
a credit card between the lock and the door. He had a kit of small tools
in his shirt pocket but as he expected, the old style lock presented no problem.
He suspected that half the locks in town were like this one. People did not
seem to be too interested in changing them: what was the use? There was very
little thievery. And what was there to steal in a dentist’s outer office
anyway, he asked himself, besides old magazines.
He moved quietly across the room to the patient’s
file cabinet adjacent to the receptionist’s desk. He opened the drawer marked
with the letter “D” and holding the penlight between his teeth, he removed
the folder of Raoul Duffy. He erased his name and printed in the name of
St Ives at the top of the X-ray Mount. He knew the chemically prepared surface
of the Mount was made to be used over again many times. And it was impossible
to tell if a name had been erased. He then placed the Mount holding Duffy’s
X-rays into St Ives’ folder. He then placed both Duffy’s folder and St Ives’
X-rays inside his coat to be destroyed later. Unless Duffy returned for treatment
at some later date, no one was ever going to be the wiser. And tonight, Jean
doubted he would ever need them again.
He left the building the same way he came in. This
was the first time in his life he had ever done anything like this and his
heart was racing. He was even shivering a little and not from the cold. But
all had gone well. He thought that maybe he had missed his calling as a spy.
Perhaps he had inherited some of his grandmother’s genes. But he did not
indulge himself in this whimsy for long, because the stakes were too high
for that.
Before he went to bed, he removed a gas can from
his apartment storage area. He filled two demijohns with gas and placed a
tight cork in each. He laid them in a packing container and placed the container
in the small carrying compartment under the seat of his street motorcycle.
Before he lowered the seat, he wrapped three pieces of long braided cotton
strips around his grandmother’s souvenir Luger, and stuffed it in on top
of the bottles.
There was a restaurant about ten miles out of town
that had special meaning for the two of them. Jean would later discover that
Duffy had followed them there many times. He had paid the manager to call
him whenever the Colonel made a reservation.
So tonight, he was not surprised to find that Duffy
was not in his usual spot. St Ives and his mother had returned that afternoon
and apparently had dinner reservations. He thought it might be some kind
of a celebration, having dinner in their favorite place, perhaps for the
last time. Whatever their reason for going out, it played right into Duffy’s
hand. If he was going to do something, Jean thought, he might well do it
tonight.
Jean had called his mother and when he discovered
she was not at home, he called the restaurant. The manager told him that
they had arrived only moments earlier.
He had more than an inkling of what Duffy had in
mind. It had come to him within hours of seeing the two of them in the lorry.
He thought there was a good chance that he would at some time and place crash
into his mother’s car at high speed and then claim that it was just another
accident. They happened all the time on the narrow slippery roads of France.
And given the difference in size of the two vehicles, it was unlikely that
the passengers in the truck would be seriously injured.
He had set about building an explosive device,
which he intended to mount under the gas tank of the lorry. He had the tools
and the know- how to construct such a device in his workshop. It could be
detonated from a distance of a quarter mile or so, using the paraphernalia
common to a toy radio controlled automobile. A good idea, he thought at first.
But then he realized that the explosive residue might be later detected and
traced back to him. Still it was almost finished and might yet be useful.
And then there were the Molotov cocktails in his motorcycle carrier compartment,
although his plan to use them was just as sketchy.
Maybe it had been a mistake to notify the police
of his suspicions. Now whatever happened, he or St Ives would be the first
to be blamed. Why not just show Duffy the pistol, he thought, and threaten
to shoot him? Would he forget about it, not likely? He would probably change
his plans, all right. But he would probably include him as one of the victims.
And now he realized for the hundredth time that he was not cut out for this
sort of thing. St Ives was to blame; he should have never come back with
his mother. They both should have stayed in the south until they decided
for sure what they were going to do.
The roads were extremely slippery tonight. He thought
it would be better if he had used his car but there was no time to go back
home. When he realized where Duffy was, he sped out of town at a dangerous
speed.
He expected to find Duffy and his friend somewhere
near the restaurant waiting to ambush them. He should have stuck by his first
plan. He should have blown-up Duffy and trusted to his first thought that
the police were not experienced enough to trace the residue. Now he had no
plan at all.
What was he going to do if the lorry was waiting?
What was he going to do if it was not? He felt panic begin to set in as he
raced down the slippery road. Then, out of the corner of his eye, about three
miles from his destination, he spotted the white lorry well off to the side
of the road. It was turned facing in the opposite direction for a quick get-away.
He was thinking that maybe he would be able to
get there before they left and warn them. They had not been at the restaurant
very long. Not long by French custom, anyway. But St Ives was an American
and he was probably in a hurry to leave?
He pulled up to the doorman without shutting off
his engine. He told him who he was and the man promptly informed him that
they had just left. He realized he must have just passed them and that they
were ahead of him now by only a few minutes. But could he catch them before
they passed the lorry?
He saw tail lights ahead but it was not the sedan.
As he sped even faster he saw the outline of the truck moving at a high rate
of speed. He concluded that St Ives had seen the truck bearing down on him
and had accelerated ahead to try to outrun him.
Jean remembered passing
a traffic circle not too far in the distance. At the rate the three of them
were traveling, disaster lurked ahead. And he sensed what might happen with
an increasing sense of panic. He slowed down as the tail lights of the truck
ahead dimmed and then faded out all together. Something had happened.
And then he saw it: first the lorry and then the
sedan. The lorry had entered the traffic roundabout directly behind the sedan
and was going too fast to negotiate the circle or to avoid the center divider.
He had caromed off the cement divider into the perimeter barrier. The sedan
had fared even worse. It had skidded on the slick bricks, which had been
placed there to slow traffic, and had overturned.
He stopped before entering the traffic circle to
avoid crashing into the wrecked vehicles. As he sat wondering what he was
going to do, he saw two passengers in the lorry dismount. They started to
run toward the sedan as if they were trying to help the injured. But he could
see at a glance, and to his absolute horror, that they were not bent on helping
anybody, because each of them was carrying a large club.
There was no time to reach under the seat for the
pistol. At any rate he was not thinking about the pistol or anything else
for that matter. He was reacting to instinct. His mother’s life was in jeopardy,
which is all that registered in his mind.
He revved up the engine and slipped the clutch.
The wheels of the bike almost accelerated from underneath him on the wet
stones. When he gained control, he was headed directly for the back of one
of the men running towards the sedan. As the man neared the car, he lifted
the club to breakout the window on the passenger side. It was then that the
motorcycle slammed into him. The impact dislodged Jean from the cycle and
drove his mother’s would be assailant into the sedan, where he died instantly
of a broken neck.
When Jean gained his feet, he was badly bruised
but otherwise unhurt. The first thing he saw was the second man attempting
to break the windshield, in an effort to bludgeon St Ives. Without thinking,
he picked-up the club from the ground and struck the man in the head. He
fell, never to regain consciousness. He then helped his mother and the Colonel
from the car. Neither was hurt but both of them were badly shaken, as might
be expected.
He was quick to see a plan in the making. It was
better, he thought, than any he could have devised. But it depended on whether
oncoming motorists, who might be expected to stop to see if they could help,
interrupted him.
He ordered a dazed St Ives to help him put the
body of Duffy in the driver’s side of the sedan and the other body back inside
the lorry. But it was taking them far too long. Any minute somebody was going
to come along and discover them. A few minutes ago, they might have explained
away the accident with two dead men on the outside of their vehicle. But
not now, anyway. Not with one body on the ground and another with his legs
protruding from the window of a car owned by somebody else.
Elaine summed up the situation, and with out being
told, moved as fast as she could to the edge of the circle. She had been
there just a few minutes, when a car came by. She stopped him and told him
there had been an accident. She told him he could not get through. And then
she asked him if he would turn around and go to the closest farmhouse and
telephone for the police and an ambulance.
Gasoline had been spilling from the sedan’s tank
and from the engine. It could be seen running toward the lorry. Jean, inaccordance
with his new plan, climbed into the cab of the lorry and pushed the corpse
aside and started the engine. He then drove the lorry broadside into the
sedan to make it appear the lorry had caromed off the barrier and hit the
wrecked sedan, killing the occupant.
He told the Colonel to leave the area. He said
he would pick him up in a minute about one hundred yards down the road. He
told him to get off the road and to stay out of sight.
He started his bike and motored over to where his
mother was standing guard. He put her up behind him and drove her passed
the wreck and out of harms way. He told her to ride back in the ambulance
when it arrived and to check into the hospital for observation. She was to
tell them that the other occupant of the sedan had been St Ives. The occupant
of the truck, she recognized as Raoul Duffy. She was told to tell them that
she had seen Duffy slumped over the wheel before it caught fire. Jean then
told her to go straight home and not to talk to anyone: this meant the press
and the police particularly. Then he told her he would see her later on in
the morning.
He went back to the wreck. He parked his cycle
on the kickstand and pulled the two bottles of gasoline from the carrier.
He removed the fuses from around the pistol and soaked the ends in gasoline.
He then placed one end of the fuses in the bottles and secured the corks.
Climbing back on his bike, he lit the fuses and thru both bottles over his
shoulder, breaking the glass against the two wrecked vehicles. Even as he
sped away, he heard the explosion and felt for a moment the extreme heat
generated by the burning fuel.
He stopped long enough to kiss his mother and then
sped down the road to find St Ives. The two of them motored back to Chateauroux.
But they did not stop, although St Ives wanted to. He told Jean that he needed
his passport and a few things. Jean ignored him for the most part. But he
did turn his head and yell loud enough for the Colonel to hear that he did
not need a passport or anything else, because he was dead.
When they did stop, about thirty miles out of town,
Jean explained to him testily, that he was indeed dead and that he had better
get used to the idea. They went into a cafe and ordered coffee with a croissant
for Jean. Then he swore at him and asked him why he came back when he was
told not to. St Ives explained that he had met with the CIA and the FBI when
he went back to the States. The CIA wanted him to work for them in France
in exchange for getting Duffy and the KGB off his back.
He told him that if he and Elaine left the area,
Raoul Duffy might in some way exact his revenge on Jean and his sister. He
believed the only way of saving them was to get rid of Duffy once and for
all and that is what he came back intending to do.
The next fifteen minutes were spent going over
his finances again. He made sure Jean understood about the safety deposit
box in the Swiss bank. And that he knew the name of the banker.
Then Jean interrupted him. And before the Colonel
could say another word, Jean told him he expected him to marry his mother.
He said he had more to fear from him than he did from France and her bigamy
laws, which he said, were quite liberal. Anyway, he told him, you are not
marrying her, you are dead. I want you to pick a new name before we leave
and that is the person who is going to marry her.
You are free to use my name, he said. It is well
respected and quite common. He then told him he was never to contact him
again or to return to Chateauroux. If you do, I guarantee I will shoot you.
I absolutely forbid you to have any more to do with spies and violence of
any kind. The tone of his voice left no doubt in St Ives mind that he was
serious.
He then gave him a telephone number of a friend.
He told him to call and leave the number where he could be reached and he
would get back with him. After the inquest and the memorial service, he would
bring his mother to him. In the mean time, he was to lay low and decide on
where he was going to make his permanent home.
St Ives was also told not to worry about the police,
because he had switched dental records with Duffy. When St Ives asked him
how he knew things were going to happen just the way they did, he was told
that he had a plan. But the way it worked out was fine too, and just as permanent,
he said.
Weeks later, the Colonel called his banker friend
from his new home in the south of France. He told him more than he needed
to know to carry on his business before telling him he was remarried. The
banker congratulated him and then told him he was glad things had worked
out the way they had. But, he said, nothing you have told me comes as any
big surprise. I understand, and if there is anything you need like a passport
or any thing else, please let me know.
After all Mr. Burgoyne, that is what Swiss banking
is all about, he remarked.
Elaine and St Ives set up housekeeping in Arles.
And then after six months of traveling around the southern part of France,
they settled for the Garonne River valley. They first chose one of several
villages but then decided that village life was too confining. They finally
bought an apartment in her name in one of the better sections of Toulouse.
It was comfortable but not too pretentious. The last thing they wanted was
to attract attention.
They had only been there a few weeks when a letter
arrived from the Swiss banker. Inside the envelope was an unopened letter
from Welker and was postmarked Riverside, California.
Welker explained how he knew what had happened.
He said he knew the complete story and that he suspected Rasmussen did as
well. But he said his secret was safe with both of them. And then he told
him that Rasmussen had supervised the settling of his estate, in accordance
with military regulations. He told him that nothing was left and that within
days his family had been forced to move to a small apartment. His wife had
found work as a waitress in a restaurant, while she was attending a local
real estate sales school. Their son had been looking around for work but
only half-heartedly, Welker wrote. He had quit school and his mother, who
was on to him, had forced him to leave her apartment. He finally found a
job at a fast food outlet. He had moved in with two other school dropouts
and was saving his money to buy a car.
Welker talked to him, although of course he did
not know who he was. He said he had confided in Welker about his intentions
to go to a remedial reading course at the local high school. He also told
him, he intended to try and get a diploma. Welker stopped by once in a while
and often talked to him. But he told him not to keep his fingers crossed
about the boy. He said he was still in shock about the major disruption in
his life. And whether or not he was going to make a serious effort to better
himself was anybody’s guess, he wrote.
The newly married spent long hours on picnics along
the riverbank and just walking and talking. He was gratified to find that
Elaine had more than a passing interest in the major events of his life.
He supposed one of the reasons might be because they shared so many of them
in common. In fact she wanted to know as much about him as he was willing
to tell her. And she was most eager to fill in many of the blank spots; particularly
those that occurred after the Germans let him escape. He wanted to find out
what her life was like during the war years. And he was most interested in
what she had been doing immediately after the war and up to the present time.
He quizzed her about her membership in the Party. And she told him that she
had become disillusioned early on and had quit soon after he left for the
States.
She was not at all reluctant to discuss her mother
and her wartime activities. They had not been talking long about this subject
when he realized she had been much more aware of things than he ever supposed.
He always thought she had been too young to be aware of much at the time.
But he was pleased to learn he was wrong.
She told him that she had always loved him. What
he thought was a young girl’s crush on an older man was in reality much more
than that. And they discussed endlessly the years when he was stationed at
the depot in Chateauroux. And all the things they did and said, they talked
over and over again. It was one of their favorite activities. And they spent
hours reminiscing about the war and the period just after.
It happened during one of their many motor trips
along the picturesque Garonne. They had stopped to sit and admire the scenery
from a bluff above the river. St Ives remarked that he recognized what he
thought was the very place where someone shot at him while he was escaping.
“Elaine,” he said, “I don’t believe I ever told
you somebody tried to shoot me from about right here.” It was kind of his
way of introducing the subject as she removed a picnic basket from the car
and spread a blanket.
“I had been floating for several days,” he said,
“when for no reason, somebody started shooting. And then when I jumped into
the river, there was a rattle of gunfire, and then all I could hear was the
water. I never knew who it was, although I have spent endless hours speculating
about the numbers of people who didn’t want me going any further.
“You told me about your mother: how she was playing
on both sides at the same time; how she was a patriot but in love with an
enemy soldier. We both understand her dilemma and I suppose we sympathize
with her. But to my way of thinking she was the only one in the area that
was privy to much of the important information possessed by both sides. Did
she ever talk to you much about what went on just prior to the Invasion?”
“Yes she did. But I’m not quite as ready to forgive
her as you are. It is true she was loyal to France. And then too, she was
never given much credit for the danger she faced, while extracting information
from her German lover. But she enjoyed it too much. I understood in a way.
But then again I viewed it as a complete betrayal of my father. I hesitate
to say this, but I considered her loyalty to him as being more important
than gathering intelligence for the Allies. She did, you know, and much of
it resulted in the savings of thousands of lives during the Invasion. She
also passed them vital information that caused many casualties but she did
not do it on purpose. As far as I am concerned she was a patriot. However,
I’m convinced the Germans were using her.
“She never told me about any of it until after
it had all happened. And then she did, because she wanted me to understand
why she was going to marry the German and move to his home. She wanted me
to understand and to forgive her. She knew how, even as a young girl, I felt
about you. She wanted me to know you arrived safely home just as soon as
she could. She had to make sure I understood. And she did want me to believe
he, so she told me the details of everything that happened to you after you
left us. I suppose it made her feel better in those dark days, after the
Liberation.”
“Elaine, did she know who was shooting at me?”
“Yes, and much more than that, she knew why.
“You see she had a promise from the Oberst that
you would come to no harm, because of the way I felt about you. He had put
several of his best operatives on you with instructions to see that you got
back. At the time, though, Mother thought he was doing it for her. They wanted
you to tell the English that you had convinced them the Invasion was coming
at Normandy. What none of us knew, excepting the Oberst, and he never told
her of course, was that they had used Scopolamine on you. Under the effects
of the drug, you told the Germans the Invasion was coming at Pas de Calais.
So you see it was most important to the Oberst that you get back to England.
”
“Yes, I realized that much later.” He said. “But
I never faulted anybody for doing it the way they did. Under the circumstances
they could not have told me the truth. And it could not have been pulled
off in any other way.”
“She told me the Oberst was going to get you back
safely to England just for her sake, because she wanted him too, which of
course was a lie. He also promised to keep her informed and she promised
to do the same for me. He kept his promise about this, I guess because it
didn’t matter to him. Anyway, I was aware of what was happening to you all
along your route.”
“Who was it that was shooting at me then?” He asked
“It was the Resistance.” She said.
“And the Germans tailing me, they shot them, right?”
“Correct.”
The two of them had been speaking in French. In
fact he spoke French all the time now. He only resorted to English when he
had forgotten a word. But this was becoming more and more infrequent. His
language skills suffered during the extended periods he was away. But he
become more fluent each time he returned to France And now these last few
weeks of talking in nothing but that language had resulted in his regaining
most of his former proficiency.
He dressed like a Frenchman and ate the same things
they ate. And he really preferred wine to soft drinks. So as they basked
in the afternoon sun, he thought he might be well on his way to becoming
a real Frenchman. Elaine noticed it as well and had voiced her approval.
“Do you know who Henri was and whom he was working
for?” He asked Elaine as they lay back looking at the clouds and listening
to the river.
“Yes I do as a matter of fact. He was a member
of the Resistance, who was taking money from both the Germans and the Resistance.
The Germans shot him when he had outlived his usefulness. If you had been
able to go on over the mountain as was planned, they would have left him
alone. But under the circumstances he knew too much and your continued journey
had the highest priority.
“How could they be so sure that I was going to
get picked up outside the estuary by a Spanish fishing boat? How did they
know that I wouldn’t drown and spoil all their plans?”
“You know the Germans; they never leave anything
to chance,” she said. “They had it arranged with the Spanish, who incidentally
were playing both sides from the middle. If the boat missed you, they had
a plan to alert one of several gunboats, which patrolled those waters. They
simply alerted the gunboat to be on the lookout for you. And when they saw
you they radioed the fisherman. They were watching you all along the way.
They knew you were in danger most of the time. But they also knew that if
you kept your head, you were going to make it to the ocean.
“How could they be so sure? I thought many times
that I was going to drown”
“Well in a way they supplied you with the boat
and they knew that even if did turn over, it would not sink. As I understand
it, the Frenchman who sold you the boat and gave you the instructions was
picked up soon after you left. He told them everything he had told you.
“The Oberst was nothing if not thorough. This kind
of stuff was what he excelled at. And don’t forget, he was telling mother
he was doing it for her, and she was telling me he was doing it all for me.
In that way, I guess, she figured I might get to like him a little better.
But I was never able to forget he was responsible for the death of my father.
And my mother had wanted to become convinced at the outset that he could
not have prevented any of that from happening. She was most interested in
convincing me he was a great humanitarian and it had all come about because
of the war. I guess it is one of the things I found the hardest to forgive.”
One week later, the two of them were sitting at
a sidewalk I overlooking the river. Neither of them was saying much. Their
marriage had matured to the point where they were very comfortable in each
other’s company without having to say much of anything. So there were now
long lulls in the conversation when they just sat alone with their thoughts,
secure in the knowledge that the other was there. St Ives had not been looking
for a topic to start a conversation; it just popped into his head, when he
asked her, “do you ever think you might forgive your mother?”
She looked out of the corner of her eye at him.
This was a subject that was sensitive to her. And she knew he would not have
brought it up just to make conversation. It did not exactly make her angry
but it did make her blood pressure rise slightly. And as a result she answered
more quickly than she otherwise would have had she given it some thought.
“Edward,” she said his name with a kind of edge
to her voice that she wished she could have retracted, “do you suppose you
will ever forgive your wife and family?”
He was taken aback. In fact he was more than that. He was caught off guard and totally surprised. He had no idea she knew he was still married. He knew Welker had written letters to both her and her son soon after he had been reported killed. In one of them, it was obvious the agent believed the story that St Ives was dead. It was a letter of condolence to Elaine, wherein, he told her how much the Colonel loved her and that he had filed for divorce before he left. Elaine naturally thought he was divorced. But she later came to realize the suit had been terminated upon the report of his death. Her son, on the other hand, knew this would happen and did not care. To him their present status was far better than living together in an unmarried state. And anyway, her son told Elaine, if things had not happened so fast, they would have been divorced, because his wife made no indication she wanted a contest. She did not